| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Endocrine Care |
Department of Internal Medicine I (N.K., H.P.), Bispebjerg University Hospital, 2400 Copenhagen; Centre for Preventive Medicine (N.K., T.J.), Glostrup University Hospital, 2600 Copenhagen; Department of Endocrinology (I.B., P.L.), Aalborg Hospital, 9100 Aalborg; Institute of Food Research and Nutrition (L.O.), The Danish Veterinary and Food Administration; and The Danish Centre for Prevention of Thyroid Disease (Danthyr) 2860 Søberg, Denmark
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Nils Knudsen, Medical Clinic I, Bispebjerg Hospital, DK-2400 Copenhagen NV, Denmark. E-mail: danthyr.bbh{at}dadlnet.dk
Abstract
Serum Tg is widely used in the control of thyroid cancer but also in the diagnosis of certain other thyroid diseases. Serum Tg may be useful in the characterization of the iodine status of a population, but little is known about determinants of serum Tg levels. We examined a random selection of 4,649 subjects from 2 regions in Denmark with different iodine status. Thyroid volume and structure were determined with ultrasonography, and thyroid function tests and Tg analysis were performed.
The factor with the closest association with serum Tg levels was thyroid volume at ultrasonography (P < 0.001). Also thyroid nodularity (P < 0.001) and iodine excretion (P < 0.001) had close associations to serum Tg, even after adjusting for the influence of the other parameters. Thyroid dysfunction had a less pronounced but still highly significant association with serum Tg (P < 0.001), but no relation was found to serum TSH in general. The association with age seemed to rely on differences in the prevalence of thyroid abnormalities, and men had lower Tg levels than women of the same age. There was a marked difference in serum Tg between the two regions with slightly different iodine excretion also after adjusting for the other factors.
In conclusion, serum Tg reflects thyroid abnormalities and thyroid function and is a sensitive marker of iodine deficiency in a population.
SERUM Tg is an important marker of cancer recurrence among patients who have received ablative therapy for thyroid cancer (1, 2). The value in the diagnosis of other thyroid diseases is limited, because serum Tg is increased in almost all kinds of thyroid disease with an overlap to healthy individuals. Still, some clinical applications of serum Tg measurements have been suggested, as for instance in the diagnosis of subacute thyroiditis (3), thyrotoxicosis factitia (4, 5), or as a marker of postoperative recurrence of nontoxic goitre (6). Serum Tg levels may predict the outcome of antithyroid drug therapy in Graves disease (7, 8, 9), whereas the ability of serum Tg measurements to predict the outcome of thyroid hormone treatment of nontoxic goitre has not been convincing (10, 11).
Few studies have elucidated the epidemiology of serum Tg, and comparison of results from different studies is hampered by differences in the performance of the assays, interference with endogenous Tg antibodies (Tg Ab), and a lack of standardization, as reviewed by Spencer et al. (2). Consequently, generally accepted normal values of serum Tg have not been published, and comparisons between studies have been difficult. In comparative studies from areas with different iodine status, lower serum Tg values were reported in iodine-sufficient than in iodine-deficient areas (12, 13, 14), and serum Tg has been suggested as a marker of iodine deficiency disorders in a population (15, 16, 17, 18).
In the present study, we characterized serum Tg in a population and investigated the relative importance of thyroid volume and thyroid nodules as well as other possible factors influencing serum Tg. With the use of a sensitive immunoluminometric Tg-assay, special focus was on whether measuring serum Tg could be used to characterize the iodine status of a population in an epidemiological context.
Subjects and Methods
A population study, focusing on thyroid disease, was performed in urban areas in Copenhagen and Aalborg, 2 cities in Denmark. These locations were chosen because previous studies have shown that the western part of Denmark (Aalborg) suffers from moderate iodine deficiency and that the eastern part of Denmark (Copenhagen) suffers from mild iodine deficiency (19). The cohort comprised women in the age groups 1822, 2530, 4045, and 6065 yr; and men, 6065 yr. From the Civil Registration System in Denmark, in which all citizens are registered with a unique 10-digit number, a sample comprising all inhabitants of the 2 areas in the selected ages was drawn. These 40,233 subjects were assigned random numbers, within each group, by a computer program. The subjects were then invited in order of the random numbers until the desired number of participants was reached in each group. The subjects were invited by letter; and in case of no response, a reminder was sent. Of the 9,274 subjects invited, 4,649 participated in the examination (50.1%). The cohort has previously been described in detail (20).
The participants answered questionnaires concerning previous thyroid
disease and medication, and further information about previous thyroid
disease was obtained in an interview. Ultrasonography was performed
with high-resolution ultrasonic equipment with a 7.5-MHz 70-mm linear
transducer (Sonoline Versa Pro, Siemens, Erlangen, Germany).
Thyroid size was computed as length x width x depth of the
each lobe x
/6, as previously described (21), and
thyroid enlargement was defined as a thyroid vol exceeding 18 ml for
women and 25 ml for men (22). The number of distinct
nodules with a diameter exceeding 5 mm and the diameter of the nodules
were recorded, and the structure of the glands was accordingly
classified as regular, uninodular, or multinodular. These parameters
have previously been shown to be reproducible (21). On the
other hand, a heterogeneous echo pattern or hypoechogenecity was found
not to be reproducible between different observers, and the association
with serum Tg was not evaluated.
Blood samples were drawn and stored at -20 C and analyzed after the completion of the investigation in a sequence mixing samples from the 2 regions, subjects of different age and gender, and samples collected at different seasons. Serum Tg and TSH were analyzed with immunoluminometric assays (LUMITEST, BRAHMS, Berlin, Germany) using a Stratec autoanalyzer (STRATEC-BIOMEDICAL SYSTEM AG, Birkenfeld, Germany). The Tg assay had an effective working range of 1500 µg/liter (23). All assays included control samples at 3 levels at the start and end of each run. In 12 consecutive assays, the intraassay and interassay variations (coefficients of variation) for single determinations for controls with average Tg concentrations of 8.1, 45, and 154 µg/liter were (intra) 5.3, 2.8, and 4.2% and (inter) 6.8, 4.5, and 3.3%. The assay was calibrated by the use of an in-house standardization procedure at BRAHMS; and for comparison to CRM457 calibrated assays, the values of LUMItest should be multiplied by 1.6 (manufacturers information) (24).
Tg Ab were measured with an RIA (DYNOtest, BRAHMS, Germany) with
a functional assay sensitivity below 20 kU/liter (manufacturers
information). In Table 1
it is seen that
participants with Tg Ab levels above 20 kU/liter had an
overrepresentation of very low values of serum Tg (22.4% of
participants with serum Tg Ab > 20 kU/liter had serum Tg <
2 µg/liter, compared with 3.3% of participants with Tg Ab < 20
kU/liter). This illustrates that analytical interference was present
and underlines the importance of exclusion of Tg Ab-positive samples
from the Tg analyses.
|
Spot urine samples were collected during the time interval 0800 to 1900 h and analyzed for iodine and creatinine concentration. For the iodine analysis, the urine samples were digested by alkaline ashing and analyzed for iodine content with the Ce/As method (25), as previously described (26). The functional sensitivity of the assay was 23 µg/liter. Median urinary iodine concentration was 68 µg/liter in Copenhagen and 53 µg/liter in Aalborg; but after exclusion of subjects taking individual iodine supplementation, the figures were 61 µg/liter in Copenhagen (mild iodine deficiency) and 45 µg/liter in Aalborg (moderate iodine deficiency). Urinary creatinine concentration was analyzed with the kinetic method of Jaffe (27). Iodine excretion in the regression models was expressed as an age- and sex-adjusted iodine/creatinine ratio, because this has been shown to be an acceptable estimate of iodine excretion in individuals (28).
Statistics
All data processing was done with SPSS, Inc. version 8.0 software (SPSS Denmark, Holte, Denmark). In the linear models, factors were tested univariately and in a model including all significant factors. For analysis of continuous variables, Mann-Whitney tests and linear models were used. Because serum Tg was not normally distributed, but showed log normal distribution, logarithmic transformation was used before the linear model analyses. If interaction between terms was suspected, an interaction term was included; and in case of significant interactions, new variables, allowing analysis of the interacting terms as combined variables, were generated and included in the multivariate models.
For the estimation of the strength of the association of the different factors to serum Tg, the type III Sums of Squares in the linear models were used, univariately as well as multivariately.
Results
Distribution of serum Tg
The distribution of serum Tg values, stratified by region,
is demonstrated in Table 1
with different selection criteria. When
serum Tg was stratified by age and gender, marked regional differences
were found in all groups as shown in Fig. 1
.
|
Table 2
demonstrates the
association between serum Tg and some demographic and physiological
factors. Data are shown from a simple model where the association of
the factors are demonstrated independently from each other, as well as
from a multivariate model where adjustment is made for the impact of
the other factors. In the simple model, a significant association with
serum Tg was found for all factors in the Table
. The closest
association was found for thyroid enlargement and thyroid nodularity,
followed by iodine excretion and age- and sex-matched group.
Significant associations were also found in the multivariate model for
all factors, but the relative importance was different. Thyroid
enlargement was still the most important factor, now followed by iodine
excretion. The impact of thyroid nodules, and especially age and
gender, diminished markedly in the multivariate model. Elevated serum
TSH (>5 mU/liter) and familial occurrence of thyroid disease had no
significant impact on serum Tg in the multivariate model, and they are
not shown.
|
Iodine and serum Tg
Living in areas with slightly different iodine status still
had a significant impact on Tg levels (Table 2
), even after adjusting
for the measures of thyroid abnormalities and the estimates of iodine
excretion. The estimated daily iodine excretion also had a marked
association with serum Tg levels (Table 2
). Decreasing levels of serum
Tg were found with increasing iodine excretion ,even with estimates of
iodine excretion beyond the recommended minimum of 150250 µg/d.
A regular intake of iodine-containing vitamin tablets was
reported by 1281 participants. In most cases, the daily supplementation
was 150 µg iodine, because this is the standard in Danish
vitamin/mineral tablets; iodization of salt and other foods was not
allowed in Denmark at this time. Analyses were performed with
stratification according to the regularity of the iodine intake and the
daily dose, but no differences were detected between those groups. The
impact of iodine supplementation on serum Tg was significantly stronger
in the area with the most pronounced iodine deficiency (Fig. 2
).
|
In this comparative investigation of unselected subjects from two areas in Denmark, we report independent associations of thyroid volume, thyroid nodules, and thyroid dysfunction with levels of serum Tg. The most important predictor of serum Tg was clearly thyroid volume. Also, age and gender of the subjects had a significant relation to Tg levels, and marked regional differences in serum Tg were found in Denmark, probably conditioned by the different iodine status of the regions. The regional difference was still highly significant after adjusting for iodine excretion from casual urine samples, probably because iodine excretion in casual urine samples is a rather imprecise estimate of habitual iodine intake at the individual level (28).
Previous studies have indicated that serum Tg is increased in patients with palpable goitre and in patients with palpable nodules in the thyroid (29, 30, 31, 32). Contradictory reports have been published about the relation between thyroid volume at ultrasonography and serum Tg (33, 34, 35); this controversy might be caused by the limited number of participants in the studies or by the different iodine status of the populations. Previous studies have not been able to describe the independent influence of thyroid nodules and increased volume of the thyroid on serum Tg. We report independent and highly significant impacts on serum Tg of thyroid nodules and thyroid volume, suggesting that though the amount of thyroid tissue is important, also the structure of the thyroid tissue plays a role.
It has been shown, in a number of studies, that serum Tg is increased in Graves disease (36, 37). We report an independent association of suppressed TSH values to serum Tg, though the associated increase in thyroid volume and nodules had additional effects. This is in contrast to Szabolcs et al. (31), who found no independent effect of suppressed TSH in a small study of geriatric patients.
Controversy exists about the influence of age and gender on serum Tg, as discussed by Feldt-Rasmussen (36, 38, 39). We found clearly lower levels of serum Tg in men, also after correcting for the difference in thyroid abnormalities. This is in line with a report of increased Tg levels in women on estrogen treatment, suggesting an association to estrogen levels, though no gender difference was reported in that study (40). The effect of age was highly significant as a single factor; but adjusting for the age-related differences in the occurrence of thyroid abnormalities, the effect of age on serum Tg diminished considerably. This suggests that there may be little independent effect of age, but that the age-related increase in serum Tg may simply be reflecting the increase in thyroid abnormalities. It is consistent with the reports of no age-related differences in serum Tg in iodine-sufficient areas (39), where the prevalence of goitre is relatively constant with age.
Since the report of a correlation between serum TSH and serum Tg in an endemic goitre area (41), the role of TSH in the control of Tg synthesis has been discussed. The correlation was confirmed in areas with severe iodine deficiency (ID) (17, 18), but reports from areas with less severe ID have failed to find any correlation between serum TSH and serum Tg (30, 38), and we found no correlation over the whole range of TSH in this study. A possible explanation is that, in severe iodine deficiency, goitre is associated to increased serum TSH values. This is not the case in areas with less severe iodine deficiency, such as ours, where goitre is rather associated to low serum TSH values, probably because of autonomous areas in the gland (42).
Large differences in serum Tg were found in this study between the region with mild iodine deficiency and the region with moderate iodine deficiency, though the difference in iodine excretion was modest. The regional difference was also present after adjusting for differences in thyroid abnormalities and differences in iodine excretion. This suggests that Tg may be a sensitive and useful marker of iodine deficiency if standardized Tg assays are used. Other studies investigating regional differences in Tg in areas with more pronounced differences in iodine excretion have found large differences in serum Tg (12, 13, 18). One study indicated that abundant iodine intake may also lead to increased Tg levels, though the difference was insignificant in the small material (14). Such a tendency was not found within the range of iodine excretion in this study; serum Tg decreased with increasing iodine excretion over the whole range of iodine excretion.
The large impact of iodine supplementation on serum Tg in the area with moderate ID emphasizes the sensitivity of serum Tg as a marker of iodine deficiency. The small influence of iodine supplementation in the region with only mild iodine deficiency probably reflects Tg values closer to the optimal levels in iodine sufficiency. Thus, only little further reduction could be obtained with iodine supplementation. This was parallel to experimental data, where no effect of iodine supplementation to iodine-replete rats was seen, whereas iodine deficient rats had increased serum Tg (43). The different impact on serum Tg of iodine supplementation in the two regions also underlines the difference in thyroid physiology and pathology between areas with mild and moderate iodine deficiency.
In conclusion, serum Tg is a marker of thyroid abnormalities and thyroid dysfunction, with thyroid volume as the most important determinant. In population studies, Tg is a sensitive marker of iodine deficiency (in many situations, easier to apply than thyroid volume measurement or measurement of iodine excretion). Especially with the newer assays with better standardization, higher sensitivity, less problems with interference from Tg Ab, and increasing automation, serum Tg may be a useful tool in the monitoring of iodine status in a population.
Acknowledgments
We express our thanks to Inge-Lise Legaard and Rene Fiege, who carefully performed the ultrasonographies; and to BRAHMS, who provided the kits for the biochemical analyses at very favorable conditions.
Footnotes
This study was part of The Danish Investigation of Iodine Intake and Thyroid diseases, which was supported by grants from Tømmerhandler Vilhelm Bang Foundation, the Copenhagen Hospital Corporation Research Foundation, the 1991 Pharmacy Foundation, the Danish Medical Foundation, the Health Insurance Foundation, and North Jutland County Research Foundation.
Abbreviations: Ab, antibodies; ID, iodine deficiency.
Received January 10, 2001.
Accepted April 27, 2001.
References
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. B. Zimmermann, B. de Benoist, S. Corigliano, P. L. Jooste, L. Molinari, K. Moosa, E. A. Pretell, Z. S. Al-Dallal, Y. Wei, C. Zu-Pei, et al. Assessment of Iodine Status Using Dried Blood Spot Thyroglobulin: Development of Reference Material and Establishment of an International Reference Range in Iodine-Sufficient Children J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., December 1, 2006; 91(12): 4881 - 4887. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. D. Tronko, A. V. Brenner, V. A. Olijnyk, J. Robbins, O. V. Epstein, R. J. McConnell, T. I. Bogdanova, D. J. Fink, I. A. Likhtarev, J. H. Lubin, et al. Autoimmune Thyroiditis and Exposure to Iodine 131 in the Ukrainian Cohort Study of Thyroid Cancer and Other Thyroid Diseases after the Chornobyl Accident: Results from the First Screening Cycle (1998-2000) J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., November 1, 2006; 91(11): 4344 - 4351. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Laurberg, T. Jorgensen, H. Perrild, L. Ovesen, N. Knudsen, I. B. Pedersen, L. B Rasmussen, A. Carle, and P. Vejbjerg The Danish investigation on iodine intake and thyroid disease, DanThyr: status and perspectives. Eur. J. Endocrinol., August 1, 2006; 155(2): 219 - 228. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. B Zimmermann, D. Moretti, N. Chaouki, and T. Torresani Development of a dried whole-blood spot thyroglobulin assay and its evaluation as an indicator of thyroid status in goitrous children receiving iodized salt Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, June 1, 2003; 77(6): 1453 - 1458. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. B Rasmussen, L. Ovesen, I. Bulow, T. Jorgensen, N. Knudsen, P. Laurberg, and H. Perrild Relations between various measures of iodine intake and thyroid volume, thyroid nodularity, and serum thyroglobulin Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, November 1, 2002; 76(5): 1069 - 1076. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |