| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Other Original Articles |
-Dihydroprogesterone in Depressed Patients during the Latter Half of Pregnancy
Psychoendocrinology Unit, Allan Memorial Institute (B.E.P.M., F.-Y.H., C.M.A.), Departments of Psychiatry (B.E.P.M., S.I.S., C.M.A.), Obstetrics & Gynecology (B.E.P.M.), and Medicine (B.E.P.M.), McGill University, Montréal, Québec, Canada H3G 1A4
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Beverley E. Pearson Murphy, M.D., Ph.D., Psychoendocrinology Unit, 1033 Pine Avenue, West Montréal, Québec, Canada H3A 1A1. E-mail: bev. murphy{at}mcgill.ca
Abstract
Progesterone and its 5
reduced metabolite,
5
-dihydroprogesterone, rise greatly in pregnancy. Both are known to
have anesthetic properties, as do a number of other ring A-reduced
progesterone metabolites. The possible significance of these steroids
with respect to the mood changes that are common in pregnancy and in
the puerperium has not been explored. In this study, pregnenolone,
progesterone, and five neuroactive progesterone metabolites: the 5
and 5ß dihydroprogesterones (DHP), and three tetrahydroprogesterones
(THP)3
,5
-THP, 3ß,5ß-THP, and 3ß,5
-THPwere studied at
various stages of pregnancy and in the early postpartum period.
Levels of all of the steroids rose greatly during pregnancy
(P < 0.001), being highest for progesterone
(562-fold the follicular level), 5
-DHP (161-fold), 3ß,5
-THP
(56-fold), 3
,5
-THP (37-fold), pregnenolone (30-fold), 5ßDHP
(16-fold) and 3ß,5ß-THP (16-fold) at 37 wk of gestation. During the
period 27 d postpartum, the level of progesterone fell precipitously,
whereas those of pregnenolone and the metabolites fell more slowly and
mean levels were still elevated compared with follicular levels 2 wk
after delivery. By 7 wk postpartum, only
3
,5
-tetrahydroprogesterone and 3ß,5ß-tetrahydroprogesterone
remained slightly elevated (P
0.012 and 0.007,
respectively).
Mean levels of the progesterone metabolites tended to be higher in
depressed patients compared with controls, and this difference reached
significance for 5
-dihydroprogesterone both at 27 wk
(P = 0.04) and at 37 wk (P =
0.02) of gestation (combined, P = 0.003).
These results show that all five of these metabolites rise markedly during pregnancy and suggest that alterations in progesterone metabolites may be involved in the mood changes of pregnancy and the puerperium.
THE TERM "neuroactive steroids" as used here refers to steroids that are active on neural tissue and that may be synthesized endogenously in the brain itself (neurosteroids) or elsewhere in the body. Pregnenolone is the precursor of all mammalian steroid hormones, being produced by the adrenal cortex, the ovary, the testis, the placenta, and by the brain itself. These tissues produce a variety of corticoids, progestins, androgens, and estrogens, and also the lesser known group of "anesthetic steroids" (neuroactive A-ring reduced steroids, NARS), whose physiological significance is still unknown.
It has been recognized for more than 50 yr that, when injected as a
bolus, many of the ring A-reduced metabolites of progesterone have
potent direct (nongenomic) effects on the brains of mammals, and indeed
are among the most powerful anesthetics known (1, 2, 3, 4);
however their blood levels are low, and their measurement is difficult.
Interest in these compounds increased recently, when some of them, such
as allopregnanolone (for structures and abbreviations of the steroids
measured, see Table 1
) were shown to bind
stereoselectively and with high affinity to receptors for
-aminobutyric acid (GABA), the major inhibitory neurotransmitter
in brain; they are thought to affect cognition, memory, and mood (for
reviews, see Refs. 5, 6). Others may be GABA receptor
antagonists (7, 8). The pathways of steroid synthesis and
metabolism are complex, so that changes in the availability of one
steroid hormone may alter both the production and the route of
metabolism of others through competition for enzymes and induction of
enzymes. This means that lack of direct correlation between alterations
of the principal steroid hormones and pathology does not preclude a
major etiological role for steroids.
|
The aim of this study was to document levels of pregnenolone and
progesterone and five of its neuroactive metabolites during pregnancy
and the puerperium, using a method described recently (9).
Pregnenolone, the precursor of progesterone, was also measured. In
addition, patients with no previous history of mental problems who
became depressed during pregnancy were also studied and showed
elevations of 5
-dihydroprogesterone. These data were reported in
part at the Annual Meeting of The Endocrine Society
(10).
Subjects and Methods
Subjects
The patients in this study were drawn from a group of 203 healthy women, with no previous history of mental problems of any kind and not in high-risk obstetrical categories, recruited during pregnancy and followed to delivery and for several weeks following. Most were seen at 2628 wk gestation, 3638 wk gestation, at 27 d after delivery, and at 2 wk (1318 d) and 6 wk (4258 d) postpartum. A few were seen in early pregnancy, at 1119 wk. Data for 155 women regarding changes in mood, life stress measures, plasma tryptophan concentrations and platelet imipramine binding will be presented elsewhere (Steinberg, S. I., L. Annable, S. N. Young, J. Martial, N. Liyanage, D. Ramdoyal, S. Mainville, and F. Roule, in preparation). When seen, blood samples were obtained if possible.
Each subject underwent a physical examination and a structured psychiatric clinical interview (11) to exclude physical and psychiatric illness. Results for a limited number of those remaining physically well throughout and immediately following pregnancy are reported here, as well as those for women who became depressed during or following pregnancy. Because samples were not available for all women at all visits, this is not strictly a longitudinal study, although in some cases subjects were studied more than once. Samples for nonpregnant women in the follicular and/or luteal phase were collected from healthy women, with regular menstrual periods, who were not taking medications.
For the pregnant patients, inclusion criteria were: age between 21 and 45 yr; in good physical health; pregnancy confirmed by the obstetrician; involved in a stable relationship with the father of the child. Excluded were: women in high risk obstetrical categories; those with a current or previous documented DSM III-R Axis I diagnosis (12); those with a requirement for medication other than the usual vitamin preparations prescribed during pregnancy. All subjects gave written informed consent to participate in the study, which was approved by the Research Ethics Board of St. Marys Hospital, where the patients delivered.
Psychological assessments
Various rating scales were completed at each visit. Those used
here included the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (Ham-D)
(13), the Maternity Blues Scale of Kennerley and Gath
(14), and the SCL-90-R scale of Derogatis et
al. (15). The Ham-D was modified for pregnancy so
that the items concerning weight loss and somatic manifestations such
as backache, gastrointestinal disturbances, and urinary frequency,
which are common in pregnancy, were not scored. Control subjects were
chosen who had a Ham-D score
7.
The criteria for maternity blues used here required a score of 12 or
greater on the 28-item Blues scale within the period of 27 d
following delivery; controls were chosen with a score
7.
Mood in nonpregnant subjects was assessed using the self-rating SCL-90 questionnaire, which we have found to correlate well with the Ham-D. None had a depression rating above 6. Patients in early pregnancy were assessed using a similar scale modified for pregnancy.
Patient sampling
Among the 12 subjects studied at 1219 wk, none met the
criteria for depression. At 2628 wk gestation, samples were available
for nine depressed subjects as defined by a modified Ham-D
13.
They were compared with 12 control subjects selected randomly from the
available samples for women who had Ham-Ds less than 6. At 3638 wk,
samples on six depressed subjects were available; they were compared
with nine controls chosen as above. During the early postpartum period
samples on five patients with Blues were available, and were compared
with ten controls, while at 2 wk postpartum, five depressed patients
were compared with 11 controls. Two of the patients sampled were
depressed both at 27and at 37 wk gestation, and also suffered from the
"blues"; one other was depressed only by 37 wk and also suffered
from "blues." Unfortunately, many patients failed to arrive for
their postpartum visits, and at 7 wk samples were only available on
five controls. Fewer postpartum samples were usable than expected
because some of the samples had insufficient volume for the larger
sample size required in nonpregnant subjects (preferably 6 ml of
plasma, for duplicate assays).
Heparinized blood samples were taken in the morning at 09001000 h, and the plasma was separated, frozen, and stored at -20 C until assayed. Six samples were also taken without heparin and the results compared; no differences were observed.
Determination of levels of progesterone and its metabolites
This method has recently been described in detail (9). Briefly, after addition of tracer tritiated progesterone (about 3000 cpm), an aliquot of plasma (0.50 ml in early pregnancy, 0.10 ml in late pregnancy, and 1.03.0 ml postpartum) was extracted with toluene, and the organic phase dried. The extract was redissolved in methylene chloride and passed through HPLC. The exclusion volume was approximately 0.5 ml. The eluate was split, one-third collected into counting vials for determination of recovery, and the remaining two-thirds was collected into 50 assay tubes for RIA. Because of the very high progesterone levels, the tubes containing the progesterone were diluted so that only 1/10 was assayed. Each sample was carried through the whole procedure at least twice, and the mean values analyzed.
Recoveries of tracer progesterone averaged about 50%. For 28 samples,
a tracer of tritiated 3
,5
-THP was run simultaneously; the
recovery averaged 50.5% for progesterone and 50.7% for 3
,5
-THP,
and the SD for the two tracers was ± 2.9%. The
coefficients of variation of the final values for the metabolites
varied from ± 11% for levels over 40 ng/ml to ± 20% for
those below 0.5 ng/ml. Sensitivity was 7 pg for 3ß,5
-THP, 33 pg
for 3
,5
-THP, and 20 pg for the others.
Because pregnenolone eluted exactly with 3ß,5
-THP and cross-
reacted 6% as strongly, it was determined separately by an RIA
that did not cross-react with the other steroids, and the value for
3ß,5
-THP was corrected accordingly (9).
Mean values for depressed (or blues) and control groups were compared using t test, or, where the standard deviations differed significantly, the Mann-Whitney nonparametric test or Welchs approximation.
Results
Figure 1
shows a typical pattern
obtained at 32 wk gestation. All of the metabolites measured eluted
before progesterone. In addition to the seven steroids listed above, we
found in all samples cross-reactive material eluting before 5
-DHP,
which also rose during pregnancy. This was resolved into at least eight
peaks. When summed as progesterone equivalents, their total averaged
about 12% that of progesterone in the luteal phase of the menstrual
cycle, 9% in early pregnancy, 7% at 2628 wk, 6% at 3638 wk, but
relatively more (200500%) in women in the follicular phase, and by 2
wk postpartum. There was also a small unidentified peak consistently
detectable immediately following the 5
-DHP peak, which is just
visible in the graph. This peak was also relatively larger in
nonpregnant subjects.
|
-DHP, which rose from
about 1.5 nmol/liter to 29 nmol/liter, an approximately 20-fold rise.
5ß-DHP rose from luteal values of about 0.5 nmol/liter to 2.9
nmol/liter, 3ß,5ß-THP from 0.4 nmol/liter to 2.2 nmol/liter,
5
,3
-THP from 2.4 nmol/liter to 14 nmol/liter, and 3ß,5
-THP
from 0.5 nmol/liter to 5 nmol/liter-all 5- to 10-fold. Expressed as
change from follicular levels, progesterone rose 562-fold, 5
-DHP
161-fold, 3ß,5
THP 56-fold, 3
,5
-THP 37-fold, pregnenolone
30-fold, and 5ß-DHP and 3ß,5ß-THP 16-fold, by 37 wk of gestation.
The unidentified material rose 27-fold.
|
|
0.0070.03) compared with follicular levels. By
7 wk, the levels were not significantly different from follicular
control levels, save for 3ß,5ß-THP (P = 0.007) and
3
,5
-THP (P = 0.012), which, although lower than
at 2 wk postpartum, remained elevated, as did the unidentified
material. Among all the women studied, 7% met criteria for depression during pregnancy and the depression persisted postpartum in 4%; 25% experienced symptoms of "blues" as defined here during the week following delivery, while 7%, who were not depressed during pregnancy, developed postpartum depression.
Figure 3
compares the results for
depressed and control subjects for samples taken at 2628 wk and at
3638 wk gestation. Four of the mean values for the metabolites at
2628 wk were higher in the depressed group than those in the control
group, but only that for 5
-DHP reached significance
(P = 0.04). At 3638 wk gestation, mean values again
tended to be higher in the depressed group, but again only the
difference for 5
-DHP was significant (P = 0.02).
Values for two of the depressed patients (depressed at both ages) and
three of the controls (not depressed at both ages) were obtained at
both 27 and 37 wk gestation. The combined data, calculated as % mean
control value, and taking the mean value at the two gestational ages
for each patient studied more than once, gives a level of significance
for 5
-DHP of P = 0.004 for the 13 depressed
patients, and 18 controls (or, if log transformed, P =
0.003).
|
Discussion
We have studied only five of about 20 NARS that may be pertinent
(see Fig. 4
). The NARS measured here were
chosen for technical reasons, but it is potentially important and
feasible to measure all of them. Because desoxycorticosterone
levels rise in pregnancy, though to a lesser extent than progesterone
(16), one would expect that its NARS also rise.
|
In this study, the material that eluted very early on HPLC consisted of at least eight peaks, which although still not definitively identified, are probably lipoidal in naturelikely fatty acid esters of progesterone metabolites conjugated at the C3 position. This seems reasonable because these peaks 1) cross-react with our antibody, 2) rise through pregnancy, 3) are very nonpolar, and 4) appear to correspond to material eluted early when progesterone is metabolized by lymphocytes (18). Because our antibody was raised to a C3-linked antigen, the progesterone metabolites measured here with the addition of a fatty acid at the C3 position would be expected to cross-react. Such lipoidal steroids or "liposteroids" have been identified in bovine corpora lutea (19). This material expressed as progesterone equivalents is relatively large, amounting in late pregnancy to about 6% of the progesterone level, but to 200500% of the progesterone level in follicular phase plasma. Similar amounts were seen in plasma of men and postmenopausal women (Murphy, B. E. P., and C. M. Allison, unpublished observations). Because the same compounds occur in men, and the testis produces very little progesterone, the main sources are probably adrenal and brain. Lipoidal derivatives of pregnenolone and some of its derivatives, including allopregnanolone, have been isolated from bovine corpora lutea (19, 20), and lipoidal derivatives of E2 have been found in human breast cancer cells (21). There is evidence that the C17 fatty acid esters of E2 are long-acting estrogens (22). The persistence of increased levels of all the free metabolites by 2 wk postpartum could be due to longer half-lives, slow breakdown of lipoidal compounds (which, however, also remained elevated), or to increased synthesis.
Our levels of 5
-DHP both in nonpregnant and pregnant subjects are
lowerabout 1/3of those found by others, probably due to the greater
precision of high performance liquid chromatography in separating
steroids that interfere with the RIA, as discussed previously
(9). During pregnancy, Parker et al.
(23) reported that levels of 5
-DHP rose to 1/7 those of
progesterone from 1215 wk gestation, whereas at 3541 wk, the ratio
had risen to 1/5values of 40 ± 20 ng/ml (111 nmol/liter).
Dombroski et al. (24) showed that the high
levels of 5
-DHP were attributable to high rates of production rather
than to low rates of clearance, and that about 70% of 5
-DHP is
cleared in extrahepatic tissues. Löfgren et al.
(25) found that 5
-DHP fell before the onset of labor
but were unable to relate this change to inhibition of uterine
contractions (26).
Here we have shown that levels of 5
-DHP are elevated even more in
previously healthy women who become significantly depressed for the
first time during pregnancy. So far as we have been able to learn,
there has been no previous investigation of this steroid in the
depression of pregnant or nonpregnant subjects. During pregnancy, the
prevalence of depression is 416% (27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32), whereas that
postpartum is 1028% (28, 33, 34, 35). In addition, about
1/4 suffer from the blues in the first 10 d following parturition
(33), data similar to those obtained in this study.
No values for 5ß-DHP were found in the literature. While both
5
-DHP and 5ß-DHP given as a highly concentrated bolus produce
anesthesia, 5ß-DHP is considerably more potent, while 5
-DHP can
cause convulsions (2). We showed that, at what were
estimated to be physiological levels in rats, 5
-DHP increased motor
activity, whereas 5ß-DHP decreased it (36). Thus, these
steroids, while differing only by the position of a single hydrogen,
can have very different effects at low doses.
We were also unable to find any data at all for plasma levels of 3ß,5ß-THP.
Our levels of 3
,5
-THP (follicular 0.36 ± 0.24
nmol/liter rising to about 2.4 nmol/liter in the luteal phase) are in
keeping with those found initially by Purdy et al.
(37) using HPLC and RIA as here. More recent data by
Genazzani et al. (38), omitting the HPLC step,
gave higher mean follicular levels of 0.79 ± 0.30
SEM nmol/liter, rising 5-fold to 3.69 ±
0.96 SEM nmol/liter in the luteal phase.
Recently, this group (Luisi et al.) (39), again
omitting HPLC, reported levels in pregnancy that rose to about 50 ng/ml
(158 nmol/liter) i.e. about 10 times higher than our values.
We suspect that their values were influenced by a number of other
cross-reacting steroids, including progesterone, because they did not
validate their method for pregnancy, but relied entirely on
cross-reactivity data (40, 41). This same group
(42) recently found low levels of 3
,5
-THP in 18
women experiencing "blues" sampled on d 3 postpartum, compared with
22 controls (1.1 ± 0.5 vs. 2.3 ± 1.0 nmol/liter;
P
0.001). Our data were too scattered (over 27 d
when levels were falling rapidly) to show any significant differences.
However, we did find that the metabolite levels remained above
nonpregnant levels during the early puerperium and 3
,5
-THP as
well as 3ß,5ß-THP levels remained elevated even at 6 wk postpartum.
Because 3
,5
-THP is anxiolytic, these higher levels may act to
help women deal with the increased demands on time and effort in this
usually stressful period.
We found only one paper in the literature in which 3ß,5
-THP was
measured in human plasma. Using gas chromatography/mass spectrometry,
Romeo et al. (43) found levels of 3ß,5
-THP
of about 0.2 nmol/liter in 8 healthy male control subjects, values
similar to those found by us (9). They found that the mean
combined level in eight depressed male outpatients during a major
unipolar depressive episode (0.6 nmol/liter) fell during fluoxetine
treatment (to 0.2 nmol/liter, P
0.05), whereas those
of 3
,5
-THP rose from 2 to 5 nmol/liter (P
0.05). A second study by the same group (43) showed the
same trends but data for men and women were combined. No differences in
progesterone levels were observed. Although 3
,5
-THP is clearly a
positive allosteric modulator of the GABAA
receptor, 3ß,5
-THP may act as a functional antagonist.
The etiology of the depression occurring during pregnancy is still
unclear. Our data strongly suggest that 3ß,5
-THP may be involved.
Buckwalter et al. (45), in a study of 15 women
in the last month of pregnancy, found that higher levels of
progesterone were associated with greater mood disturbances, and higher
levels of DHEA with better mood. DHEA was not
measured here, but the mean progesterone levels in the depressed groups
were higher than those of the controls, but this difference failed to
reach significance. OHara et al. (46) found
lower levels of E2 in depressed subjects at wk 36 of gestation.
Cognitive deficits (particularly deficit in verbal memory) observed by
Buckwalter et al. (45) during pregnancy,
in comparison to performance postpartum, were independent from the
mood disturbances occurring during pregnancy.
The mood changes following parturition remain poorly understood. Blues have been associated with higher testosterone levels (45), lower DHEA levels (45), lower E2 levels (46), and reduced catecholamines (47), whereas postpartum depression has been attributed to low E2 levels (48).
According to the data obtained by Freeman et al.
(49), levels of pregnanolones (combined 3
,5
-THP +
3
,5ß-THP) above 96 nmol/liter are associated with fatigue,
delayed verbal recall, and symbol copying. Thus the levels of
3
,5
-THP obtained by Luisi et al. (158 nmol/liter)
(38) in late pregnancy would be expected to be associated
with symptoms. Because only 3
,5
THP was measured, and high
levels of 3
,5ß-THP as well as the other anesthetic metabolites of
progesterone which may have similar effects, including 5ß-DHP as
found here, would also be expected to be elevated in pregnancy, these
would be levels which, if correct, would be expected to cause serious
alterations of functioning in virtually all pregnant women near term.
We think it more likely that the lower amounts of the steroids measured
here, when combined together with the other neuroactive progesterone
metabolites, including those of desoxycorticosterone that also
rises in pregnancy (16) and gives rise to NARS, do affect
cognition and mood to the usually minor extent seen in many pregnant
women, and occasionally to a disabling extent. These relatively high
levels may act to provide some analgesia during the pain of labor and
contribute to the tendency of most women to forget its intensity once
it is over.
Acknowledgments
Footnotes
This work was supported in part by the Fonds de Recherches Scientifiques du Québec, the Stairs Memorial Foundation, and the National Alliance for Research in Depression and Schizophrenia (NARSAD).
Abbreviations: DHP, Dihydroprogesterone; GABA,
-aminobutyric
acid; Ham-D, Hamilton Depression Scale; NARS, neuroactive A-ring
reduced steroids; THP, tetrahydroprogesterone.
Received October 26, 2000.
Accepted August 27, 2001.
References
-dihydroxy-5-pregnen-20-one
and 3ß-hydroxy-5-androsten-17-one. J Steroid Biochem 11:13331340[CrossRef][Medline]
-dihydroprogesterone
(5
-pregnane-3,20-dione) in women and men. J Clin Endocrinol
Metab 77:944948[Abstract]
- dihydroprogesterone during
labor and early postpartum. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand 69:123126[Medline]
-reduced
progestins, 5
-pregnane-3,20-dione and 5
-pregnane-3
-ol-20-one,
on contracting human myometrium at term. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand 71:2833[Medline]
- and 5ß-pregnane-3,20-dione on the motor
activity of ovariectomized rats. J Steroid Biochem 26: 577580
-hydroxy-5
-pregnan-20-one in rat and human plasma. Steroids 55:290296[CrossRef][Medline]
-reduced neuroactive steroids and their precursors in plasma of
patients with major depression and after clinical recovery. Biol
Psychiatry 45:27j4277
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. Kancheva, M. Hill, D. Cibula, H. Vcelakova, L. Kancheva, J. Vrbikova, T. Fait, A. Parizek, and L. Starka Relationships of circulating pregnanolone isomers and their polar conjugates to the status of sex, menstrual cycle, and pregnancy J. Endocrinol., October 1, 2007; 195(1): 67 - 78. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. A. Hagedorn, C.-L. Cooke, J. R. Falck, B. F. Mitchell, and S. T. Davidge Regulation of Vascular Tone During Pregnancy: A Novel Role for the Pregnane X Receptor Hypertension, February 1, 2007; 49(2): 328 - 333. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. M. Sheehan, G. E. Rice, E. K. Moses, and S. P. Brennecke 5{beta}-Dihydroprogesterone and steroid 5{beta}-reductase decrease in association with human parturition at term Mol. Hum. Reprod., July 1, 2005; 11(7): 495 - 501. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Parizek, M. Hill, R. Kancheva, H. Havlikova, L. Kancheva, J. Cindr, A. Paskova, V. Pouzar, I. Cerny, P. Drbohlav, et al. Neuroactive Pregnanolone Isomers during Pregnancy J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., January 1, 2005; 90(1): 395 - 403. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |