| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Department of Internal Medicine (P.C., S.L., F.S., A.F.), Section of Internal Medicine and Endocrine and Metabolic Sciences, University of Perugia, 06126 Perugia, Italy; Department of Morphological and Biochemical Sciences (C.B.V., M.B.), University of Verona, 37134 Verona, Italy; Pediatrics Unit (R.P.), Regional Hospital "Vito Fazzi", 73100 Lecce, Italy; Department of Medical and Surgical Sciences (C.B.), University of Padova, 35131 Padova, Italy; Department of Clinical Pathophysiology (M.M.), Section of Endocrinology, University of Florence, 50139 Florence, Italy; Division of Endocrinology and Metabolism (R.G.), Department of Internal Medicine, University of Turin, 10126 Turin, Italy; Department of Clinical and Experimental Medicine and Surgery "F. Magrassi, A. Lanzara" (A.D.B.), Second University of Naples, 80131 Naples, Italy; and Department of Clinical Sciences (C.T.), University of Rome "La Sapienza", 00161 Rome, Italy
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Alberto Falorni, M.D., Ph.D., Department of Internal Medicine, Section of Internal Medicine and Endocrine and Metabolic Sciences, Via E. Dal Pozzo, 06126 Perugia, Italy. E-mail: falorni{at}dimisem.med.unipg.it.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Design: We tested the immunoreactivity of full-length porcine AADC and of eight fragments of the enzyme with human serum from 18 patients with APS I, 199 with non-APS I autoimmune Addisons disease, 124 with type 1 diabetes mellitus, 36 with Graves disease, and 141 healthy control subjects, and we evaluated the autoantibody-mediated enzymatic inhibition.
Results: AADC antibodies (Ab) were detected in 12 of 18 (67%) APS I patients and in six of 199 (3%) autoimmune Addisons disease patients. Four patients with autoimmune hepatitis were all positive for AADCAb. None of the 141 healthy control subjects, 82 patients with nonautoimmune adrenal insufficiency, 124 with type 1 diabetes mellitus, and 36 with Graves disease were found positive. Two epitope regions, corresponding to amino acids 274299 (E1) and 380471 (E2) were identified. Localization of E1 was confirmed by displacement studies with synthetic peptides corresponding to peptides of porcine AADC. All 12 AADCAb-positive APS I sera reacted with E1, and seven of 12 (58%) reacted also with E2. E2-specific, but not E1-specific, autoantibodies were associated with a significant inhibition of in vitro AADC enzymatic activity.
Conclusions: We mapped the human AADCAb epitopes to the middle and COOH-terminal regions of the enzyme. Autoantibodies to the COOH-terminal region induce a significant inhibition of enzymatic activity.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
APS I is a rare autosomal recessive disease defined by the concomitant presence of at least two of three main disease components: hypoparathyroidism, adrenal insufficiency, and chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis (5). Additional components, such as autoimmune hepatitis, hypergonadotropic hypogonadism, chronic thyroiditis, type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM), alopecia, vitiligo, chronic atrophic gastritis, pernicious anemia, malabsorption, neoplasias, keratoconjunctivitis, and nail dystrophy may also be present. APS I is caused by mutations of the autoimmune regulator gene on chromosome 21q22.3, which encodes for a transcription factor expressed in cells of the immune system (5, 6).
APS II is more typically diagnosed in adult subjects with AAD, in the presence of a concomitant thyroid autoimmune disease or T1DM (1). APS II is a complex genetic syndrome with a major contribution of the HLA class II region (7, 8, 9).
In patients with AAD, the enzyme steroid-21-hydroxylase (21OH) is the main adrenal autoantigen, irrespective of the type of APS (10, 11, 12, 13, 14). Other steroidogenic enzymes, such as 17
-hydroxylase (17
OH) and P450 side-chain cleavage enzyme (P450scc) are autoantibody targets in APS I patients, and less frequently in APS II patients (1, 3, 4, 15, 16, 17, 18). In patients with APS I, several other autoantibody specificities have been recognized, including autoantibodies against glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD65 and GAD67), protein tyrosine-phosphatase-like pancreatic islet cell antigen-2 (IA-2), thyroid peroxidase, cytochrome P450 IA2, aromatic L-amino acid decarboxylase (AADC), tryptophane hydroxylase, and histidine decarboxylase (1, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24).
The enzyme 3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine (DOPA) decarboxylase is a homodimeric pyridoxal 5'-phosphate (PLP)-dependent enzyme that catalyzes the conversion of L-DOPA, L-5-hydroxytryptophan, and other cathecol- or indole-related L-amino acids to their corresponding amines and is more generally described as AADC (25).
AADC autoantibodies (AADCAb) have been detected in a proportion of patients with APS I and related to the development of autoimmune hepatitis and vitiligo (20, 21). AADCAb have also been found in a small fraction of patients with isolated AAD or APS II (26, 27). Although it has been proposed that human autoantibodies might affect the enzymatic activity of AADC (28), little information is currently available on the interrelation between AADCAb epitope specificity and autoantibody-mediated enzymatic inhibition.
With the aim to investigate the prevalence and epitope specificity of AADCAb in patients with APS I and in those with non-APS I AAD, we took advantage of a large group of samples collected by the Italian Addison Network (IAN) (8, 9, 29). We mapped the major human AADC autoantibody epitope regions and we addressed the question of whether human autoantibodies affect the enzymatic activity of AADC in vitro, by also investigating the association between autoantibody-induced inhibition of enzymatic activity and autoantibody epitope specificity.
| Patients and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A total of 299 patients with a diagnosis of primary adrenal insufficiency, recruited by the IAN between 1998 and 2006, were enrolled in this study. Both diagnosis and etiological classification of primary adrenal insufficiency were made according to criteria described in a previous work of the IAN (29).
Three distinct groups of IAN patients were studied. The first group was represented by 18 APS I patients (median age 23 yr, range 540 yr, eight males and 10 females). Three of these 18 APS I patients were suffering from autoimmune hepatitis and were all positive for anti-liver kidney microsome (LKM) Ab. Two other APS I patients were positive for anti-LKM Ab with no or transient clinical signs of autoimmune hepatitis. Two APS I patients (including one with autoimmune hepatitis) were suffering from vitiligo.
A total of 199 non-APS I AAD patients (median age 42 yr, range 670 yr, 69 males and 130 females, time from diagnosis: median 6 yr, range 045 yr) constituted the second group; of these, 89 had isolated AAD, 95 had APS II, and 15 had APS IV (according to the classification proposed by Betterle et al. in Ref. 1).
Another 82 patients (median age 64 yr, range 4687 yr, 43 males and 39 females, time from diagnosis: median 9 yr, range 253 yr) were enrolled in the group of subjects suffering from nonautoimmune adrenal insufficiency; this group included patients with X-linked adrenoleukodystrophy, adrenal hypoplasia congenita, posttubercular, postsurgical, sepsis-related, or neonatal adrenal insufficiency.
We also analyzed serum samples from 124 patients with recent onset T1DM (median age 13 yr, range 145 yr, 70 males and 54 females) and from 36 patients with Graves disease (median age 31 yr, range 1852 yr, nine males and 27 females) with no clinical or biochemical signs of either adrenal autoimmunity or adrenal insufficiency. Diagnosis of T1DM was made according to National Diabetes Data Group criteria (30). Islet cell autoantibodies were detected in over 95% of T1DM patients. Diagnosis of Graves disease was confirmed by thyroid ultrasound, thyroid scintiscan, and/or presence of TSH receptor autoantibodies in subjects with biochemical and clinical signs of hyperthyroidism.
A group of 141 healthy subjects (median age 39 yr, range 1055 yr, 65 males and 76 females), with no chronic or autoimmune diseases, served as control group. All patients and healthy subjects gave their informed consent for the study, and the study was approved by the local ethic committees.
Porcine AADC plasmid preparation and development of a radiobinding assay for human autoantibody detection
Full-length porcine AADC cDNA (31) was subcloned into the HindIII/XbaI site of a modified pcDNAII vector (Invitrogen, Groningen, The Netherlands), containing an AATTCACC sequence upstream of the ATG start codon to enhance the efficiency of the in vitro translation reaction, under the control of the SP6 promoter. Porcine AADC shares 88.7% homology with human AADC and 85.6% homology with rat AADC with 100% homology at the level of the PLP-binding site (32).
Full-length 35S-labeled AADC protein was produced in an in vitro coupled transcription/translation system with SP6 RNA polymerase using TnT coupled reticulocyte lysate system (Promega Corp., Madison, WI) and 35S-methionine (NEN Life Science Products, Inc., Boston, MA) and used for immunoprecipitation of patient sera following a previously described method for detection of human GAD65 autoantibodies (33), with only slight modifications.
In each autoantibody assay, one positive standard serum and two negative standard sera were used. The positive standard serum was from an APS I patient and the two negative sera from two healthy control subjects. AADCAb levels were expressed as a relative index using the formula: (cpm sample mean cpm negative controls)/(cpm positive control mean cpm negative controls).
The positive standard serum from an APS I patient immunoprecipitated 32% of total trichloroacetic acid-precipitable 35S-AADC, against a percentage of 3.53.7 performed by the two negative standard sera from healthy subjects of the control group. The upper level of normal range of AADCAb index was set at 0.10, as calculated as the mean value + 3 SD of the AADC index observed in a total of 141 healthy control subjects.
Epitope mapping of AADCAb
To characterize the epitope specificity of human AADCAb, we generated fragments of porcine AADC, corresponding to the NH2-terminal region [amino acids (aa.), 1130, fragment NH], the middle region (aa. 131300, fragment MID), the COOH-terminal region (aa. 301486, fragment COOH), and five additional fragments overlapping the first three, one corresponding to aa. 69228 (fragment A), one to aa. 229394 (fragment B), one to aa. 69261 (fragment D), one to aa. 301379 (fragment E) and one to aa. 380486 region (fragment F) (Fig. 1
).
|
|
For competition experiments, cold AADC-NH, AADC-MID, and AADC-COOH were produced by in vitro transcription/translation using nonradiolabeled aa.
Displacement of AADCAb with an excess of nonradiolabeled recombinant porcine AADC or with synthetic peptides
To address the question whether the immunoprecipitated radioactivity was specifically related to the presence of AADC autoantibodies in human serum, we performed separate experiments with an excess of cold, nonradiolabeled purified recombinant porcine AADC or cold, nonradiolabeled purified human GAD65, another PLP-binding decarboxylase. In each displacement experiment, a total of 1 µg of cold AADC or 1 µg of cold GAD65 was added to the immunoprecipitation reaction containing in vitro-translated 35S-AADC and human serum, in separate tubes. AADC cDNA was inserted into plasmid pKKDDCD3D4, which was expressed in SVS370 Escherichia coli cells using a procedure described elsewhere (31). AADC was purified to homogeneity (31, 34), and the enzyme concentration was determined by using the extinction coefficient at 280 nm of 1.3 x 105 M1·cm1 (35).
Nonradiolabeled recombinant human GAD65, expressed into and purified from a baculovirus expression system, was a kind gift of Dr. John Robertson (Diamyd Co., Stockholm, Sweden).
Synthetic peptides corresponding to aa. 227241, 242256, 249263, 272286, 279293, and 286300 of porcine AADC were obtained from Primm S.r.l. (Milan, Italy). The peptides were resuspended at a concentration of 1 mg/ml in 10 or 20% acetonitrile. The immunoprecipitation buffer used in the AADCAb assay was supplemented with 0.1 mg/ml of either peptide to investigate the effect on AADCAb binding to in vitro-translated AADC-MID, the fragment that contains the tested peptides.
In separate series of experiments, the AADCAb assay was performed in the presence of cold, nonradiolabeled AADC-NH, AADC-MID, or AADC-COOH fragment produced by in vitro transcription/translation. In each well, 4 µl (or 8 µl) of cold AADC fragment (or the in vitro transcription/translation mix with no cDNA, for the control reaction with no AADC fragment) was added to the immunoprecipitation mix that contained approximately 0.1 µl of in vitro-transcribed, in vitro-translated 35S-AADC.
Effect of human AADCAb on in vitro AADC enzymatic activity
The standard reaction for AADC enzymatic activity contained, in a final volume of 250 µl, 100 µl of 0.1 M potassium phosphate buffer, pH 6.8, 0.1 µM recombinant AADC (31), 10 µM PLP, and 0.5 mM L-DOPA in the absence or presence of serum samples (10 µl). After 5 min of incubation at 25 C, the reaction was stopped by heating at 100 C for 1 min, and the AADC activity was measured as described by Sherald et al. (36), as modified by Charteris and John (37). The percentage of inhibition for each sample was the mean for three independent experiments; in each case, the SE was less than 5%. To test the effect of APS I AADCAb on in vitro AADC enzymatic activity serum samples were available from 15 of the 18 APS I patients.
Other autoantibody assays
Autoantibodies to 21OH (21OHAb), 17
OH (17
OHAb), and P450scc (P450sccAb) were detected by using radiobinding assays with in vitro-translated recombinant human autoantigens radiolabeled with 35S (12, 18), similar to that for detection of AADCAb. The upper levels of normal were 0.06, 0.10, and 0.06 for 21OHAb, 17
OHAb, and P450sccAb, respectively. The full-length cDNAs for human 17
OH and for human P450scc were kindly donated by Dr. Walter L. Miller (Department of Pediatrics and Metabolic Research Unit, University of California, San Francisco, CA).
Autoantibodies to GAD65 (GADA) and protein tyrosine-phosphatase-like pancreatic islet cell antigen-2 (IA-2A) were detected using previously described quantitative radioimmunoprecipitation assays (38). The full-length cDNA for human GAD65 was kindly donated by Dr. Åke Lernmark (Department of Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, WA). The (a.a.256556:630979)BDC cDNA for human IA-2 was kindly donated by Dr. George S. Eisenbarth (Barbara Davis Center for Childhood Diabetes, University of Colorado, Denver, CO).
Adrenal cortex autoantibodies (ACA) were determined in two separate laboratories using indirect immunofluorescence on cryostatic sections of either human (39) or monkey (40) adrenal glands. Levels of ACA were expressed as the reciprocal of the end point dilution titer.
Statistical analysis
Differences in autoantibody frequencies among the groups were tested with the
2 method. Yates correction or the Fisher exact test were used when appropriate. Differences in autoantibody titer were tested by the nonparametric Mann-Whitney test or the Wilcoxon test for paired samples. A two-tailed P < 0.05 was considered significant in all tests.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Autoantibodies against AADC were detected in 12 of 18 patients with APS I (67%) and in six of 199 (3%) non-APS I AAD patients. In AADCAb-positive patients, AADCAb titer was significantly higher in APS I patients than in non-APS I AAD patients (P = 0.006). Of the six APS I patients found negative for AADCAb, none had autoimmune hepatitis or anti-LKM Ab, whereas one had vitiligo. On the contrary, of the 12 AADCAb-positive APS I patients, three had autoimmune hepatitis (including one with vitiligo) and two others were positive for anti-LKM Ab, with no or transient clinical signs of hepatitis. Of the six non-APS I AAD patients who tested positive for AADCAb, four (one male and three females) had isolated AAD, one male patient had AAD and Hashimotos thyroiditis, and one female patient had AAD and chronic active hepatitis. Time from diagnosis of AAD of the six non-APS I patients positive for AADCAb (median: 10 yr, range: 133 yr) was not significantly different from that of the 193 AADCAb-negative AAD patients (median: 6 yr, range 045 yr). None of 18 AAD subjects who had also vitiligo was found positive for AADCAb. On the other hand, none of the AADCAb-negative Addison patients had chronic autoimmune hepatitis.
None of the patients with other forms of primary adrenal insufficiency, as well as none of T1DM or Graves patients, was found positive for AADCAb (Fig. 2
). Similarly, none of 141 healthy subjects had an AADC index higher than the upper level of normal range.
|
2 test showed a significant difference in the prevalence of AADCAb between the six groups tested (P < 0.001); when the prevalence of AADCAb-positive sera of the APS I patient group was compared with that of the other groups, a marked statistical significance was found (in all cases P < 0.001). No further statistical difference was found in the remaining comparisons among groups.
When the AADCAb-positive sera from both APS I and non-APS I AAD groups were tested with an excess of cold, nonradiolabeled porcine AADC, a complete displacement of radiolabeled AADC from autoantibody binding was observed, and the AADCAb titer decreased from 0.120.96 to 00.10 (Fig. 3A
). On the other hand, no significant displacement of radiolabeled AADC was observed when the immunoprecipitation reaction was carried out in the presence of an excess of cold, nonradiolabeled, recombinant human GAD65 (Fig. 3B
), thus indicating a specific autoantibody binding to AADC.
|
OHAb, P450sccAb, ACA, GADA, or IA-2A prevalence was observed between AADCAb-positive and -negative APS I patients.
|
To localize the autoantibody epitope regions on AADC, we used radiolabeled fragments of the enzyme (Fig. 1
).
We first tested the immunoreactivity of the AADC-NH fragment, corresponding to aa. region 1130, using the sera from 12 AADCAb-positive APS I patients and six AADCAb-positive non-APS I Addison patients (Table 3
). None of the AADCAb-positive sera reacted with the AADC-NH fragment.
|
Subsequently, we tested four additional fragments: AADC-A, corresponding to aa. 69228, AADC-B, corresponding to aa. 229394, AADC-D, corresponding to aa. 69261, and AADC-E, corresponding to aa. 301379. By using the first one (AADC-A), none of the AADCAb-positive sera did react, this showing that the first 228 aa. of the enzyme do not contain major autoantibody epitope regions. On the contrary, all the AADCAb-positive sera reacted significantly with the second of the two fragments (AADC-B), suggesting that the major autoantibody epitopes are localized in the aa. 229394 region of the enzyme. To further restrict the autoantibody epitopes located in the middle region of the enzyme, we tested the reactivity of the AADC-D fragment. None of the AADCAb-positive sera reacted with this fragment, showing that the first 261 aa. of the enzyme do not contain major autoantibody epitope regions and that the middle epitopes identified by the AADC-MID fragment (aa. 130300) are restricted to the aa. 261300 region. Finally, we found that none of the AADCAb-positive sera reacted with the AADC-E fragment, which shows that the COOH-terminal epitope(s) is(are) restricted to the aa. 380486 region.
Displacement of human AADCAb by synthetic peptides or AADC fragments
The use of several AADC fragments enabled the identification of two major epitope regions corresponding to the aa. 261300 (E1) and the aa. 380486 (E2) regions. To confirm the localization of the major immunodominant E1 epitope present in all AADCAb-positive APS I sera, we tested the 12 APS I sera positive for AADC-MID-Ab in the presence or absence of synthetic peptides corresponding to aa. 227241, 242256, 249263, 272286, 279293, and 286300 of porcine AADC. When the results were expressed as percent of the observed immunoprecipitation in the absence of synthetic peptides (Fig. 4
), a significant displacement of autoantibody binding was observed in the presence of either of the three synthetic peptides corresponding to aa. 272286, 279293, or 286300. Conversely, no significant displacement of autoantibody binding was observed in the presence of the synthetic peptides corresponding to aa. 227241, 242256, or 249263 (Fig. 4
).
|
|
When human serum was included in the in vitro assay to determine AADC enzymatic activity, 10 AADCAb-positive APS I sera determined an inhibition of the enzymatic activity that ranged from 2.241% (median value: 14%), compared with an inhibition that ranged from 114% (median value: 7%) when five AADCAb-negative APS I sera were used in the assay (P not significant). The inhibition of the enzymatic activity obtained with the six AADCAb-positive sera from non-APS I AAD patients ranged from 618% (median value: 7%), compared with an inhibition that ranged from 421% (median value: 9%) observed with 10 sera from AADCAb-negative autoimmune Addison patients (P not significant).
Although there was no statistically significant difference in inhibition of enzymatic activity between AADCAb-positive and AADCAb-negative sera, the degree of inhibition (median value 32%, range 341%) caused by six AADCAb-positive APS I sera reacting against both fragments MID and COOH was significantly higher than that observed with four AADCAb-positive APS I sera reacting against the fragment MID, but not against the fragment COOH (median value 3.5, range 2.210; P = 0.019) (Fig. 6
). Such a finding is not explained by the difference in AADCAb titer, because autoantibody titer was similar in both APS I patients exhibiting serum reactivity against the fragment COOH (AADC index median value 0.87, range 0.641.11) and those not exhibiting it (AADC index median value 1.01, range 0.111.10).
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The prevalence of AADCAb in our APS I patients (67%) was similar to that found in other previous studies (20, 21, 26, 27). In addition, by analyzing a large population of patients with non-APS I AAD, we confirm the 3% frequency of AADCAb positivity registered in a recent study performed on a smaller population (27). Accordingly, the presence of AADCAb appears to be a sensitive marker for APS I, but not for isolated or APS II/IV-related AAD. The diagnostic sensitivity of AADCAb for APS I is similar to that of 17
OHAb, but slightly lower than those of both P450sccAb and 21OHAb. Furthermore, the presence of AADCAb was not dependent on that of other autoantibodies, such as 21OHAb, 17
OHAb, P450sccAb, GADA, or IA-2A, thus indicating that AADC targets a distinct immunologic response.
The specificity of the autoantibody binding was demonstrated in our study by competition experiments with an excess of nonradiolabeled AADC. Conversely, no significant displacement was observed in the presence of an excess of recombinant human GAD65, another PLP-binding decarboxylase. Human GAD65 was selected as control protein because of the low homology with porcine AADC and the presence of GADA in nine of our 18 APS I patients. Our results can be interpreted to indicate that our assay is able to selectively detect AADCAb and that AADCAb represents a distinct autoantibody specificity from GADA.
It had been suggested initially that AADC would be a pancreatic ß-cell autoantigen (41). However, subsequent studies have failed to detect a significant reactivity to AADC in the sera from T1DM patients not having APS I (20, 27). In the present study, we detected AADCAb in none of 124 patients with recent onset T1DM. Similarly, 36 patients with Graves disease scored negative for AADCAb, thus indicating that this autoantibody specificity can mainly be detected in APS I patients, but not in patients with other endocrine autoimmune diseases or syndromes, as also shown by its absence in 110 patients with complete or incomplete APS II/APS IV, in our study.
It has been reported that AADCAb would be present in 7592% of APS I patients with hepatitis (20, 21, 27). Although our study cannot provide definitive data on this specific topic (because of the limited number of patients with autoimmune hepatitis), our results support the hypothesis that AADCAb is a sensitive marker for autoimmune hepatitis in patients with primary adrenal insufficiency. Indeed, the three APS I patients and the non-APS I AAD patient with autoimmune hepatitis were all found positive for AADCAb. In addition, two other APS I subjects who were positive for anti-LKM, with no or transient clinical signs of hepatitis, were also found positive for AADCAb. The high sensitivity of AADCAb for autoimmune hepatitis is not paralleled by a similarly high diagnostic specificity because seven APS I patients and five non-APS I AAD patients were positive for AADCAb in the absence of both anti-LKM Ab and clinical signs of hepatitis. Our finding of AADCAb in seven of 13 (54%) APS I patients without hepatitis or anti-LKM Ab is in line with the results of previous studies; Husebye et al. (20) found AADCAb in 24 of 57 (42%) and Dal Pra et al. (27) found AADCAb in 10 of 14 (71%) APS I patients without hepatitis. Future follow-up studies of these AADCAb-positive subjects will be instrumental in testing the predictive value of this marker for autoimmune hepatitis. No association between AADCAb and vitiligo was observed in our population.
An important novelty of our study is the use of porcine AADC, instead of rat AADC that was used in previous studies (20, 21, 26, 27). Rat and porcine AADC have an overall homology of 85.6% (32). Thus, it is not surprising that we detected AADCAb at a similar frequency to that of the studies using rat autoantigen. However, it must be noted that the rat and porcine AADC show significantly different COOH-terminal tails, with only three identical aa. residues in the region corresponding to the 472486 peptide of porcine AADC. Consequently, it is highly unlikely that the last 15 aa. residues of the COOH-terminal tail of porcine AADC may contain an autoantibody epitope. In addition, it must be noted that human AADC ends at position 480.
To better characterize the autoantibody epitope regions, we constructed eight different fragments of porcine AADC and we tested their reactivity with the sera initially found positive for AADCAb. In the first series of experiments, we observed that all the APS I AADCAb-positive sera reacted with a middle fragment (AADC-MID) corresponding to the aa. 131300 region, evidently containing the major epitope(s), and to which we refer to as E1. In addition, separate epitope(s) was(were) detected in the COOH-terminal fragment corresponding to the aa. 301486 region. This second group of epitopes are referred to as E2. Differently from E1, which were reactive in all AADCAb-positive patients, E2 reacted only with seven of the 12 APS I patients found positive for AADCAb. Slightly different results were observed with the six AADCAb-positive sera from patients with isolated or APS II/IV AAD, because only two sera were positive for AADC-MID-Ab and four for AADC-COOH-Ab; moreover, such positives were mutually exclusive and no serum reacted with both E1 and E2. The difference in behavior between APS I and non-APS I sera may be related to the lower autoantibody titer observed in the latter patients, which may make difficult the accurate dissection of the epitope specificities or to a more pronounced epitope spreading in APS I.
Interestingly, none of the 12 APS I or the six non-APS I AADCAb-positive sera reacted with AADC-NH, AADC-A, or AADC-D, which leads us to consider that no major autoantibody epitope is located in the region corresponding to the first 261 aa. This finding is apparently at variance with the results of a previous study (27) that suggested that additional epitopes may be located in the NH2-terminal region of the enzyme. However, our present study and the previous one (27) are based on different methodological approaches and there was a lack of statistical significance in the results of the previous study (27) regarding the existence of NH2-terminal epitopes. Indeed, our strategy of using large AADC fragments does not exclude the possibility of the existence of additional, conformational epitopes in the NH2-terminal region of the enzyme. Because of the chronic nature of the autoimmune process, it is likely that some of the autoantibody epitopes may be conformational. Nevertheless, the significant displacement of AADCAb by an excess of cold AADC-MID, although not complete in some of the tested samples, confirms that one or more major E1-epitope(s) is(are) located in the middle domain of the autoantigen. The incomplete displacement of AADCAb by an excess of AADC-MID, observed in three of seven APS I-tested patients, may be the consequence of technical problems related to the use of nonpurified AADC fragment produced by in vitro transcription/translation, but can also be interpreted to indicate that additional, conformational epitopes of AADCAb are present.
The use of a fragment corresponding to aa. 229394 (AADC-B) confirmed the immunoreactivity of the middle region of the enzyme as all the ADDCAb-positive sera scored positive for this fragment. By combining our results and the results of a previous study (27), we can hypothesize that E1 is(are) located in the region corresponding to aa. 262300. A detailed analysis of the aa. 261300 region of AADC reveals that aa. 262270 is characterized by a low homology between rat and porcine with only four identical aa. residues. In addition, it is interesting to note that a cluster of five conserved aa. residues (HVDAA) can be detected upstream of the PLP binding lysine in both the 269273 region of porcine AADC and the 362366 region of human GAD65, which shows that this peptide is unlikely to be involved in AADCAb reactivity. We then conclude that E1 is(are) most likely located in the aa. region 274299, because the NPHK peptide corresponding to aa. residues 300303 of porcine AADC is identical to the PLP-binding site of human GAD65. It is noteworthy that the 274299 region of porcine AADC is identical to the corresponding region of rat and human AADC (32). The mapping of the middle epitope region to aa. region 274299 was confirmed by the signification inhibition of autoantibody binding by coincubation with synthetic peptides corresponding to aa. 272286, 279293, and 286300 (Fig. 4
).
Husebye et al. (28) have shown that human AADCAb may variably inhibit in vitro enzymatic activity of AADC. In our study, we show that incubation with human serum containing AADCAb induced a 2.241% inhibition when APS I sera were analyzed, or a 618% inhibition when non-APS I sera were studied. Although the observed inhibition was nonstatistically different from that obtained with AADCAb-negative sera, the subgroup of APS I sera reacting against the COOH-terminal epitopes induced a significantly pronounced inhibition of enzymatic activity, thus providing a clear interrelation between autoantibody epitope specificity and autoantibody-mediated enzymatic inhibition. The AADC-COOH fragment contains a peptide corresponding to aa. 328339 that creates a mobile loop that plays an important role in the catalytic mechanism (42). However, as for E2 location on AADC-COOH, we hypothesize that the region corresponding to aa. residues 380471 (present in the AADC-F fragment) is a likely candidate to contain major autoantibody epitopes on the basis of the negative results obtained with the AADC-E fragment. Interestingly, the analysis of the crystal structure of porcine AADC (42) revealed that the COOH-terminal domain contains a four-stranded antiparallel ß-sheet with three helices packed against the face opposite of a large central domain in which the PLP binding-site is located, thus indirectly supporting the hypothesis that autoantibodies directed against the COOH-terminal tail may interfere with enzymatic activity. A similar pattern of autoantibody reactivity has been demonstrated for other organ-specific autoantibodies, and more specifically for GAD65Ab that, similarly to AADCAb, are directed mainly (although not exclusively) to epitopes located in the middle and COOH-terminal regions (43, 44), with COOH-terminal specific autoantibodies correlating with an in vitro inhibition of GAD65 enzymatic activity in patients with Stiff-Person syndrome (45).
In conclusion, we have demonstrated the frequent occurrence of AADCAb in APS I patients and the ability of autoantibodies specific to the COOH-terminal region of the enzyme to induce in vitro enzymatic inhibition. A mapping of the major AADCAb epitope regions was performed. At present, it is still unclear whether E1 and E2 identify two distinct subgroups of patients with different mechanisms of AADCAb production or are the expression of different phases of the natural history of autoantibody production which is characterized by epitope spreading. Further analyses are needed to address this specific question.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
OH cDNA and human P450scc cDNA, and Dr. George S. Eisenbarth (Barbara Davis Center for Childhood Diabetes, University of Colorado) for the kind gift of human IA-2 (a.a.256556:630-979)BDC cDNA. In addition to the authors, the following members of the Italian Addison Network contributed to the collection of data and blood samples from patients with primary adrenal insufficiency: B. Ambrosi (Milan), A. Angeli (Orbassano), G. Arnaldi (Ancona), E. Arvat (Turin), A. Baccarelli (Milan), L. Barbetta (Milan), P. Beck-Peccoz (Milan), A. Bellastella (Naples), A. Bizzarro (Naples), M. Boscaro (Ancona), F. Cavagnini (Milan), F. Dotta (Siena), E. Ghigo (Turin), S. Laureti (Perugia), R. Libè (Milan), F. Loré (Siena), F. Mantero (Padova), G. Mantovani (Milan), P. Paccotti (Orbassano), F. Pecori-Giraldi (Milan), P. Toja (Milan), M. Torlontano (S.Giovanni Rotondo), V. Toscano (Rome), V. Trischitta (S.Giovanni Rotondo), and R. Zanchetta (Padova).
| Footnotes |
|---|
Disclosure Statement: The authors have nothing to disclose.
First Published Online January 2, 2007
1 See Acknowledgments for additional members of the Italian Addison Network. ![]()
Abbreviations: aa., Amino acid; AAD, autoimmune Addisons disease; AADC, aromatic L-amino acid decarboxylase; Ab, antibodies; ACA, adrenal cortex autoantibodies; APS, autoimmune polyendocrine syndrome; DOPA, 3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine; GAD, glutamic acid decarboxylase; GADA, GAD autoantibody; IA-2A, protein tyrosine-phosphatase-like pancreatic islet cell antigen-2 autoantibody; IAN, Italian Addison Network; LKM, liver kidney microsome; 17
OHAb, 17
-hydroxylase autoantibody; 21OHAb, 21-hydroxylase autoantibody; P450sccAb, P450 side-chain cleavage autoantibody; PLP, pyridoxal 5'-phosphate; T1DM, type 1 diabetes mellitus.
Received October 24, 2006.
Accepted December 27, 2006.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-hydroxylase. Lancet 339:770773[CrossRef][Medline]
-hydroxylase in Addisons disease and autoimmune polyendocrine syndrome type III. Eur J Endocrinol 142:187194[Abstract]
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||