| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Departments of Pediatrics (N.I.L., E.E.B., R.L.R.), Medicine (R.L.R.), and Health Studies (M.K.), The University of Chicago Pritzker School of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois 60637
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Robert L. Rosenfield, University of Chicago Comer Childrens Hospital, Section of Pediatric Endocrinology, 5841 South Maryland Avenue (M/C 5053), Chicago, Illinois 60637. E-mail: robros{at}peds.bsd.uchicago.edu.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: We tested the hypothesis that parental MBS is related to the PCOS phenotype in their offspring.
Design/Setting: We phenotyped for MBS and PCOS in our General Clinical Research Center.
Patients: Girls with PCOS, 1219 yr old (n = 36, including one pair of siblings), and their parents (35 mothers, 19 fathers) were recruited from the Pediatric Endocrinology Clinic. Healthy girls, 1219 yr old (n = 21), were recruited as a reference population.
Interventions: We measured anthropometrics, blood pressure, fasting lipids and androgens, oral glucose tolerance, and ultrasonographically determined polycystic ovary status.
Main Outcome Measures: MBS in parents, and PCOS features in mothers, were related to the presence of PCOS features in probands.
Results: Fathers had strikingly high prevalence of excess adiposity (94% were obese or overweight) and MBS (79%). Premenopausal mothers more commonly had MBS (36%) than features of PCOS (
22%). Polycystic ovaries in proband offspring of premenopausal mothers were associated with maternal polycystic ovaries only in a minority of cases. Proband polycystic ovary status was completely concordant to fathers MBS status (P = 0.008), but not their own or their mothers MBS status, in families whose premenopausal mothers lacked polycystic ovaries. Proband prevalence of MBS was 27.8%, 3-fold greater than expected for obesity status.
Conclusion: Familial factors related to paternal MBS seem to be fundamental to the pathogenesis of PCOS.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
MBS, a variably expressed cluster of glucose abnormalities, central (android) obesity, hypertension, and dyslipidemia, is the result of insulin resistance interacting with obesity and age (17, 18). Given that both PCOS and the MBS have insulin resistance and obesity at the core of their pathophysiology and have heritable components, we tested the hypotheses that parental MBS would be related to the PCOS phenotype in their offspring and that MBS prevalence would be increased in adolescents with PCOS.
| Subjects and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
PCOS was defined consistent with Rotterdam criteria: otherwise unexplained biochemical evidence of hyperandrogenism (specifically, plasma free testosterone above the upper limit of normal for reproductive age women, 10 pg/ml) and menstrual irregularity and/or a polycystic ovary (9). A polycystic ovary was defined according to volume criteria (over 10.5 ml in volume in adults and 10.8 ml in adolescents, according to the formula for a prolate ellipsoid), whether or not an excessive number of follicles was present (9, 19, 20). Congenital adrenal hyperplasia, adrenal tumors, Cushings syndrome, hyperprolactinemia, and thyroid disease were excluded.
For comparison with previously published national prevalence data, MBS was defined in adults according to National Cholesterol Education Program Adult Treatment Panel III criteria (ATP-III) in adults (21), and in adolescents by criteria extrapolated from ATP-III criteria in line with national recommendations for lipid and blood pressure levels in children (C-III criteria) (Table 1
) (22). Similarly, the prevalence of the individual MBS features in all groups was compared with published national prevalence data representative of the general U.S. population, the third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES III) (22, 23, 24, 25, 26). These data were adjusted for significant age, sex, ethnic, and body mass index (BMI) differences as indicated. For all other data analyses, the updated 2004 criteria of the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute/American Heart Association (NHA-04) were applied (17). These are ATP-III criteria modified to encompass current American Diabetes Association criteria for glucose abnormalities, including impaired glucose tolerance (IGT) (a 2-h plasma glucose 140199 mg/dl) or a 2-h glucose of at least 200 mg/dl as a T2DM criterion. Similarly, the C-III criteria for children were modified (C-04) by aligning the criteria for glucose abnormalities with the NHA-04 recommendations; we also defined increased waist circumference as at least 88 cm, i.e. the critical level of risk for adult women, although this is somewhat lower (approximately 85th percentile NHANES III) than the cut-point of C-III criteria [www.cdc.gov/nchs/about/major/nhanes/datatblelink.htm (27)] (28). Any subject on a medication for diabetes, dyslipidemia, or hypertension was considered to meet that MBS criterion.
|
95th percentile for adolescents), overweight as a BMI between 25 and 29.9 kg/m2 (8594.9th percentile for adolescents). Waist circumference was obtained at the narrowest part of the torso (29). Sitting blood pressure was recorded as the mean of one to three measurements. Fasting blood samples were obtained at approximately 0800 h (during d 311 of the menstrual cycle in regularly menstruating females) for total and free testosterone, estradiol, and SHBG (30, 31); LH and FSH (Delphia, Wallach, Finland); and a lipid panel (homogenous enzymatic colorimetric assay; Roche, Indianapolis, IN). Then an oral glucose tolerance test was performed according to American Diabetes Association guidelines (32). Plasma glucose was measured using a glucose analyzer (YSI model 23; Yellow Springs, OH). Serum insulin was measured by double-antibody RIA (33). The females had real-time pelvic ultrasound examinations; abdominal imaging was performed in probands and endovaginal imaging in mothers using an Acuson Sequoia with a 4-Mhz transducer (Acuson, Mountain View, CA) and Philips ATL 3000 or 5000 with an 8- to 10-Mhz transducer (Philips Medical Systems, Bothell, WA), respectively. Insulin resistance was indexed by homeostatic model assessment (HOMA); higher scores indicate greater insulin resistance (34). It was not computed in parents who were on antidiabetic treatment. Oral contraceptive medications were discontinued in probands for at least 2 months before participation in the study; regularly menstruating females were studied on d 310 of their menstrual cycle. The Institutional Review Board of the University of Chicago approved the study, and all patients gave informed consent. All studies were conducted in the General Clinical Research Center of The University of Chicago.
Statistical methods
Fishers exact test was used to test independence of two categorical variables because the expected frequencies were low for most variables (35), and t tests were used to identify differences in continuous measurements (e.g. HOMA, BMI, testosterone, and SHBG) between two groups; P values are given for two-tailed tests. To reduce the effect of outliers and to account for unequal variability in the MBS feature groups, the nonparametric trend test (36) was used to determine whether BMI and HOMA scores were significantly increasing as the number of metabolic features went up. Because there was only one pair of proband siblings, the within-family correlation could not be estimated, and the two siblings with PCOS were treated in the analyses as if they had come from different families. In the analyses involving both probands and their parents, the parents of the two siblings were counted twice.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The 36 probands averaged 16 yr of age (range, 1219 yr); 73.6% were Caucasian (W) and 26.4% were African-American (AA). Ninety-seven percent had irregular menses, and 72% had a polycystic ovary; 44% were hirsute. One proband had preexisting type 1 diabetes. Seventy-four percent of the mothers and 89% of the fathers were W; 26% of the mothers and 11% of the fathers were AA. The mothers averaged 45.2 yr of age (range, 3154 yr); 10 (29%) were postmenopausal on both clinical and endocrinological grounds. Their PCOS features are discussed below. The fathers averaged 48.5 yr of age (range, 3958 yr). Of the fathers studied, 10.5% were on oral antidiabetic medications, 10.5% were on medications for dyslipidemia, and 26% were on antihypertensive medications. Eleven percent of the mothers were on antihypertensive medications. The adolescent reference group was 1219 yr of age; two thirds were AA, one third W. All had monthly menstrual cycles of 2235 d.
Information was not available for waist circumference in two mothers and two fathers, lipids in one proband and one father, and blood pressure in seven mothers and three fathers. Two premenopausal mothers declined pelvic ultrasound examination. No ultrasound was performed on a mother who was surgically postmenopausal. Insulin levels were not available on two fathers, both of whom were known diabetics.
Relationship of adolescent PCOS to MBS
Sixty-one percent of probands were obese, and 14% were overweight (Fig. 1A
). By C-III criteria, MBS was present in 19.4%; all were obese. Seventy-two percent of probands had central adiposity, 31% had low high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C), 22% had hypertension, 20% had elevated triglycerides, and 8.6% had glucose abnormalities (exclusive of the type 1 diabetic) by C-III criteria. By C-04 criteria, 27.8% had MBS and 20% had T2DM-related glucose abnormalities; during this study, three probands (8.6%) were diagnosed with T2DM, one had impaired fasting glucose (IFG) alone (3%), two IGT alone (5.7%), and one both IFG and IGT (3%).
|
The healthy adolescent reference group had a prevalence of MBS and MBS features similar to that expected for their BMI and ethnicity (22), differing from that expected by less than 7% and 1.5-fold (Fig. 1B
). All had normal glucose tolerance. Their prevalence of polycystic ovaries was unexpectedly high (61.9%).
Probands with MBS had significantly higher BMI, HOMA score, and free testosterone than those without MBS (Table 2
). However, SHBG level and polycystic ovaries were not significantly related to the presence of MBS, although there was a tendency to lower SHBG levels in the subgroup with MBS. The number of MBS features was significantly related to BMI and the HOMA index of insulin resistance in the probands (P < 0.0001). The adolescent reference population all proved to be free of MBS.
|
The majority of mothers were either obese (54.4%) or overweight (11.4%) (Fig. 1C
). By ATP-III criteria, 34% had MBS. Central adiposity was the most common MBS feature; it was present in 70% of mothers, followed by 48% with hypertension, whereas 17.1% had glucose abnormalities, 43% low HDL-C, and 26% elevated triglycerides. Using NHA-04 criteria hardly changed the prevalence of MBS (37.1%), although T2DM-related glucose abnormalities were much more frequent (48.6%). The latter consisted of T2DM in five (14.3%), three previously undiagnosed; IFG alone was found in 11.4%, IGT alone in 8.6%, and both IFG and IGT in 14.3%.
The maternal prevalence of obesity was 1.5-fold greater than that expected for age and ethnicity in the general U.S. population, but the combined prevalence of obesity and overweight was similar (26). Although the prevalence of MBS and central adiposity in mothers was not substantially higher than that in the general U.S. population, the maternal prevalence of hypertension and glucose abnormalities was 1.5- to 2.0-fold greater than expected (24).
Fathers were obese or overweight in 94% of cases by a combination of history (n = 12) and examination (n = 19) (Fig. 1D
). Unexamined fathers were overweight or obese in 25 and 58%, respectively, of cases; there was a history of diabetes in 17% of cases, hypertension in 25%, and dyslipidemia in 8%. All examined fathers were overweight (31.5%) or obese (68.5%). According to ATP-III criteria, 53% of the examined group had MBS. Eighty-eight percent of these fathers on whom data were available had hypertension, 42.1% glucose abnormalities, 76.5% central adiposity, 50% low HDL-C, and 42.1% elevated triglycerides. Using NHA-04 criteria in examined fathers, MBS (79%) and T2DM-related glucose abnormalities (84.3%) were much more frequent. The latter included T2DM in six (31.6%), three previously undiagnosed, IFG alone in 31.6%, IGT alone in 15.8%, and both IFG and IGT in 5.3%. The examined fathers prevalence of obesity, MBS, central adiposity, hypertension, and glucose abnormalities, including T2DM and IGT, were all about 1.5- to 2-fold greater than expected in the age- and ethnicity-adjusted general U.S. population (24, 25).
As expected, the number of MBS features was significantly related to BMI and the HOMA index of insulin resistance in mothers (P < 0.001 and P < 0.0001, respectively) and to BMI in fathers (P = 0.006). A relationship to HOMA could not be demonstrated in fathers, because the great majority (79%) for whom HOMA scores were available already had at least three MBS features.
Parental features previously linked to PCOS were less common than the prevalence of obesity and MBS (Table 3
). One or more polycystic ovaries were found in five of the 23 (22%) premenopausal mothers on whom pelvic ultrasonography was performed. Increased free testosterone was found in three (12%) of the 25 premenopausal women. Two of these three met criteria for PCOS, having both irregular periods and polycystic ovaries; both were obese and had MBS (the third, who was obese and had abdominal adiposity, but not a history of anovulatory symptoms, declined the ultrasound). Two other mothers reported a history of relative infertility because of PCOS, one of whom was postmenopausal, and the other declined pelvic ultrasound because of a history suggestive of a wedge resection for PCOS. Thus, approximately 14% (four of 35) of the mothers had evidence of PCOS. The prevalence of MBS among the premenopausal mothers was 36%, and the presence of MBS and PCOS was not associated (P = 0.1).
|
Relationship between proband and parental phenotype
Table 4
shows the relationship between parental features of MBS and the presence of MBS, HOMA scores, and the PCOS features of their offspring in the 19 families that underwent complete study. SHBG in the probands significantly decreased as the number of parents with the MBS increased (P = 0.008), and HOMA scores and free testosterone increased marginally, although to a lesser extent (P = 0.09 and P = 0.06, respectively). However, no association was found between the presence of polycystic ovaries in the probands and the number of parents affected with the MBS.
|
|
|
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Obesity and metabolic syndrome features of PCOS families
The prevalence of excessive weight in our adolescents with PCOS, 14% of whom were overweight and 61% obese, was over 2-fold greater than expected in the general population. This is at the upper end of that reported in a U.S. series of adolescents with PCOS (5075%) (37, 38, 39, 40). Nevertheless, MBS prevalence in our adolescent PCOS cohort was at least 3-fold higher than expected from either national prevalence data or a local reference population when adjusted for BMI status. MBS prevalence has not previously been documented in adolescence, although obesity, insulin resistance, and glucose intolerance are frequent at this early stage of PCOS (37, 39, 41, 42, 43). The MBS prevalence in our adolescents with PCOS was about half as great as in 20- to 29-yr-old adults with PCOS (10). The prevalence of all component features of MBS except triglyceride levels was at least 1.5-fold greater than expected for BMI in the population or in a local reference group. As in the general population (22), the prevalence of MBS features in these girls increased with increasing BMI. Probands with MBS were significantly more obese and insulin resistant, as indexed by BMI and HOMA score, and had a higher free testosterone level than those without MBS, although they did not have a lower SHBG level.
Fathers had an unexpectedly high prevalence of obesity (about two thirds) and excessive weight (94%), more so than anticipated from the population or from the known degree of correlation of adiposity of fathers and daughters (44). This was more striking than in mothers, in whom obesity was found in about half and the prevalence of excessive weight (65%) was similar to that expected in the general population of similar sex, age, and ethnicity. In parallel with excessive weight, MBS was considerably more frequent than expected in fathers (5379% according to ATP-III and 2004 criteria, respectively) but not in mothers (3437%). In parents, as in probands, central obesity (7076% of parents), hypertension (4888%), and glucose abnormalities (4884% by current criteria) were the major features of MBS. It has been noted before that mothers of young women with PCOS have increased abdominal adiposity; on the contrary, an increased prevalence of central adiposity was not found in the fathers in that study (14). However, another study found that fathers of young women with PCOS were more obese than those of healthy controls and had higher HOMA scores than the mothers, even when controlled for BMI (45). Our data are consistent with the recent report of increased MBS prevalence in hyperandrogenic sisters of PCOS patients (46).
Familial factors in PCOS
Polycystic ovaries, testosterone levels, and T2DM-related defects in insulin secretion and action have previously been identified as heritable factors in PCOS (4, 12, 13, 15, 16, 47, 48). In premenopausal mothers, we found excessive weight and MBS to be more common than documented polycystic ovaries (22%), testosterone excess (12%), or PCOS (9%). Evidence exists that polycystic ovaries can be inherited as an autosomal dominant trait (12, 13). Testosterone is elevated in 2346% of sisters of women with PCOS, and about half of these, in turn, have PCOS (13, 48). PCOS was reported to occur in 35% of premenopausal mothers of women with PCOS, using less objective criteria than we used, namely, menstrual irregularity and hirsutism as a surrogate for hyperandrogenemia (15). However, other studies documented only 78% of premenopausal mothers of women with PCOS to have an elevated free or total testosterone level (13, 14). Although our criteria for ovarian enlargement and androgen elevation may underestimate the incidence in premenopausal mothers because these values normally decrease with age, this is likely to be small because most studies indicate that the fall in these parameters with age is closely related to menopause (49, 50, 51, 52).
There has been considerable interest in identifying a possible heritable paternal component that may contribute to the PCOS phenotype. This is particularly relevant to our study because the majority of our PCOS adolescents did not have a mother with PCOS, an elevated testosterone level, or polycystic ovaries, and the maternal prevalence of excessive weight and MBS did not seem unusual. It has been suggested that premature male pattern baldness is the paternal phenotype (12, 13, 53). We could not confirm this in our family histories, which is not surprising in view of the complexity of this phenotypic trait (54). We did not find hyperandrogenism in the fathers, consistent with some, but not other, previous studies (12, 14). Indeed, about 10% of the fathers had low testosterone levels. Slightly elevated dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate levels have been reported in one series of brothers of PCOS women (55), but not in another (14).
Notably, however, in examining the phenotype of parent-daughter trios, we found that the presence of MBS in fathers, according to either ATP-III or current criteria, was strongly associated with the presence of polycystic ovaries in daughters, in the absence of polycystic ovaries in the mother. Such a relationship of MBS to proband polycystic ovary status did not pertain in premenopausal mothers or in the probands themselves. This was the only aspect of MBS in either probands or parents that was associated with polycystic ovaries. Our admittedly limited number of pedigrees of normal-weight probands showed these same relationships. These data strongly suggest that MBS in fathers is closely related to their daughters polycystic ovary status independently of the probands MBS status. Although we cannot exclude an environmental basis for the relationship between paternal MBS and polycystic ovaries in probands, these findings are most compatible with the genetic determinants of this aspect of PCOS being closely linked to paternal MBS.
Although there was no additive effect of paternal and maternal MBS on proband polycystic ovary status, we found a weakly additive effect on their offsprings HOMA index of insulin resistance. This combined effect is not surprising in view of insulin resistance being a major factor underlying MBS and having a significant heritable component (56). Paternal and maternal MBS also had a strongly additive effect on the suppression of offspring SHBG levels and a marginally additive one on free testosterone levels; this suggests complimentary effects of heredity (57, 58) and the compensatory hyperinsulinemia of insulin resistance (59, 60) on SHBG and free testosterone levels.
Study limitations
The applicability of this study is limited by the ascertainment bias inherent in the process of recruiting patients, their families, and volunteers. It is possible that adolescents whose parents had obesity, diabetes, or other MBS-related problems preferentially enrolled for this family evaluation. Although we observed the same relationship between paternal MBS and polycystic ovary status in probands with or without excessive weight, our proband group had a high prevalence of excessive weight (75%), which was nevertheless within the range of overweight and obesity reported for PCOS in the United States (3075%) (10, 37, 38, 39, 40, 60, 61, 62). However, PCOS is clearly a multifactorial disorder; although excessive weight is increased in prevalence in PCOS in the United States, it is not necessarily a feature in all PCOS populations (62, 63, 64). Nevertheless, it is noteworthy that increased upper body fat accumulation seems to be characteristic of most lean PCOS patients (65), suggesting that an increase in central adiposity is fundamental to the disorder. Similar considerations pertain to our reference population of adolescent volunteers, who are not necessarily representative of the general adolescent population. Although the prevalence of MBS features in this healthy volunteer reference group was similar to that expected from national prevalence data, the high percentage of polycystic ovaries in this group was unexpected. Although polycystic ovaries have been reported in 2343% or more of normal adult volunteers (66, 67, 68), the true prevalence in the general population is probably lower (69). The transabdominal visualization approach that is standard and appropriate for studies in adolescents probably underestimates the prevalence of polycystic ovaries (70), even though the prevalence of polycystic ovaries in our probands was similar to that reported in other series of PCOS patients. However, there is reason to believe that ovarian size may be greater in the perimenarcheal period than at any other stage of development; the number of large antral follicles reaches its maximum at that time, as the result of the combination of mature gonadotropin output and a higher population of follicles than in adults (71, 72).
Conclusions
With the reservations noted above, our results link adolescent polycystic ovaries with paternal MBS and add to a growing body of evidence suggesting that PCOS is fundamentally related to insulin resistance and additionally suggest a familial relationship to central obesity that warrants additional study.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
The authors have nothing to declare.
First Published Online January 31, 2006
Abbreviations: AA, African-American; ATP-III, National Cholesterol Education Program Adult Treatment Panel III criteria; BMI, body mass index; C-III, extrapolated from ATP-III for children; HDL-C, high-density lipoprotein cholesterol; HOMA, homeostatic model assessment; IFG, impaired fasting glucose; IGT, impaired glucose tolerance; MBS, metabolic syndrome; NHA-04, 2004 criteria of the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute/American Heart Association; NHANES III, third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey; PCOS, polycystic ovary syndrome; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; W, Caucasian.
Received August 1, 2005.
Accepted January 20, 2006.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. L. Rosenfield Identifying Children at Risk for Polycystic Ovary Syndrome J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., March 1, 2007; 92(3): 787 - 796. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |