| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Original Studies |
Mercers Institute for Research in Aging (C.J.C., A.D., J.B.W., R.O., D.C., R.F.C., B.A.L., D.D.O.) and Central Pathology Laboratory (M.S.), St. James Hospital, Dublin 8; and Department of Clinical Pharmacology (M.R.), Trinity College, Dublin, Ireland
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Dr. C. J. Cunningham, Mercers Institute for Research in Aging, St. James Hospital, Dublin 8, Ireland. E-mail: ccunningham{at}stjames.ie
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cross-sectional studies can only allow estimation of the risk of developing AD if the risk factor in question remains stable before and after a person develops the disease (specifically, in this case, if serum estrogen levels are unaltered by developing AD). This may not be the case. Postmenopausal women with acute illnesses (11) and insulin-dependent diabetes (12) have been shown to have higher serum estrogen levels. Given that circulating estrogen is formed postmenopausally by metabolism of adrenal and gonadal steroids (8) and that AD is associated with a disorder of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis (13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18), the possibility that AD might be associated with an alteration in estrogen production must also be considered.
Our objective was to determine whether total serum levels of the two estrogen subtypes (estrone and estradiol) or their precursors (androstenedione and testosterone) were altered in Alzheimers disease, having controlled for all relevant confounding factors.
| Subjects and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cases (52 subjects) were consecutive referrals to an out-patient memory clinic who met National Institute of Neurological and Communicative Disorders and Stroke/Alzheimers Disease and Related Disorders Association (21) and Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (20) criteria for probable Alzheimers disease. Detailed neuropsychological testing and neuroimaging were used to establish diagnosis in all cases (22). Patients with severe dementia [Mini Mental State Examination (23) (MMSE) score of 14 or less] were excluded because of the difficulty in excluding depression in these circumstances.
All subjects (cases and controls) were administered the 30-item Geriatric Depression Scale (24) (GDS). This scale has been validated in mild to moderate dementia (25, 26, 27, 28) and was included to allow any effects on mood to be determined.
Controls (60 cases) were a convenience sample recruited from local active retirement groups in the catchment area of the memory clinic who were neither cognitively impaired [defined as MMSE (23) score <24] nor depressed (DSM IV criteria).
The approval of the joint research ethics committee of the Federated Dublin Voluntary Hospitals for this study was granted, and all participants (plus their caregivers in demented groups) signed informed written consent, according to the Helsinki II Declaration, at study outset.
Serum was collected from each subject between 0900 and 1400 h and stored at -20 C until analyzed. Total serum levels of estrone, androstenedione, and testosterone were determined by RIA, and levels of estradiol and cortisol were determined by time-resolved fluoroimmunoassay. Total serum cortisol was included as an index of HPA activity. The endocrine laboratory at Hammersmith Hospital (London, UK) performed the estrone assay. The other assays were performed by the endocrine laboratory at St. James Hospital (Dublin, Ireland). Serum estrone was measured using ether extraction followed by RIA with [3H]estrone tracer and charcoal separation. The detection limit was 40 pmol/L, the intraassay coefficient of variation (CV) at low levels was 8.1%, and the interassay CV was 13%. Cross-reactivities at the 50% inhibition level were: with estradiol, 0.18%; with androstenedione, less than 0.01%; with testosterone, less than 0.01%; and with cortisol; less than 0.01%. Recovery rates after spiking serum samples with varying levels of estrone ranged from 92105%. Serum estradiol was measured using an AutoDELFIA estradiol kit (Wallac Ltd., c/o United Drug PLC, Dublin, Ireland) [detection limit, 40 pmol/L; intraassay CV, 4.4%; interassay CV, 6.9%; cross-reactivity (50% inhibition level) with estrone, 0.75%; cross-reactivity with androstenedione, <0.001%; cross-reactivity with testosterone, <0.01%; cross-reactivity with cortisol, <0.001%; recovery rate, 86112%]. Serum androstenedione was measured using a Coat-A-Count androstenedione RIA kit (ICN Pharmaceuticals Ireland, Oxon, UK) [detection limit, 0.7 nmol/L; intraassay CV, 5.5%; interassay CV, 8.8%; cross reactivity (50% inhibition level) with estrone, 0.75% cross-reactivity with estradiol, <0.001%; cross-reactivity with testosterone, 0.2%; cross-reactivity with cortisol, 0.02%; recovery rate, 84115%]. Serum testosterone was measured using a Testo-CT2 RIA kit (Electramed Ltd., Dublin, Ireland) [detection limit, 0.5 nmol/L; intraassay CV, 4.6%; interassay CV, 4.9%%; cross reactivity (50% inhibition level) with estrone, <0.01%; cross-reactivity with estradiol, <0.01%; cross-reactivity with androstenedione, <0.01%; cross-reactivity with cortisol, <0.01%; recovery rate, 90110%]. Serum cortisol was measured using an AutoDELFIA cortisol kit (Wallac Ltd.) [detection limit, 15 nmol/L; intraassay CV, 3.1%; interassay CV, 1.4%; cross-reactivity (50% inhibition level) with estrone, <0.1%; cross-reactivity with estradiol, <0.1%; cross-reactivity with androstenedione, <0.1%; cross-reactivity with testosterone, 0.3%; recovery rate, 94107%].
During their visit, subjects (or the main caregiver in the case of demented patients) completed a rater-administered questionnaire that included information about age, years of education, past and current medical history, medication, cigarette-smoking history, and alcohol intake (units of alcohol in past year was estimated by asking how much alcohol consumed on the average per month and multiplied by 12). Medications were recorded if they were taken more than three times a week and were classified according to the British National Formulary (29). Weight (in light clothes without shoes) was measured using an electronic scale accurate to 0.5 kg, and height was measured using a wall-mounted scale accurate to 1 mm. Body mass index (BMI; weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared) was calculated. Time of assessment was noted.
Undetectable hormone levels occurred in 35.7% (40 of 112) of cases for estradiol (18 of 52 cases and 22 of 60 controls), 1.8% (2 of 112) of cases for androstenedione, and 0.9% (1 of 112) of cases for testosterone. Detectable estrone and cortisol were found in all cases. Undetectable hormone levels were analyzed as occurring at the lower detection limit.
Group differences were analyzed using the Mann-Whitney U test for
continuous variables and
2 or Fishers exact
test for categorical variables. Alcohol intake and time of sample were
analyzed by tertile for the multivariate analyses (the lowest tertile
was compared with the other two tertiles in each case).
For each of the four sex hormones a linear regression model was constructed. The dependent variable was the serum hormone level, and the independent variable was group membership (AD, n = 1; controls, n = 0). Log transformation of hormone values was used in all regression analyses. The effects of confounding were adjusted for by using as control variables: age, BMI, alcohol intake, time of sample, medication use that differed significantly between the groups (use of a medication was coded as 1, nonuse was coded as 0), cigarette smoking (current smoker = 1, past or never smoked = 0), and serum cortisol level in a series of multivariate regression analyses. Due to the importance of adipose tissue in the production of postmenopausal estrogens a subanalysis was performed using only subjects whose BMI could be matched within 2 kg/m2 of each other. There were 74 subjects (37 in each group) in this analysis. Hormone levels were compared between groups in a manner similar to the main analysis (because of the smaller sample size the number of confounders adjusted for was reduced to age, alcohol intake, and cortisol level).
The assumptions of each model were checked by examining the residuals
for normality and constancy of spread. All significance levels reported
are two-sided (
set at 0.05), and all analyses were performed using
Datadesk 5.0 software (Data Description, Inc., Ithaca, NY).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Differences in hormone levels between groups are shown in Table 2
. Estrone and androstenedione levels
were significantly (P < 0.05) higher in the demented
group. After adjusting for age, BMI, cortisol level, alcohol intake,
time of sample, cigarette smoking, and use of medications that differed
between groups, the differences for estrone and androstenedione
remained significant. As a single measure of cortisol is an unreliable
measure of HPA axis activity, all analyses were repeated after omitting
cortisol as a control variable. Results were unchanged, with estrone
(ß = 0.17; SE = 0.061; P =
0.0072) and androstenedione (ß = 0.24; SE
= 0.11; P = 0.025) remaining significantly different
between groups.
|
A subanalysis was performed using only subjects whose BMI could be
matched within 2 kg/m2 of each other. The results
are shown in Table 3
. Levels of estrone
and androstenedione continued to be significantly higher in subjects
with AD. Spearmans nonparametric rank correlation method was used to
determine whether MMSE or GDS scores correlated with hormone levels in
either group. Apart from a single negative association between the
serum cortisol level in the AD group and the GDS score (
=
-0.33; P = 0.020), there were no significant
correlations.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This study has several limitations that need to be considered before the results are discussed. The study was based on a convenience sample. Both cases and controls were community dwelling and were recruited from the same geographical area, and results were adjusted for all factors known to be associated with hormone levels or that differed between groups, but the influence of unknown and unmeasured factors on hormone levels cannot be determined. Hormone levels were based on a single morning sample, which may have obscured the findings with respect to some hormones. This is particularly true for pulsatile hormones such as cortisol. It is worth noting, however, that a 3-yr study looking at the reproducibility of endogenous sex hormones found that intraindividual changes were minimal (10). Serum samples were frozen immediately after sampling and kept for up to 6 months. Although it is possible that changes in hormone values due to storage may have occurred, other researchers have shown that serum levels of steroid hormones are relatively stable when frozen in polypropylene tubes over periods of 310 yr (31, 32). Undetectable estradiol occurred in about a third of cases. Although this was akin to the findings of others (33, 34) studying similar postmenopausal populations, it does tend to limit the conclusions that can be drawn for this hormone.
Our results disagree with the recent findings of Manly et al. (35), who found that 50 women with AD had lower serum estradiol levels than 93 control subjects after (and before) adjusting for a variety of potential confounds. However, alcohol intake was not adjusted for in their analyses [there is some evidence that subjects with a regular alcohol intake have significantly higher serum estradiol levels (36)]. It is possible, therefore, that the lower estradiol levels found in their demented subjects reflected a lower alcohol intake among this group. In addition, although subjects using estrogen replacement were excluded, the highest estradiol level noted in their subjects (277 pmol/L) was considerably higher than would be expected in a postmenopausal population (usually <100 pmol/L), suggesting that there may have been some inadvertent use of estrogen replacement by some of the subjects. Lastly, their subject group was ethnically quite diverse, with a majority of subjects being black or Hispanic, whereas all of our subjects were Caucasian. For these reasons, a direct comparison with our results is problematic.
There are several reasons why serum estrogen or its precursors might have been elevated in our subjects with AD. Higher levels of estrogen might be damaging and increase the risk of developing AD. This is biologically implausible given a range of studies showing that estrogen prevents hippocampal degeneration by toxins (37, 38, 39), increases hippocampal synaptic density (40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45), converts amyloid to a less toxic form (46), and improves verbal memory (47, 48, 49) as well as the aforementioned epidemiological studies showing reduced prevalence of AD in women taking estrogen replacement .Another explanation is that the hormones we are measuring are predominantly subtypes with antagonistic properties. For example, estrone has a C-2 hydroxylated subtype that is a competitive inhibitor of estradiol (50, 51, 52). Although this might explain an elevated estrone level in this context, it fails to explain the elevation in androstenedione found in this study. A third explanation and the one that is probably more likely is that some factor that differed systematically between the groups is responsible. The finding of higher sex hormone levels remained after adjustment for multiple demographic and biological factors. This suggests that variations in these factors between the groups was not responsible for the difference in hormone levels. The possibility that AD itself was responsible for the higher sex hormone levels must therefore be considered, although this will need to be confirmed in subsequent studies.
The finding of higher estrone, but not estradiol, levels may represent a true difference between estrogen subtypes or a lesser ability of a single measurement of serum estradiol to reflect average levels throughout the day (53, 54). It may also reflect the lower sensitivity of the estradiol assay used in this study. Variations in sex hormones were not associated with mood (as assessed by the GDS) or cognition (as assessed by the MMSE) for either group. This replicates the recent findings in two large cohorts of nondemented postmenopausal women that found no association between serum estrogens and mood (34, 55) or cognition (34) and extends them to our group with AD. The significant univariate relationship between serum cortisol and GDS score in subjects with AD is not explained by existing theory and is probably spurious. There were 20 univariate analyses in all, and 1 false positive finding would not be unexpected.
In conclusion, levels of the estrogen subtype estrone and its precursor androstenedione were significantly higher in subjects with AD than in controls after adjusting for a variety of demographic and biological factors (including cortisol). This raises the possibility of an abnormality of sex steroid production in AD that warrants further research.
Received March 4, 2000.
Revised September 5, 2000.
Revised October 31, 2000.
Accepted November 6, 2000.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
K. M. Webber, G. Perry, M. A. Smith, and G. Casadesus The Contribution of Luteinizing Hormone to Alzheimer Disease Pathogenesis Clin. Med. Res., October 1, 2007; 5(3): 177 - 183. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. Ravaglia, P. Forti, F. Maioli, L. Bastagli, F. Montesi, N. Pisacane, M. Chiappelli, F. Licastro, and C. Patterson Endogenous Sex Hormones as Risk Factors for Dementia in Elderly Men and Women J. Gerontol. A Biol. Sci. Med. Sci., September 1, 2007; 62(9): 1035 - 1041. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. S. Lee, B. Ettinger, F. Z. Stanczyk, E. Vittinghoff, V. Hanes, J. A. Cauley, W. Chandler, J. Settlage, M. S. Beattie, E. Folkerd, et al. Comparison of Methods to Measure Low Serum Estradiol Levels in Postmenopausal Women J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., October 1, 2006; 91(10): 3791 - 3797. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |