| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Endocrinological Oncology |
Departments of Endocrinology (J.J.M., N.I., G.K., P.J.T., J.P.M., G.M.B., A.B.G.), Pathology (D.G.L.), Radiology (M.C.), and Neurosurgery (F.A.), St. Bartholomews Hospital, London EC1A 7BE, United Kingdom
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Professor A. B. Grossman, Department of Endocrinology, St. Bartholomews Hospital, West Smithfield, London EC1A 7BE, United Kingdom.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Apparent recurrence of Rathkes cleft cysts after initially successful surgery in our series was higher than suggested by previous reports, and thus, long-term follow-up with pituitary imaging and neuroophthalmological assessment is essential. There are no specific characteristics of the cyst that predict recurrence. Ideal management of these cysts is unclear, but aspiration, followed by extensive excision of the cyst wall when possible, seems to be the best initial option. For recurrent symptomatic tumors, surgical resection is the treatment of choice. Considering the high recurrence rate with residual structural and functional dysfunction, the role of radiotherapy in preventing recurrence of these cysts needs careful evaluation with a larger study with a longer follow-up period.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Subjects and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Pituitary imaging was available for review in 8 out of 12 patients; in 2 patients (nos. 1 and 12), the original computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) films could not be obtained, and in a further 2 patients (nos. 2 and 11), the preoperative films were not available for review. We relied on the original radiologists report in these 4 patients. Pituitary imaging included contrast-enhanced CT scans in 5 patients, gadolinium-enhanced MR scans in 3 patients, and both types of scan in 4. Four patients (nos. 4, 7, 10, and 11) were noted to have a reaccumulation of the cyst, 3 of whom were reoperated. Of these 3 patients, 2 had a preoperative gadolinium-enhanced MR scan and 1 a contrast-enhanced CT scan. All MR scans were T1-weighted sequences, except in 2 patients (nos. 3 and 12), who also had T2-weighted sequences.
Endocrine evaluation was carried out using standardized basal and dynamic stimulation tests, as previously published (18).
Ten patients underwent transsphenoidal surgery and 2 had transfrontal craniotomy at first presentation. Of the 3 patients reoperated for recurrence, 2 had transsphenoidal and 1 had transcranial surgery. The histology from 10 patients was available for review, including all 3 patients with a recurrence who were reoperated; in the remaining 2 patients (nos. 2 and 11), we had to rely on the original report of the histopathologist from the referring institution.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Nine patients presented with relevant symptoms, whereas in 3 (nos. 5, 6, and 7), the lesions were found coincidentally during a CT scan of the brain for other disorders. Of the 9 symptomatic patients, 4 presented with visual symptoms and 4 with headaches; another patient presented with visual symptoms plus nausea and vomiting. Seven patients had bitemporal hemianopias, and 1 had a bitemporal upper quadrantinopia. The median duration of symptoms at presentation was 12 months (range 324 months). The median duration of follow-up was 30 months (range 1168 months).
|
One patient (no. 11) had high serum PRL levels and complained of galactorrhea and amenorrhea. Three patients (nos. 2, 9, and 12) were panhypopituitary, and two (nos. 2 and 9) had diabetes insipidus at presentation. Patient no. 6 had pituitary-dependent Cushings syndrome, which was subsequently confirmed histologically. In the four patients with recurrent disease, only one (no. 4) had developed a further hormonal defect, that of gonadotropin deficiency.
|
The cysts varied in size from 6 mm to 50 mm. One was located entirely in the suprasellar region, two were entirely intrasellar, and nine were intrasellar with suprasellar extensions. Of the eight CT scans reviewed, the cyst was isodense to the grey matter of the brain in three, of low density in two, of high density in one, and of mixed density (low and isodense) in one. One of the lesions showed patchy calcification. Postcontrast CT scans showed rim enhancement with a small superior nodule in two lesions, two showed peripheral enhancement, in two there was patchy enhancement, and in one there was no enhancement.
Of the five MR scans (T1-weighted) reviewed, the lesion was of low signal intensity in two patients, isointense in two, and of high signal intensity in one. In four patients, there was rim enhancement noted post-gadolinium, whereas there was no enhancement in patient no. 12. Two scans were T2-weighted, and the cyst was recorded to be of high intensity on both these studies.
In the four recurrent tumors, the cyst size varied at representation from 11 to 28 mm. Two of the cysts were intrasellar, and the other two both were intra- and suprasellar. One patient had a CT scan of the pituitary fossa, whereas the other three had an MRI. The lesion was of mixed density with patchy calcification and enhancement on the CT study. Two of the three T1-weighted MRI studies were available for review; in one the lesion was of low signal intensity, and in the other it was isointense. Both had peripheral enhancement post gadolinium.
Ten patients underwent transsphenoidal surgery, whereas two had transfrontal craniotomy at first presentation. Three of the four patients with a recurrence were reoperated; one patient with a previous transcranial approach had transsphenoidal surgery, the second had a repeat transcranial approach, whereas the third patient had a repeat transsphenoidal approach. The cyst contents were drained, and a biopsy of a portion of the cyst wall was obtained, where possible without causing destruction of surrounding structures.
|
Cyst fluid ß-hCG measurements were performed in three patients, two with a recurrence. Patient no. 12 had undetectable levels (<50 IU/L). Patient no. 4, on first presentation, had a cyst fluid ß-hCG of 187 IU/L; but on recurrence, this was undetectable. Patient no. 10 had detectable cyst fluid ß-hCG at first presentation and, on recurrence, had levels of more than 100 IU/L (no further dilutions were done). Patient no. 1 had undetectable CSF ß-hCG.
There were no perioperative complications. Post operatively, transient diabetes insipidus was noted following 9 of the 12 transsphenoidal approaches and 1 out of 3 transcranial approaches.
A definite diagnosis of Rathkes cleft cyst was possible in
eight patients (Table 3
). In the remaining four patients (nos. 2, 6, 7,
and 9), the diagnosis of Rathkes cleft cyst is presumptive. In two
patients (nos. 2 and 6), the original pathology report identified a
Rathkes cleft cyst, although the actual histology was not available
to us for review. In patient no. 7, no epithelial lining could be
detected, and the diagnosis of Rathkes cleft cyst was made on the
basis of the radiological findings and the peroperative appearance of a
soft structureless lesion. In patient no. 9, a small amount of
epithelial lining was included in the biopsy specimen that was
cuboidal, thereby suggesting a Rathkes cleft cyst.
Details of patients with recurrent cysts
Patient no. 4. The patient presented with blurred vision and bitemporal hemianopia. Pituitary imaging revealed a 35-mm cystic lesion. At surgery, 8 mL clear fluid was aspirated, followed by partial excision of the cyst wall, and histology showed cuboidal epithelium. The patient presented 4 yr later with headaches and deterioration of visual fields. A 22-mm cystic mass was seen; and at surgery, 15 mL clear fluid was aspirated, followed by resection of the cyst wall. Pituitary radiotherapy (4500 cGy in 25 fractions over 35 days) was given. There has been no change in the size of the cyst on follow-up MR scans over 1 yr. This patient also had a cystic pineal lesion that measured 1220 mm over 5 yr.
Patient no. 7. This patient was found to have a 13-mm cystic lesion, which was removed, but no epithelial lining was detected on histology, whereas a postoperative MR scan showed resolution of the lesion; a further scan, 4 yr later, showed an 11-mm intrasellar lesion. Because she was asymptomatic and the recurrence was intrasellar, it was followed with yearly MR scans; there has been no change in size over 2 yr.
Patient no. 10. This patient presented with blurred vision and bitemporal hemianopia. On imaging, a 40-mm cyst with patchy calcification was seen, which was evacuated and its wall partially excised. Histology showed ciliated columnar and stratified squamous epithelium. A postoperative scan showed considerable reduction in the size of the cyst, but she represented, 3 months later, with decreased acuity and optic atrophy in the right eye. On imaging, a 28-mm cystic lesion was seen, from which clear CSF-like fluid was aspirated after partial excision of its wall. Pituitary radiotherapy was given, and MR scanning, a year later, showed no change in the size of the cyst.
Patient 11. This patient presented with headache, galactorrhea, and oligomenorrhea. Serum PRL was elevated, and an MR scan revealed a 25-mm cystic lesion; at surgery, chocolate-colored fluid was aspirated, and the semisolid components were evacuated. Histology showed flattened cuboidal cells. She represented, 5 months later, with headaches and an elevated serum PRL. MR scan of the pituitary showed a 12.5-mm cystic lesion. At surgery, the cyst was aspirated again and its wall partially excised. Histology showed ciliated columnar epithelium, and a postoperative MR scan confirmed the complete removal of the cyst. Follow-up CT scans, over 2 yr, have not shown any further reaccumulation of cyst fluid.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
There have been numerous attempts to define the features of a Rathkes cleft cyst on pituitary imaging. The cyst density on CT scanning and cyst intensity on MRI imaging have been variably reported to range from hypo- to iso- to mixed intensity (5, 33). Calcification, said to be characteristically absent from Rathkes cleft cysts, also has been seen in isolated cases (4, 34). Lack of postcontrast enhancement on MRI has been suggested by some to be the hallmark of these cysts (5), but patchy or ring enhancement post-gadolinium injection also has been reported (16). We were unable to identify any characteristic features, on imaging with either CT or MRI, which distinguished a Rathkes cleft cyst from either a pituitary adenoma or a craniopharyngioma. At surgery, these lesions have been variably noted to have a cystic to semisolid consistency, and the cyst contents have been described from clear CSF-like to milky-white, brown, machine oil-like, and engine oil-like (5, 35). Cholesterol crystals within the cyst fluid has been documented (36), as are cysts with solid components (3, 5, 19, 33, 37).
Recurrence of Rathkes cleft cysts is said to be very rare. A review of the literature revealed only 7 well-documented recurrences of Rathkes cleft cysts (34, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16). In contrast, the recurrence rate in our group of patients is much higher: 4 out of 12 patients had a recurrence, 3 of whom were symptomatic and required reexploration. It has been suggested that the presence of a solid lesion within the cyst, consisting of stratified squamous epithelium, increases the risk of a recurrence (3, 13, 14). However, recurrence of cysts lined by a single layer of cuboidal or columnar epithelium also has been reported (12, 15, 16). Of the 4 recurrences in our series, 2 were lined by a single layer of cuboidal epithelium, and 1 had a focus of stratified squamous epithelium. One of our recurrences had clear cyst fluid, whereas 1 had a solid component. Thus, we could not identify any definite cyst fluid or histopathological characteristic that might predict an increased risk of recurrence. However, because complete surgical removal was not attempted in many cases, it may be more appropriate to consider such recurrences as cyst fluid reaccumulation, at least in some instances.
The reason for a higher recurrence rate in our series is unclear. It is possible that the true incidence of recurrence in Rathkes cleft cysts is higher than previously reported. As suggested by Fager and Carter (38), there has always been a confusion in the diagnosis between Rathkes cleft cysts and craniopharyngiomas, which may contain overlapping histological features, and it is possible that many Rathkes cleft cysts are misdiagnosed as craniopharyngiomas, more so in the case of a recurrence (39). An elevated level of immunoreactive ß-HCG in the cyst fluid of patients of craniopharyngioma has been reported (40, 41). One of our patients (no. 12) had undetectable ß-HCG levels in the cyst fluid. However, of the two recurrences, in the one lined by pure cuboidal epithelium, cyst fluid ß-HCG was detectable at first presentation but undetectable at recurrence; whereas in the second, with a focus of squamous epithelium, cyst fluid ß-HCG seemed to increase. Thus, it would seem that cyst fluid ß-HCG was also not discriminatory between the simple single-layered Rathkes cyst and the one with a focus of squamous epithelium, and also between Rathkes cysts and craniopharyngiomas.
In summary, we present the clinical, radiological, surgical, and histopathological features of eight definite and four probable cases of Rathkes cleft cysts. Clinical, endocrine and radiological characteristics were highly variable and were rarely helpful in identifying such lesions. We believe that long-term follow-up with periodic MRI and neuroophthalmological assessment is hence necessary in all cases. We recommend that a postoperative MR scan should be performed to assess the extent of removal of the cyst, with further scans at 6 and 12 months and then at intervals for at least 5 yr. The optimal therapy for a recurrent symptomatic cyst is unclear, but transsphenoidal aspiration and, where possible, extensive removal of the cyst wall are most appropriate; we have adopted a regimen whereby repeat surgery is followed by external beam pituitary radiotherapy, although the role of radiotherapy in preventing further recurrence at present is unclear. Rathkes cleft cysts seem to be more prone to cyst fluid reaccumulation and recurrence than previously recognized.
Received December 16, 1996.
Accepted March 19, 1997.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
G. A Kaltsas, J. Evanson, A. Chrisoulidou, and A. B Grossman The diagnosis and management of parasellar tumours of the pituitary Endocr. Relat. Cancer, December 1, 2008; 15(4): 885 - 903. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
F. Bonneville, J. Chiras, F. Cattin, and J.-F. Bonneville T2 Hypointense Signal of Rathke Cleft Cyst AJNR Am. J. Neuroradiol., March 1, 2007; 28(3): 397 - 397. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Megdiche-Bazarbacha, K. Ben Hammouda, A.B. Aicha, R. Sebai, L. Belghith, M. Khaldi, and S. Touibi Intrasphenoidal rathke cleft cyst. AJNR Am. J. Neuroradiol., May 1, 2006; 27(5): 1098 - 1100. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. L. Shin, S. L. Asa, L. J. Woodhouse, H. S. Smyth, and S. Ezzat Cystic Lesions of the Pituitary: Clinicopathological Features Distinguishing Craniopharyngioma, Rathke's Cleft Cyst, and Arachnoid Cyst J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., November 1, 1999; 84(11): 3972 - 3982. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |