| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
CLINICAL CASE SEMINAR |
University of Calgary Department of Medicine, Division of Endocrinology and Metabolism, Calgary, Alberta, Canada T2R 0X7
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Lois Donovan, 4005, 1213 4th Street S.W., Calgary, Alberta, Canada T2R 0X7. E-mail: loisdon{at}telus.net.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Objective: The objective of this study is to raise awareness of this rare form of adult-onset nonobese DM so that these patients are identified and provided with appropriate care.
Patients: We describe a kindred in which four of seven siblings have adult-onset DM and sensorineural hearing loss with a confirmed genetic mutation at position 3243 in the tRNA. Two other siblings in this kindred demonstrate different phenotypes of mitochondrial disease.
Intervention: The proband was treated with coenzyme Q10 for 1 yr.
Outcome Measures: Outcome measures included stress thallium exercise testing and audiometry testing.
Results: After 1 yr of treatment of with coenzyme Q10, repeat stress thallium testing demonstrated improvement in the exercise tolerance of the proband from 712 min. Audiometry testing did not demonstrate a change in the rate of hearing decline.
Conclusion: Maternally inherited diabetes and deafness is a rare cause of DM that is important to diagnose because of the unique management issues and associated comorbidities. This work highlights clues to the identification of this rare monogenic form of adult- onset diabetes.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Case Reports |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The patient was initially diagnosed with gestational diabetes (GDM) requiring insulin at 32-wk gestation during her first pregnancy, at the age of 23. During her second pregnancy at age 25, GDM recurred. Placenta accreta occurred at delivery of her second child. Glucose tolerance normalized after both pregnancies, and she was not diagnosed with DM until 8 yr later at age 33.
Her presumed type 2 DM was initially managed with glyburide. This was poorly tolerated so she was switched to insulin. At the time of consultation, her total daily insulin requirements were 60 U and her hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) was 8.8% (upper limit of the nondiabetic range, 6.1%). The patient had never experienced any episodes of diabetic ketoacidosis or severe hypoglycemia. She has no diabetic retinopathy; however, she does exhibit retinal pigmentation in keeping with macular pattern dystrophy. Her microalbumin to creatinine ratio was 32.9 mg/mmol (normal range < 3.4 mg/mmol), and old medical records documented unexplained stable proteinuria predating her onset of DM by 8 yr. She reported mild numbness and tingling in her feet and hands.
The proband was diagnosed with Wolf-Parkinson-White syndrome (WPW) at age 19 and had experienced several episodes of tachycardia resulting in loss of consciousness. Her last episode occurred approximately 8 yr before the time of consultation. In the spring of 2003, when she complained of fatigue, elevated creatinine kinase (CK) and CKMB were documented. Concurrent troponin was negative, ruling out cardiac ischemia as the etiology of her elevated CK and raising suspicion of skeletal muscle breakdown. A stress thallium test demonstrated only fair exercise capacity in this physically active young woman. She stopped exercise after 7 min because of fatigue and reached a maximum heart rate of 151 beats per minute.
The patient was started on a CSII. She had a marked improvement in her glycemic control such that her HbA1c fell to 7.3% 5 months after initiation of CSII. Glycemic control subsequently deteriorated as indicated by a HbA1c of 9.3% 1 yr after she started CSII. She was also started on coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10), 300 mg daily. The patient reported a marked improvement in energy level and exercise recovery. Her duration of exercise on maximal exercise testing improved dramatically from 712 min. The proband is a rancher in a rural setting. She has always had to be physically active on her ranch. Her chores often include lifting 50- to 70-pound hay bails onto trucks for up to 30 min two times each day. Before initiating CoQ10 she complained of "aching muscles" throughout the day and night. Since initiating CoQ10 therapy, her "muscle aching now rarely occurs, and when it does it is mild."
Bilateral sensorineural hearing loss was documented at age 37, has been progressive, and has resulted in the reliance on hearing aids. Unfortunately, hearing tests 1 yr after initiating CoQ10 demonstrated no improvement.
The probands C-peptide was low at 0.18 nmol/liter, and anti-glutamic acid decarboxylase and islet cell antibodies were negative. Her bicarbonate was normal. Her resting lactate levels have always been within the normal range of 1.31.6 (0.52.2 mmol/liter). Genetic testing on whole blood confirmed the tRNA A3243G mutation.
The proband is one of seven siblings born to unrelated parents, five of whom have deafness and four of whom have DM (Fig. 1
). She is third generation Canadian with English ancestry. Her maternal grandmother was born in Durham, UK. The mother of the proband did not have diabetes diagnosed during her lifetime. She died of a myocardial infarction at the age of 56. GDM is suspected in the mother of the proband because the birth weights of her last three children ranged from 911 pounds. Information on the maternal grandmother of the proband is very limited. She was known to have short stature (4 feet, 11 inches), obesity, and hypertension, and died of congestive heart failure at an unknown age. The father of the proband was obese and was diagnosed with type 2 DM at age 66. The eldest brother of the proband had cataracts removed at the age of 9 yr. He developed DM at age 28 and hearing loss at age 34. The next eldest brother developed DM at 42 and hearing loss at 38. The next brother (age 50) is not known to have diabetes; however, has just developed hearing loss in the last year as well as sick sinus syndrome. The only sibling that does not currently have diabetes or deafness is a brother, age 48. He lacks the tRNA A3243G mutation on testing of whole blood. All other living siblings and children of the proband have confirmed tRNA A3243G mutation on testing of whole blood.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
MIDD is a genetic disorder characterized by diabetes and hearing loss that is caused by a mitochondrial gene mutation. Mitochondrial DNA is exclusively maternally inherited so all offspring of an affected mother inherit the genetic defect. MIDD is most commonly caused by an A to G substitution at position 3243 in the tRNA leucine gene. This is the case with our kindred.
There is a wide variety in the phenotypic expression of this disorder. A mix of wild-type and mutant DNA in the same cell is called heteroplasmy. Varying degrees of heteroplasmy between individuals and in different tissues may partly explain the varied phenotype that results from this genetic disorder (Table 1
). The cardiac conduction abnormalities, GDM, placenta accreta, proteinuria, and neuropathy of this proband are abnormalities that have been described in other MIDD cases (4). Onset of the diabetes phenotype usually occurs between ages 1570 with a mean age of 32.838.8 yr (3). The mean duration of diabetes before insulin dependence is only 3.9 yr (5). In our patient, the onset of diabetes was at age 33, and she progressed to insulin dependence within 1 yr. She developed GDM at age 23.
|
Interestingly, these patients with MIDD are often reported to have advanced microvascular complications. However, impaired renal function and proteinuria from mitochondrial dysfunction is a known phenotype of this genetic disorder. As such, these complications may be misinterpreted as a diabetic microvascular complication. Indeed, in our proband and her sister, proteinuria predated the diagnosis of DM. The renal lesions observed in MIDD include focal segmental glomerulosclerosis with hyalinized glomeruli and myocyte necrosis in afferent arterioloes and small arteries (6, 7). Macular pattern dystrophy is a retinal lesion that is commonly seen in MIDD (8). This has the appearance of linear pigmentation on the retina surrounding the macula and the optic disc.
Neuromuscular and cardiac disorders have been described in 43.1% of MIDD patients including muscle weakness and pain, biopsy-confirmed ragged red fibers, cardiomyopathy, and preexcitation syndrome (6). The proband was diagnosed with WPW at age 19. Furthermore, the same genetic mutation can result in MELAS. Both the MIDD and MELAS phenotypes can be seen within the same family as is the case in this family (5). Finally, the natural history of MIDD is widely variable, as demonstrated in the family described here, ranging from a currently unaffected male at the age of 48 to a rapidly progressive disease that resulted in the death of a sister at age 19, 1.5 yr after the onset of "seizures" and hearing loss.
Pathophysiology
An understanding of the molecular basis of diabetes in those affected by MIDD is just emerging. Initially it was thought that impaired glucose uptake at the level of the muscle was the main defect in MIDD (9). Several studies have shown that insulin resistance is not the main culprit, but rather that pancreatic ß-cell function is impaired (10). The A to G substitution leads to dimerization of the mutant tRNA molecule and impaired aminoacylation (11). Cybrid cell lines derived from MELAS patients containing the A3243G mutation have shown a significant decrease in mitochondrial protein synthesis (12, 13). However, cybrid cell lines derived from MIDD patients showed severely reduced cellular respiration despite intact protein synthesis, leading to the hypothesis that the 3243 mutation in MIDD patients may result in enhanced degradation of mitochondrial DNA-encoded proteins (7). The end result is a reduction of functional respiratory enzyme complexes and reduced ATP generation. The altered ATP to ADP ratio may then result in impaired insulin secretion and is hypothesized to lead ultimately to the ß-cell apoptosis.
However, the question remains why there is such clinical heterogeneity and why the insulin deficiency does not manifest until later in life. It has been shown that hyperglycemia leads to an increased production of reactive oxygen species (ROS), which may then lead to oxidative damage to membranes, DNA, and proteins (14, 15, 16, 17). It has also been shown that cybrid cells containing the A3243G mutation have greatly increased levels of lipid peroxidation and oxidative stress, independent of glucose level (18). These cells are also more susceptible to damage from ROS. As such, one hypothesis is mitochondrial mutations lead to progressive insulinopenia as well as increased ROS, which then causes further damage to both the mitochondrial DNA and cell components, which may then exacerbate impaired insulin secretion. The buildup of ROS may also lead to premature and progressive ß-cell death, also leading to worsening insulin secretion and hyperglycemia. Interestingly, there is no evidence that the level of heteroplasmy coincides with clinical presentation (19). Investigations are also currently underway to determine the role that the A3243G mutation has on additional signaling molecules important for insulin secretion (4).
Management issues unique to MIDD
The A3243G mutation primarily results in a secretory defect, rather than a defect in insulin sensitivity; therefore, treatment with insulin secretagogues such as glyburide is usually first line. The hallmark of this disorder is a progressive loss of insulin secretion; thus, requirement of insulin is usually inevitable. The mean duration from diagnosis of diabetes to insulin dependence is 3.9 vs. 15 yr in type 2 diabetics (5). It should be noted that metformin, aside from being less effective, may actually be harmful because of the increased risk of lactic acidosis in these individuals (2, 3). Patients with MIDD should also be advised to maintain their carbohydrate intake carefully when ill, as some have experienced stroke-like episodes when they lacked carbohydrates on sick days (5). Of special note for females with MIDD is the predilection for complications of pregnancy, as there have been reports of preterm labor and placenta accreta (20). Pregnant women with MIDD should be carefully monitored in the third trimester, and magnesium sulfate should be avoided, as it competes with calcium in the mitochondrial membranes and may exacerbate muscle damage (21).
The unique pathophysiology of MIDD has spurred investigations into mitochondrial-based therapeutics. CoQ10 is an electron carrier in the respiratory chain of the mitochondria (see Fig. 2
). In its reduced form as ubiquinol-10, it acts as an antioxidant by protecting membrane phospholipids, serum LDL from lipid peroxidation, and mitochondrial membrane proteins from free radicals (22). We know that mutant mitochondria show enhanced release of free radicals and impairment of the mitochondrial respiratory chain, which, in turn, leads to the dysfunctions mentioned above (23). As such, CoQ10 has been noted as a possible therapeutic which may enhance insulin secretion and slow hearing loss. Indeed, there have been several studies showing an improvement in clinical symptoms in those with MELAS (24, 25, 26, 27, 28). Suzuki et al. (29) completed a 3-yr open label study in Japan of 86 patients with the A3243G mitochondrial mutation to investigate whether 150 mg of CoQ10 had any effect on insulin secretion, hearing capacity, and blood lactate levels. They found that long-term therapy with CoQ10 significantly slowed progression of the insulin secretory defect and hearing loss, as well as decreased postexercise lactate levels in those with established MIDD. Another report by Silvestre-Aillaud et al. (30), investigating CoQ10 and L-carnitine, found no such improvements. However, they only treated one patient, and follow-up was limited to 6 months. CoQ10 has also been investigated in type 2 diabetics, where it has been found to improve blood pressure and HbA1c but had no effect on oxidative stress as assessed by F2-isoprostane levels (31). Certainly type 2 diabetics do not exhibit the same degree of mitochondrial dysfunction as those with MIDD.
|
Because CoQ10 level is decreased with statins, cautious use of statins is advised in the setting of mitochondrial disorders. Theoretically, one could predict a higher rate of lactic acidosis and intolerance to statins in MIDD; however, this has not been reported.
A variety of combinations of CoQ10 and other mitochondrial cofactors including carnitine and vitamins B, C, and K have been shown in different mitochondrial disorders to improve ATP synthetic capacity in vitro and positively influence some clinical outcomes (34). One author found that CoQ10 was the only component of a cofactor mixture that improved ATP syntheses in lymphocytes (34). These other cofactors provide potential for future therapy in MIDD.
Finally, as MIDD is a mitochondrial disorder that is inherited from the mother in a dominant fashion, all progeny are at risk of developing some features of the disorder. The highly variable phenotype makes it very difficult to predict to what extent family members may be affected; however, one study in Dutch patients with the A3243G mutation showed an incidence of diabetes or IGT of 100% by age 70 (4). All first-degree family members should be screened for the mutation and provided with genetic counseling. Furthermore, for those carrying the mutation, routine surveillance regarding glucose tolerance, kidney function, hearing, and cardiac function should be considered.
Tips for identifying patients with MIDD
In retrospect, the diagnosis of MIDD in this proband appeared simple, especially when a detailed family history was taken. The presentation of many of this probands mitochondria dysfunction (i.e. WPW, GDM, and proteinuria) occurred in time, before the recognition and naming of this disorder in 1994.
A very strong family history of DM and deafness should prompt an investigation for MIDD. Microvascular complications out of keeping with duration of diabetes are another clue to the diagnosis, as the retinal and renal manifestations of mitochondrial disease may be confused for diabetic complications. Glutamic acid decarboxylase autoantibody negativity in a nonobese diabetic is yet another clue. Cardiac conduction defects and GDM may also raise suspicion as to the diagnosis; however, screening for MIDD in such individuals who have these disorders in isolation has not been productive (20).
| Conclusions |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
First Published Online October 3, 2006
Abbreviations: BMI, Body mass index; CK, creatinine kinase; CoQ10, coenzyme Q10; CSII, continuous sc insulin infusion device; DM, diabetes mellitus; GDM, gestational DM; HbA1c, hemoglobin A1c; MELAS, mitochondrial encephalomyopathy, lactic acidosis, and stroke-like syndrome; MIDD, maternally inherited diabetes and deafness; ROS, reactive oxygen species; WPW, Wolf-Parkinson-White syndrome.
Received July 12, 2006.
Accepted September 27, 2006.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
C. Thebault, R. Ollivier, G. Leurent, P. Marcorelles, B. Langella, and E. Donal Mitochondriopathy: a rare aetiology of restrictive cardiomyopathy Eur J Echocardiogr, June 25, 2008; (2008) jen189v1. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |