| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Endocrine Care |
Endocrine-Metabolic Service, Department of Medicine (H.B.B.), Department of Clinical Investigation (B.L.S., R.H.), and Nuclear Medicine Service, Department of Radiology (P.F.), Walter Reed Army Medical Center, Washington, D.C. 20307-5001; and Endocrinology Division, Department of Medicine, Sinai Hospital (D.S.C., N.W.), Baltimore, Maryland 20010
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Dr. Henry B. Burch, Chief, Endocrine-Metabolic Service, Department of Medicine, Walter Reed Army Medical Center, Washington, D.C. 20307-5001. E-mail: henry.burch{at}na.amedd.army.mil
Abstract
Acute changes in thyroid hormone levels before and after radioiodine therapy for Graves disease were compared in 42 patients randomized to receive either antithyroid drug pretreatment or no pretreatment. Five patients (11.9%), including 3 in the pretreatment arm and 2 in the no pretreatment arm experienced a late exacerbation of thyrotoxicosis after radioiodine therapy. The majority (19 of 21, 90.5%) of pretreated patients experienced a transient increase in free T4 and free T3 after discontinuation of antithyroid drugs, with little further elevation after radioiodine therapy. After stopping antithyroid drugs and before radioiodine administration, mean serum free T4 values rose from 14.7 ± 6.9 to 21.6 ± 12.1 pmol/L, representing a 46.9% increase, whereas serum free T3 levels rose from 4.9 ± 1.7 to 8.1 ± 6.3 pmol/L, representing a 65.3% increase. The average pretreated patient experienced a 52.4% increase [95% confidence interval (CI), +26.4% to +78.5%] in free T4 and a 61.8% increase (95% CI, +23.5% to +100.0%) in free T3. Conversely, the majority (19 of 21, 90.5%) of nonpretreated patients experienced a rapid decline in thyroid hormone levels after radioiodine treatment. Over the 14 days after radioiodine therapy mean free T4 values in nonpretreated patients fell from 85.8 ± 60.4 to 58.0 ± 76.5 pmol/L, representing a 32.4% decrease, whereas mean free T3 levels fell from 16.1 ± 8.0 to 10.8 ± 11.1 pmol/L, representing a 32.9% decrease. The average nonpretreated patient experienced a 20.6% decrease (95% CI, -47.3% to +7.0%) in free T4 and a 24.3% decrease (95% CI, -1.2% to -47.4%) in free T3 during this time period. Excluding 2 patients with a late exacerbation after radioiodine, 19 nonpretreated patients experienced a decrease in mean free T4 values from 76.8 ± 46.6 to 36.6 ± 19.8 pmol/L, representing a 52.3% decrease, whereas mean free T3 levels fell from 15.5 ± 7.7 to 7.8 ± 3.6 pmol/L, representing a 49.7% decrease. The average decrease in free T4 levels among this subgroup of patients was 30.1% (95% CI, -4.6% to -55.6%), whereas the average decrease in free T3 was 34.4% (95% CI, -13.7% to -55.1%). High levels of TSH receptor autoantibodies at diagnosis were associated with an acute worsening of thyrotoxicosis after stopping antithyroid drug pretreatment. We conclude that pretreatment with antithyroid drugs does not protect against worsening thyrotoxicosis after radioiodine, but may allow such patients to start from a lower baseline level should an aggravation in thyrotoxicosis occur. The findings support the recommendation that most patients with Graves disease do not require antithyroid drug pretreatment before receiving radioiodine.
RADIOIODINE THERAPY is the most common treatment for Graves disease employed in the United States (1). After delivery of a single intrathyroidal radiation dose approximating 15,000 rads, 8090% of treated patients will become hypothyroid over the ensuing 24 months. The effectiveness of radioiodine therapy stems from its ability to cause an intense radiation thyroiditis and subsequent fibrosis, thereby destroying the synthetic capacity of the thyroid (2). A release of stored thyroid hormone into the circulation may occur after radioiodine therapy, presumably as a result of follicular cell disruption. Worsening thyrotoxicosis and even thyroid storm have been reported after radioiodine therapy (3). As a result, many patients are given antithyroid drugs before radioiodine therapy in an attempt to prevent a transient worsening of their thyrotoxicosis. A survey of members of the American Thyroid Association found that 31% of respondents would prescribe antithyroid drugs before treatment with radioiodine (4). However, antithyroid drug therapy is associated with several potential side-effects, including rash, hepatic injury, and agranulocytosis (5). Further, pretreatment with antithyroid drugs increases the risk of radioiodine failure (6, 7, 8).
In a previous prospective nonrandomized study we found that the acute changes in thyroid hormones observed in pretreated patients receiving radioiodine occurred as a result of stopping antithyroid drugs in preparation for ablation therapy, rather than as a result of the radioiodine therapy itself (9). Specifically, an approximate doubling of free thyroid hormone levels was found to occur over the 6 days after stopping antithyroid drugs, with little further increase after radioiodine therapy. Conversely, a smaller group of nonpretreated patients experienced rapid decreases in free thyroid hormone levels after radioiodine. The aim of the present study was to examine this issue in a prospective randomized trial.
Subjects and Methods
Patients
Patients with a new diagnosis of Graves disease, defined as diffuse goiter, thyrotoxicosis, and, in most cases, elevated radioactive iodine uptake (RAIU) and positive TSH receptor autoantibodies, were approached for study entry. Patients were excluded for age less than 18 yr or greater than 65 yr, prior treatment for thyrotoxicosis, moderate to severe ophthalmopathy, and known cardiovascular disease or other significant comorbid illness. The study was approved by the investigational review boards and human use committees at the two participating centers.
Laboratory study
Free T4 was measured using direct equilibrium dialysis kits obtained from Nichols Institute Diagnostics (San Juan Capistrano, CA). Free T3 levels were measured using the Coat-A-Count direct single tube solid phase RIA supplied by Diagnostic Products (Los Angeles, CA). Serum TSH was measured using the LumaTag Chemiluminescence Immunometric Assay from London Diagnostics (Eden Prarie, MN). Luminometric readings were obtained on the AutoClinLumat LB-952 (Berthold, Inc., Nashua, NH). Serum thyroid-stimulating Ig (TSI) and TSH binding inhibitory Ig titers, were obtained in 25 and 19 patients, respectively, at the time of diagnosis or study entry and were run at Nichols Institute Diagnostics using CHO cells transfected with the complementary DNA from the TSH receptor and a RRA, respectively. RAIU, determined in 37 patients, was measured at 24 h after ingestion of 7.510.0 µCi 131I. The normal ranges were as follows: free T4, 10.330.6 pmol/L; free T3, 1.56.9 pmol/L; TSH, 0.515.0 mIU/L; TSI, less than 130%; TSH binding inhibitory Ig, less than 10%; and RAIU, 830%.
Treatment protocol
Randomization and ß-adrenergic blockade. Randomization was performed using a computerized random number generator. All patients were placed and maintained on ß-adrenergic blockers (generally atenolol, 50100 mg daily) throughout the study period.
Antithyroid drug therapy. Pretreated patients were given methimazole in a dose of 30 mg once daily, which was then adjusted based on serial thyroid function tests performed at 2-week intervals. All pretreated patients received antithyroid drugs for a minimum of 2 months and until free T4 levels were within the normal range.
Radioiodine therapy. Pretreated patients had not taken antithyroid drugs for 6 days at the time of radioiodine ablation. Nonpretreated patients generally received radioiodine ablation within 1 week of initial evaluation. The amount of radioiodine administered for treatment was determined in a nonblinded fashion (due to local policy) using a baseline dose of 15 mCi, with 515 mCi added for patients with estimated goiter size greater than 6080 g or a RAIU less than 30%, and 35 mCi subtracted for patients with estimated goiter size of less than 30 g.
Testing protocol
Baseline free T4 and free T3 were measured in pretreated patients 6 days before radioiodine therapy, which was approximately 24 h after stopping antithyroid drugs. Both pretreated and nonpretreated patients were tested on the day of radioiodine ablation and on days 1, 3, 5, 7, and 14 after receiving radioiodine.
Statistical analysis
Baseline laboratory and clinical features were compared using a
2 test for categorical variables and the
Mann-Whitney test for continuous variables. Free
T4 and free T3 values over
the study period were analyzed using ANOVA with repeated measures. To
satisfy assumptions of normality, the logarithmically transformed free
thyroid hormone values were used. As the sphericity of the data could
not be assumed, the corrected (Greenhouse-Geisser) probabilities were
used. Spearman rank coefficient was used to explore associations
between the maximum change in thyroid hormone levels and patient
demographics.
Results
Patient characteristics
Forty-four (34 women and 10 men) patients were recruited and
randomized for the study. These patients were either seen initially in
the authors practices or referred for study entry from other health
care providers at both centers. Among these, 1 patient withdrew after
deciding against radioiodine ablation, and 1 patient was excluded due
to failure to report for phlebotomy on several testing dates. No
systematic record was kept of patients who declined referral for study
involvement. A total of 42 patients (33 women and 9 men) completed the
study, including 31 patients at study site 1 (Walter Reed Army Medical
Center) and 11 patients at study site 2 (Sinai Hospital). Patient
characteristics in pretreated and nonpretreated groups are shown in
Table 1
. These groups were similar in
terms of age, gender distribution, goiter size, RAIU, and TSH receptor
antibody titers; however, nonpretreated patients had slightly higher
free T4 levels than pretreated patients at the
time of initial diagnosis.
|
Changes in free T4. Figure 1
shows changes in mean free
T4 values in the pretreated and nonpretreated
patient groups. In pretreated patients, after stopping antithyroid
drugs but before radioiodine administration, mean free
T4 levels rose significantly from 14.7 ±
6.9 to 21.6 ± 12.1 pmol/L, representing a 46.9% increase in mean
values (P < 0.0005). The average pretreated patient
experienced a 52.4% increase (95% CI, +26.4% to +78.5%) in free
T4 during this time period, with peak free
T4 obtained on day 3 after radioiodine. The upper
limit of normal for free T4 was exceeded in
23.8% of patients before receiving radioiodine and in 33.3% of
patients 1 day after radioiodine. The additional increase in thyroid
hormone levels occurring after radioiodine did not achieve
significance. After attaining peak values, there was a rapid and
significant decrease in mean free T4 levels into
the mid-normal ranges.
|
Changes in free T3. Free
T3 levels rose more rapidly and to a greater
extent and showed an earlier peak than free T4
levels after cessation of antithyroid drugs. Figure 2
shows changes in mean free
T3 values in pretreated and nonpretreated
patients. In pretreated patients, after stopping antithyroid drugs and
before radioiodine administration, mean free T3
levels rose significantly from 4.9 ± 1.7 to 8.1 ± 6.3
pmol/L, representing a 65.3% increase in mean values
(P < 0.005). The average pretreated patient
experienced a 61.8% increase (95% CI, +23.5% to +100.0%) in free
T3 during this time period, peaking 1 day after
radioiodine. The upper limit of normal for free
T3 was exceeded in 38.1% of patients before
receiving radioiodine and in 42.9% of patients 1 day after
radioiodine.
|
Comparison of the rates of change in pretreated and nonpretreated patients. As expected, mean free T4 and free T3 levels were higher in the nonpretreated patients at each time point in the study. The rate of improvement in free T4 levels over the 2 weeks following radioiodine ablation was greater in nonpretreated patients than in pretreated patients (P = 0.041), but the rates of change in free T3 were similar in the two groups (P = 0.36).
Individual patient data. Analysis of individual patient data
showed that a small subset of patients (three pretreated and two
nonpretreated patients) experienced a continuous rise in thyroid
hormone levels throughout the study period after receiving radioiodine
therapy (Fig. 3
). One nonpretreated
patient in this category had refractory hyperthyroidism and ultimately
required three doses of radioiodine for control. One pretreated patient
with worsening thyrotoxicosis after radioiodine was placed back on
antithyroid drugs and ultimately required a second dose of radioiodine
before becoming hypothyroid. The three remaining patients with
worsening thyrotoxicosis after radioiodine treatment, including one
nonpretreated and two pretreated patients, became hypothyroid within 2
months of receiving radioiodine.
|
Patient clinical and laboratory features were examined for
associations with the acute rise in thyroid hormone levels in the
pretreatment group and in patients experiencing late worsening of
thyrotoxicosis after radioiodine. Table 2
summarizes the associations examined and findings in pretreated
patients. In these patients, TSI titers were positively correlated with
increases in free T4 (P = 0.024)
and free T3 (P = 0.001) after
stopping antithyroid drugs. No correlation was found for patient age,
gender, goiter size, RAIU, or thyroid hormone levels at diagnosis.
Figure 4
shows the relationship between
TSI titers and change in free T3 values in
pretreated patients. It is of note that TSI titers were lower than the
reported upper limit of normal of 130% in eight of these patients,
which is in keeping with our previous observations on the current
sensitivity of this assay (10). In five patients
experiencing worsening thyrotoxicosis after radioiodine therapy, only
male gender was significantly associated, with three of five (60%)
patients being males compared with an overall male representation in
the study of only 21% (P = 0.03).
|
|
The rationale generally given for pretreatment with antithyroid drugs before radioiodine is to deplete thyroid hormone stores and theoretically reduce the risk of worsening thyrotoxicosis or even thyroid storm after radioiodine therapy (11). However, the risk of aggravating thyrotoxicosis after radioiodine for thyrotoxicosis is probably small, and it is not clear whether this risk is diminished by pretreatment with antithyroid drugs. McDermott and colleagues reviewed the medical literature with reference to cases of thyroid storm after radioiodine therapy for thyrotoxicosis (3). These researchers found that 0.34% of 2975 patients treated with radioiodine for thyrotoxicosis experienced thyroid storm, and 0.88% experienced moderate or severe exacerbation of thyrotoxicosis (3). Approximately half of the cases reviewed by these researchers were pretreated with antithyroid drugs before receiving radioiodine, although not all of these patients were known to be euthyroid before antithyroid drug discontinuation.
Data available from nonrandomized trials in this area are somewhat conflicting. Maloof and Chapman did not find aggravation of disease after radioiodine therapy in 47 patients with cardiac manifestations of thyrotoxicosis, only 2 of whom had received antithyroid drug pretreatment (12). Wise and colleagues found an early fall in thyroid hormone levels in each of 50 patients with Graves disease treated with 1015 mCi radioiodine without antithyroid drug pretreatment (13). Creutzig and colleagues followed 46 hyperthyroid patients with diffuse goiter receiving radioiodine without antithyroid drug pretreatment and noted only slight increases in serum T3 levels for the group as a whole, occurring 1 day after radioiodine therapy (14). Interestingly, progressive worsening of thyrotoxicosis occurred in 3 of 46 (7%) patients after radioiodine therapy, and was not related to goiter size or the dose of radioiodine delivered (14). More recently, Graves disease patients assessed with thyroid function testing every 2 weeks after ablation therapy were noted to sustain transient increases in free T4 levels at 46 weeks in 36% of nonpretreated patients and earlier increases at 2 weeks in 53% of pretreated patients (15). Another nonrandomized study noted asymptomatic increases in thyroid hormone levels in 29% of 21 patients with Graves disease receiving radioiodine without antithyroid drug pretreatment, although the magnitude of this change was not given, and mean thyroid hormone levels actually decreased immediately after radioiodine (16). In summary, the published literature suggests that worsening thyrotoxicosis after radioiodine is rare, and when it does occur, it is generally subclinical.
Another rationale for the use of antithyroid drug pretreatment before radioiodine for Graves disease is the belief that a more rapid control of thyrotoxicosis may be obtained after radioiodine therapy (17, 18). However, this fails to take into account the weeks or months of pretreatment during which time the patient has persistent thyrotoxicosis. Further, data previously published by us (9) and others (17) shows a rapid decrease in thyroid hormone levels after radioiodine therapy in nonpretreated patients. This rapid response may in part reflect the use of larger, ablative doses of radioiodine rather than smaller doses in an attempt to restore euthyroidism. Therefore, this second rationale for pretreatment with antithyroid drugs is not supported by published data.
In addition to a lack of proven benefit, pretreatment with antithyroid drugs before radioiodine may lead to unwanted effects, such as an increased risk of radioiodine failure (6, 7, 8) and worsening thyrotoxicosis after abrupt discontinuation of these medications in preparation for radioiodine (19). A recent study has suggested that radioiodine failure after antithyroid drug pretreatment may be more problematic with the use of propylthiouracil than with methimazole (20). As antithyroid drugs irreversibly inhibit thyroid peroxidase (21), they are generally stopped several days before radioiodine administration to allow incorporation of this isotope into thyroid hormone (5). Attempts to administer radioiodine therapy without stopping antithyroid drugs have resulted in treatment failure rates approaching 90% (22).
Our earlier prospective nonrandomized study (9) disclosed remarkably similar results to those of the present prospective randomized trial, although the former study was designed primarily to investigate acute changes occurring in pretreated patients. A study similar to ours was recently reported by Andrade and colleagues, in which patients received either methimazole or no pretreatment before radioiodine therapy (17). As in our study, Andrade and colleagues noted a small group of patients with worsening thyrotoxicosis after radioiodine therapy in 13.0% and 7.1% of the pretreated and nonpretreated groups, respectively. Unlike our current study, Andrade and colleagues failed to detect any association between clinical or laboratory parameters and changes in thyroid hormone levels after stopping antithyroid drugs (17).
When is pretreatment helpful or warranted? As worsening thyrotoxicosis after radioiodine therapy occurred in approximately 10% of patients with or without pretreatment, it is apparent that pretreatment did not prevent this exacerbation. However, pretreatment did allow such patients to start from a lower baseline value, making it less likely that a theoretical decompensation threshold would be reached. Conversely, it could be argued that the most rapid increase in thyroid hormone levels occurred after stopping antithyroid drug pretreatment. Further, many known precipitants of thyroid storm, such as discontinuation of antithyroid drugs, thyroidectomy, radioiodine therapy, and vigorous palpation of the thyroid, lead to systemic decompensation through this mechanism (19). It is not known which of these two situations presents the greatest threat to the patient. Another consideration involves a comparison of the total duration of thyrotoxicosis in pretreated and nonpretreated patients. Although this was not a specific end point in our study, our data show that mean free T4 and mean free T3 levels in nonpretreated patients rapidly approached the normal range over the 14-day period that followed radioiodine administration. Conversely, pretreated patients generally required 48 weeks or more to establish euthyroidism before becoming eligible for radioiodine. The delay in correction of thyrotoxicosis imposed by pretreatment rather than direct radioiodine ablation represents a window during which pretreated patients are at risk for ill effects from thyrotoxicosis, including atrial fibrillation and associated embolic phenomenon.
Our study did not include a comparison of symptom scores in the two treatment arms; however, both the previous study by our group (9) and the study by Andrade and colleagues (17) failed to find significant correlations between symptoms and thyroid hormone changes after stopping antithyroid drugs in pretreated patients. It is likely that the ß-adrenergic blockade therapy used in both studies significantly attenuated the change in symptoms that might have otherwise occurred (23). The radioiodine dosage in our study was selected empirically rather than on the basis of dosimetry (24) or exact measurement of thyroid volume. Our rationale for this was 2-fold. First, it was our intention to simulate current clinical practice. Eighty-five percent of respondents to a survey of American Thyroid Association members used a semiquantitative approach similar to ours for radioiodine dose selection in patients with Graves disease (4). Second, it has been repeatedly demonstrated that complex dosimetric techniques fail to reliably determine a set delivered tissue dose of radioactivity to the thyroid (24, 25, 26), due to as much as 45% patient-to-patient variability in radioiodine organification, which cannot be predicted on the basis of either gland size or RAIU (25). A recent comparison of a fixed dose of radioiodine (15 mCi) to a calculated dose designed to deliver 100 Gy to the thyroid found a success rate of 71% using a fixed dose compared with only 58% using a calculated dose (26). Although thyroid size was estimated on the basis of examination by an experienced thyroidologist at both study sites, intersite reproducibility was not specifically assessed.
In summary, pretreatment with antithyroid drugs before radioiodine ablation therapy results in a rapid increase in thyroid hormone levels upon stopping these medications in preparation for radioiodine. Direct use of radioiodine without pretreatment results in a rapid reduction in thyroid hormone levels, often approaching the normal range within 2 weeks of therapy. Pretreatment with antithyroid drugs does not protect against worsening thyrotoxicosis after radioiodine therapy, but allows such patients to start from a lower baseline value. It is our opinion, therefore, that most patients with Graves disease should not be pretreated with antithyroid drugs before receiving radioiodine. Whether patients with underlying coronary artery disease or other comorbid conditions benefit from pretreatment is not known, because, on the one hand, pretreatment exposes these patients to the risk of prolonged hyperthyroidism as well as an acute rise in free hormone levels after stopping antithyroid drugs, whereas, on the other hand, pretreatment provides a measure of protection by establishing lower baseline values should an exacerbation occur.
Acknowledgments
We acknowledge Drs. Michael J. Brennan, Carla Iudica-Souza, Teresa Jacques, R. Michael Tuttle, and Susan Wingo for patient referral, and Ms. Tracey Butcher for specimen collection and processing.
Footnotes
1 The opinions expressed in this publication are the personal views
of the authors and do not represent official policy of the United
States Army or the Department of Defense. ![]()
Received December 14, 2000.
Revised February 14, 2001.
Revised March 26, 2001.
Accepted March 28, 2001.
References
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. Toft and T. C Sandeep Radioiodine treatment of hyperthyroidism BMJ, March 10, 2007; 334(7592): 483 - 484. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. J. Bonnema, F. N. Bennedbaek, A. Veje, J. Marving, and L. Hegedus Continuous Methimazole Therapy and Its Effect on the Cure Rate of Hyperthyroidism Using Radioactive Iodine: An Evaluation by a Randomized Trial J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., August 1, 2006; 91(8): 2946 - 2951. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Bartalena, F. Bogazzi, A. Pinchera, and E. Martino Treatment with Thionamides before Radioiodine Therapy for Hyperthyroidism: Yes or No? J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., February 1, 2005; 90(2): 1256 - 1256. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. J. Bonnema and L. Hegedus Authors' Response: Treatment with Thionamides before Radioiodine Therapy for Hyperthyroidism: Yes or No? J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., February 1, 2005; 90(2): 1256 - 1257. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. J. Bonnema, F. N. Bennedbaek, A. Veje, J. Marving, and L. Hegedus Propylthiouracil before 131I Therapy of Hyperthyroid Diseases: Effect on Cure Rate Evaluated by a Randomized Clinical Trial J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., September 1, 2004; 89(9): 4439 - 4444. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. S. Cooper Antithyroid Drugs in the Management of Patients with Graves' Disease: An Evidence-Based Approach to Therapeutic Controversies J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., August 1, 2003; 88(8): 3474 - 3481. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Ginsberg Diagnosis and management of Graves' disease Can. Med. Assoc. J., March 4, 2003; 168(5): 575 - 585. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
F. Bogazzi, L. Bartalena, A. Campomori, S. Brogioni, C. Traino, F. De Martino, G. Rossi, F. Lippi, A. Pinchera, and E. Martino Treatment with Lithium Prevents Serum Thyroid Hormone Increase after Thionamide Withdrawal and Radioiodine Therapy in Patients with Graves' Disease J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., October 1, 2002; 87(10): 4490 - 4495. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Is Pretreatment Necessary Before 131I Ablation for Graves' Disease? Journal Watch (General), July 31, 2001; 2001(731): 4 - 4. [Full Text] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |