| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Department of Medicine and Experimental Oncology (P.M., C.B., A.M., A.V., F.R., F.V.), Division of Internal Medicine 4 and Hypertension, Radiology (D.R.), Surgery (C.G., G.G.), University of Torino, 10126 Torino, Italy; and Clinical Chemistry Laboratory (G.M.), Service of Clinical Pathology (G.P.), and Service of Radiology (D.G.), Azienda Sanitaria Ospedaliera San Giovanni Battista, 10126 Torino, Italy
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Paolo Mulatero, Division of Internal Medicine and Hypertension, Azienda Sanitaria Ospedaliera San Giovanni Battista, Via Genova 3, 10126 Torino, Italy. E-mail: paolo.mulatero{at}libero.it.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective and Design: The objective of the study was to test the sensitivity and specificity of the last generation CT scans, test prospectively the usefulness of clinical criteria in the diagnosis of APA, and develop a flow chart to be used when AVS is not easily available.
Setting: Hypertensive patients referred to our hypertension unit were included in our study.
Patients: Seventy-one patients with confirmed PA participated in our study.
Intervention: All patients had a CT scan and underwent AVS.
Main Outcome Measure: Final diagnosis of APA was the main measure.
Results: A total of 44 and 56% of patients were diagnosed as having an APA and a bilateral adrenal hyperplasia (BAH), respectively. Twenty percent of patients with PA displayed hypokalemia. CT scans displayed a sensitivity of 0.87 and a specificity of 0.71. The posture test displayed a lower sensitivity and specificity (0.64 and 0.70, respectively). The distribution grades of hypertension were not significantly different between APA and BAH. Biochemical criteria of high probability of APA displayed a sensitivity of 0.32 and a specificity of 0.95.
Conclusions: This study underlines the central role of AVS in the subtype diagnosis of PA. The use of the clinical criteria to distinguish between APA and BAH did not display a satisfactory diagnostic power.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The aims of the present study were: 1) to test the sensitivity and specificity of the latest generation CT scans performed and read by the same expert radiologist; 2) to test prospectively the usefulness of the clinical criteria of high probability in the diagnosis of APA; and 3) to develop a flow chart to be used after the CT scan in patients with confirmed PA, to reduce the number of patients to be referred to other centers for AVS if this technique is not easily available for all patients.
| Patients and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-blocker (doxazosin) and/or a calcium channel blocker (verapamil or amlodipine) maintained the same therapy during and for the period between the screening and the final diagnosis. The confirmatory test was an iv saline load (2 liters of 0.9% NaCl infused over 4 h) that was considered positive if posttest aldosterone levels were greater than 5 ng/dl (138.7 pmol/liter) (14). The lower limit of detection for the PRA assay was 0.1 ng*ml–1/h–1 (0.028 ng*liter–1/sec–1). The posture test was performed by measuring PAC at 0800 h after an overnight recumbency and after 2 h of standing; a greater than 50% increase in PAC levels over basal was considered a positive test result.
CT scanning (Light Speed machine; General Electric Medical Systems, Milwaukee, WI) with fine cuts (2.5 mm) of the adrenal with contrast was reported by the same radiologist (D.G.). Nodules or thickening greater than 4 mm was considered pathological. Adrenal vein cannulation was performed by the same expert radiologist (D.R.) and was considered successful if the adrenal vein/inferior vena cava cortisol gradient was at least 2 (catheterization ratio); lateralization was considered when the aldosterone to cortisol ratio (A/C) from one adrenal was at least 4 times the ratio from the other adrenal gland (lateralization ratio) or if it was 3 times the contralateral together with an A/C in the contralateral lower than the A/C in the peripheral vein (contralateral ratio CLR) (2). Most patients (65 of 70) underwent AVS without ACTH stimulation. The other five patients had ACTH infusion during AVS because the procedure was performed late in the morning. Four of five patients whose results showed they were affected from unilateral forms of PA, and APA was confirmed after adrenalectomy.
Finally, all patients with PA were screened for glucocorticoid-remediable aldosteronism using a long PCR technique (9, 15).
Among the clinical criteria we considered were age, plasma potassium levels, urinary and plasma aldosterone levels, PRA levels, severity of hypertension, and dimension of the adrenal nodule. In particular, following the criteria suggested by Young (13), we considered as suspicious criteria (high probability criteria) for APA the presence of grade 3 or resistant hypertension, profound hypokalemia (<3.0 mEq/liter), higher plasma (>25 ng/dl), and urinary (>30 µg per 24 h) levels of aldosterone, and age younger than 50 yr.
PRA, cortisol and aldosterone were measured as previously described (16).
A final diagnosis of APA was considered proven, providing that all the following conditions were satisfied: 1) histological demonstration of adenoma, 2) normalization of hypokalemia if present, 3) cure or improvement of hypertension, and 4) normalization of ARR and suppressibility of aldosterone levels less than 5 ng/dl under saline load. Cure of hypertension was defined as normal blood pressure levels without treatment; improvement was defined as achievement of normal blood pressure with a reduced number of drugs, compared with the number before adrenalectomy. All patients with a diagnosis of APA underwent adrenalectomy and had the above conditions satisfied. In particular, all patients had an ARR less than 20 after adrenalectomy and a PRA greater than 1. Of note, none of the patients displayed major complications after AVS; overall two patients had developed a hematoma of the groin that were reabsorbed in 1 wk.
Statistical analysis
All evaluated parameters are expressed as mean ± SD or median (25th to 75th percentile) where appropriate. The normal distribution of the various parameters was investigated observing the distribution of data and using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test. Values between groups were compared by the Students t test and the Mann-Whitney test. Receiver operator characteristic analysis was used to determine the test characteristics of the different variables predicting the diagnosis.
The positive predictive value of the test was defined as the ratio between subjects that were true positives and all subjects that were positive for the test. The negative predictive value was defined as the ratio between subjects that were true negatives and all the subjects that were negative for the test. The positive likelihood ratio was defined as sensitivity divided by 1 minus specificity. The negative likelihood ratio was defined as 1 minus sensitivity divided by specificity. P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Twenty-seven patients with evidence of an APA on CT scan had the diagnosis confirmed after AVS, and similarly 28 with BAH had a concordant diagnosis between CT scan and AVS. By contrast, 11 patients with an appearance of APA on CT scan (five nodules
10 mm and six > 10 mm) were found to have BAH by AVS. Finally, four patients with a diagnosis of BAH on CT scan (one with normal adrenals and three with bilateral nodules) were diagnosed as having APA after AVS. All patients with a A/C lateralization ratio between 2 and 3 did not display a contralateral A/C ratio less than peripheral and therefore could not be considered affected by APA, even with a cutoff lower than 3 as an indication for adrenalectomy. Therefore, the CT scan displayed a sensitivity of 0.87 and a specificity of 0.71, a positive predictive value of 0.71, a negative predictive value of 0.88, an accuracy of 0.78, and a positive and negative likelihood ratio of 3.1 and 0.2, respectively.
The posture test displayed a lower sensitivity and specificity (0.64 and 0.70, respectively), a positive predictive value of 0.65, a negative predictive value of 0.68, an accuracy of 0.67, and a positive and negative likelihood ratio of 2.1 and 0.5, respectively: in fact, 36% of patients with APA had a positive posture test, which is an increase of aldosterone in upright position, and 30% of patients with BAH had a negative posture test. When considered together, the CT scan and the posture test displayed a sensitivity of 0.48, a specificity of 0.93, and positive and negative predictive values of 0.82 and 0.72, respectively.
The distribution of grade 1, 2, and 3 and resistant hypertension (17) was not significantly different between the two subtypes of PA (Fig. 1
). In particular, 48% of patients with APA and 51% with BAH displayed hypertension grade of 3 or higher.
|
3.6 mEq/liter) was present in 74.2% of patients with APA (23 of 31) and 30.8% of patients with BAH (12 of 39), whereas marked hypokalemia (<3 mEq/liter) was present in 38.7% of patients with APA (12 of 31) and 5.1% of patients with BAH (2 of 39). Twenty-nine of 31 patients with a final diagnosis of APA (93%) and 23 of 39 with BAH (59%) displayed a PAC greater than 25 ng/dl and/or a urinary aldosterone greater than 30 µg per 24 h.
Eighteen of 31 patients with APA (58%) displayed a unilateral nodule of 10 mm or greater on CT scan with a normal adrenal in the contralateral side, but six of 39 patients with BAH (16%) displayed similar CT findings and therefore might have been inappropriately adrenalectomized if the decision had been based entirely on the data of the CT scan. After surgery 21 of 31 adenomas (68%) displayed dimension of 10 mm or greater, whereas the remaining 10 (32%) were microadenomas.
Considering together two or more of the criteria of high probability of APA, we observed that 10 of 31 patients with APA (32%) and two of 39 of patients with BAH (5%) had both hypokalemia (<3 mEq/liter) and high aldosterone levels (PAC > 25 ng/dl and/or a urinary aldosterone greater than 30 µg per 24 h), which are biochemical criteria of high probability of APA, and displayed a sensitivity of 0.32 and a specificity of 0.95. Considering together high aldosterone + low potassium + hypertension of grade 3 or greater, only seven patients with APA and one with BAH displayed these features; therefore, these combinations of high probability criteria show a high specificity (0.97) but a very low sensitivity (0.23). Addition of the age criterion did not result in an improvement of the diagnostic performance (0.97 specificity, 0.19 sensitivity). We also tested the combination of information from CT scan and posture test: 16 of 31 patients with a final diagnosis of APA had a diagnosis from CT scanning of a unilateral nodule and a negative posture test; 18 of 39 patients with a final diagnosis of BAH had a diagnosis from CT scanning of bilateral disease and a positive posture test. One of six patients with a unilateral nodule of 10 mm or greater on the CT scan and a negative posture test (16%) had a bilateral disease after AVS. Finally, only four patients, all affected by APA, displayed a negative posture test, a CT scan indicating a unilateral nodule, and a high probability criteria.
When the CT scan demonstrated bilaterally normal adrenal glands, 95% of the patients (21 of 22) displayed BAH after AVS (Fig. 2
); when bilateral nodules or thickening was observed, only 67% of patients (six of nine) had BAH after AVS; and when a unilateral nodule was demonstrated on CT scan only 69% of patients (27 of 39) had an APA. It should be underlined that this percentage did not change significantly when considering only nodules of 10 mm or greater (Fig. 2
).
|
All patients with BAH (39 patients) underwent spironolactone therapy: 11 of 39 patients (28.2%, two females and nine males) stopped the therapy because of side effects. All patients on spironolactone displayed a normalization or a significant amelioration of blood pressure levels after the adjunct of spironolactone to the therapy. All patients that were hypokalemic had normalization of potassium levels on spironolactone therapy. Three patients in which spironolactone was stopped for side effects and who were mildly hypokalemic were treated with potassium supplements. Nineteen of 31 of the patients with APA (61.2%) were cured by adrenalectomy, and the remainder showed a remarkable improvement of the blood pressure control and a reduction of the number of the drugs used. Overall, patients with APA reduced the number of drugs from 2.97 (range 1–5) before adrenalectomy to 0.55 (range 0–3) after adrenalectomy.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We demonstrated that under our conditions, CT scan provided useful information and was concordant with AVS in a much higher proportion (77%) than previously described (9). Interestingly, all patients with a unilateral macronodule (<1 cm) and young age (<40 yr) were found to have APA. This is in agreement with the low prevalence of nonsecreting adrenal tumors (incidentaloma) in young subjects (18) and in agreement with the recommendation of some authors that adrenalectomy be undertaken without the need to perform AVS in these patients (19) (Fig. 3
). However, the current study should not be regarded as confirmatory for such a recommendation because only five patients displayed these characteristics, and therefore, a prospective study in a wider population of PA should be performed before considering this indication as definitive. In fact, because our population includes selected patients, it is conceivable that less florid forms of PA, including normokalemic patients, may comprise patients of younger than 40 yr of age with a unilateral macronodule on CT and affected by BAH.
|
It is noticeable that in all patients with an APA except one, it was possible to demonstrate an alteration of the adrenal morphology on CT, suggesting that the sensitivity of this technique is improved when used by an expert and motivated radiologist; by contrast, the specificity of the CT scan remains low because the morphological description cannot help in determining the secretory function of the observed lesion.
We also showed that the posture test is not useful in differentiating APA from BAH because 33% of patients were not correctly classified with this test, in accordance with previous findings (2). In fact, it has been demonstrated, that 30–50% of APA respond to angiotensin II stimulation, and similarly 30% of patients with BAH do not display a significant increase in aldosterone levels after angiotensin II stimulation (20).
Unfortunately, none of the criteria of high probability for APA allows the avoidance of AVS and successfully distinguishes APA from BAH. However, patients who simultaneously display high aldosterone levels together with severe hypertension and severe hypokalemia are more often affected by APA.
Interestingly, 38% of patients with APA did not display, at the moment of the diagnosis, either hypokalemia or severe or resistant hypertension and therefore would have been missed if only these conditions were considered as prerequisite to screen the patient for PA; this is in agreement with the findings of other authors (20) and indicates that a wider application of the ARR to hypertensive patients is needed to provide the opportunity of detection and surgical cure to all patients with APA.
A limitation of the present study is that, despite the fact that it has been performed prospectively, it suffers from potential selection bias, in that many patients included in the study were referred to our centers for very high ARR and/or hypokalemia. This could explain the higher proportion of APA and hypokalemia, compared with patients uniquely screened in a single center (20). It should also be noted that whereas AVS is not perfect, it is nevertheless the best currently available way to guide therapy for a patient with PA. In fact, a small proportion of patients with unilateral secretion may be affected by a unilateral hyperplasia (primary adrenal hyperplasia) and not by an APA, but this would not change the indication to adrenalectomy. In the rare case of bilateral APA, which is hard to distinguish from BAH with bilateral macronodules, the AVS would result in a bilateral form of PA, indicating medical therapy.
In conclusion, our data confirm that definitive differentiation of subtypes in patients with PA is most reliably achieved with AVS. However, when CT scanning is performed by a highly motivated radiologist using a fine cut of the adrenal glands, AVS, if not easily available, can be avoided in some selected cases. This may be the case for very young patients with a macronodule on the CT scan and a normal appearance of the contralateral gland, in which adrenalectomy can be considered, and for patients with bilaterally normal appearance of the adrenal glands in which a medical treatment with spironolactone can be considered without performing AVS. It should be emphasized that these suggestions should be applied only to those units in which AVS cannot be performed routinely. Furthermore, in the case of bilaterally normal adrenal glands, the presence of criteria of high probability of APA (high aldosterone + low potassium + hypertension
grade 3) or the wish of the patient to have the possibility of a surgical cure definitively confirmed or excluded should nonetheless prompt performance of AVS.
| Footnotes |
|---|
First Published Online January 15, 2008
Abbreviations: A/C, Aldosterone to cortisol ratio; APA, aldosterone-producing adenoma; ARR, aldosterone to PRA ratio; AVS, adrenal venous sampling; BAH, bilateral adrenal hyperplasia; CT, computed tomography; MR, mineralocorticoid receptor; PA, primary aldosteronism; PAC, plasma aldosterone; PRA, plasma renin activity.
Received September 13, 2007.
Accepted January 3, 2008.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. J.E. Kempers, J. W.M. Lenders, L. van Outheusden, G. J. van der Wilt, L. J. Schultze Kool, A. R.M.M. Hermus, and J. Deinum Systematic Review: Diagnostic Procedures to Differentiate Unilateral From Bilateral Adrenal Abnormality in Primary Aldosteronism Ann Intern Med, September 1, 2009; 151(5): 329 - 337. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. Born-Frontsberg, M. Reincke, L. C. Rump, S. Hahner, S. Diederich, R. Lorenz, B. Allolio, J. Seufert, C. Schirpenbach, F. Beuschlein, et al. Cardiovascular and Cerebrovascular Comorbidities of Hypokalemic and Normokalemic Primary Aldosteronism: Results of the German Conn's Registry J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., April 1, 2009; 94(4): 1125 - 1130. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
F Morello, D Schiavone, G Mengozzi, C Bertello, C C Liew, D Bisbocci, P Mulatero, and F Veglio Adrenal endothelin-1 levels are not associated with aldosterone secretion in primary aldosteronism Eur. J. Endocrinol., March 1, 2009; 160(3): 453 - 458. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B Rayner Primary aldosteronism and aldosterone-associated hypertension J. Clin. Pathol., July 1, 2008; 61(7): 825 - 831. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |