| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Pediatric Endocrinology |
Department of Pediatrics, Sections of Endocrinology and Diabetology (R.R.S., A.H., O.H.P.) and Hematology-Oncology (R.I.J., M.W.L.), James Whitcomb Riley Hospital for Children, Indiana University Medical Center, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202-5225
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Ora H. Pescovitz, M.D., Departments of Pediatrics, Physiology, and Biophysics, Riley Hospital for Children, Room 5984, 702 Barnhill Drive, Indianapolis, Indiana 46202-5225. E-mail: ora_pescovitz{at}iucc.iupui.edu
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Twenty-two children who had undergone treatment for brain or skull-based tumors were enrolled in a prospective study to extensively evaluate the HPA axis. Five tests of the adrenal axis were evaluated in each patient, including determination of basal serum cortisol, a standard ACTH test (250-µg iv bolus), a low dose ACTH test (0.2 µg/kg iv bolus), an insulin tolerance test, and a single dose metyrapone test.
Cortisol responses to both ACTH tests were nearly identical. Two patients (9%) failed the low dose ACTH test, whereas three (14%) failed the standard ACTH test; five of the children (23%) failed the insulin tolerance test, and five (23%) had abnormal responses to metyrapone. One child who initially passed the metyrapone test failed the test 19 months later after becoming symptomatic. All children with abnormal metyrapone test results had low levels of basal cortisol secretion.
In this study, the low dose ACTH test did not improve the sensitivity of ACTH testing for evaluation of the HPA axis. We conclude that a single morning basal cortisol level is a good screen for testing the HPA axis in children. We recommend confirming HPA axis dysfunction with the single dose metyrapone test, although this test also has limitations.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Of the various stimulatory tests of the HPA axis, the ACTH stimulation test is the most commonly used. It is simple to perform and generally reproducible. In primary adrenal insufficiency, when the gland is completely destroyed or is incapable of responding to ACTH, this test is clearly valuable. Although it is counterintuitive to use ACTH as a stimulus to assess ACTH secretion, this procedure has been employed extensively in the past. The rationale for this lies in the belief that chronic ACTH deficiency will result in atrophy of the adrenal cortex and subsequent inability to secrete cortisol in response to a single ACTH bolus. The reliability of this method is suspect, however, because the test rarely identifies ACTH deficiency even in patients who have evidence of multiple other hypothalamic-pituitary axis abnormalities. We hypothesized that the standard ACTH test is insensitive, especially in children, because the dose of ACTH used is excessive. The levels of ACTH achieved after a bolus of 1 µg/kg are 10 times higher than those reached during insulin-induced hypoglycemia (18). A much lower dose of ACTH (0.2 µg/kg) has been reported to result in integrated serum ACTH levels that more closely approximate levels achieved during insulin tolerance testing (18).
We hypothesized that this lower dose of ACTH would be more sensitive than the standard ACTH test in detecting complete or partial ACTH deficiency, thus providing a simple, but sensitive and specific, test to evaluate the HPA axis. To test this hypothesis, we compared the low dose ACTH test with four other established tests of the HPA axis in children treated for brain or skull-based tumors.
| Subjects and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Twenty-two children who had undergone either surgical resection
and/or radiation therapy involving the hypothalamic-pituitary region
for a brain or skull-based tumor were enrolled (Table 1
). Eighteen subjects had received 3600 centigray units
or more to the hypothalamic-pituitary region as part of their
treatment, and 12 children had received chemotherapy. Radiotherapy was
completed 16167 months (mean, 48 months) before enrollment. Four
children underwent surgical resection without radiotherapy for tumors
of the pituitary gland a median of 11 months before the study (Table 1
). All subjects were documented to be euthyroid at the time of entry
into the study.
|
The protocol was approved by the institutional review board of the Indiana University Medical Center. After obtaining informed consent from the parent or legal guardian and assent from the child, the subjects were admitted to the General Clinical Research Center of the Indiana University Medical Center at 0700 h for the 2-day protocol. Five tests of the adrenal axis were evaluated in each patient, including determination of basal serum cortisol, low dose ACTH test (0.2 µg/kg iv bolus), standard ACTH test (250-µg iv bolus), insulin tolerance test (ITT), and a single dose metyrapone test. Interpretation of these tests as pass, fail, or invalid was based on published and/or Indiana University Medical Center laboratory standards. A pass for basal cortisol was a level of 248 nmol/L (9 µg/dL) or more; for the low dose ACTH test, it was a cortisol level of 496 nmol/L (18 µg/dL) or more; for the standard ACTH stimulation test, it was a cortisol level of 496 nmol/L (18 µg/dL) or more (19); for the ITT, it was a serum cortisol level of 496 nmol/L (18 µg/dL) or more (20). If the serum glucose values did not fall to 2.2 mmol/L (40 µg/dL) or less, the test was considered invalid. For the metyrapone test (21, 22), a compound S level of 115 nmol/L (4 µg/dL) or more was interpreted as indicative of a pass, and the test was considered invalid when the compound S level was < 115 nmol/L (4 µg/dL), but the serum cortisol level had been inadequately suppressed [cortisol level, >138 nmol/L (5 µg/dL)].
Determinations
Cortisol was measured by enzyme-linked immunoassay (Abbott Laboratories, North Chicago, CA) at the endocrine laboratory of the Indiana University Medical Center. The lower limit of detection was 27.6 nmol/L (1 µg/dL). At cortisol levels between 110-1100 nmol/L (4 and 40 µg/dL), the interassay coefficient of variance was 4.9%, and the intraassay coefficient of variance was 4.7%. Compound S (11-deoxycortisol) was determined in the carbon tetrachloride extract by competitive protein binding assay (Mayo Medical Laboratory, Rochester, MN). The lower limit of detection was 2.9 nmol/L (0.1 µg/dL). The average interassay coefficient of variance was 13% at a compound S level of 66.4 nmol/L (2.3 µg/dL).
Statistical analysis
Data are expressed as the mean ± SEM unless otherwise stated. The statistical analyses were performed using the Statview 4.0 package for Macintosh computers. Students t test was used to compare responses to the tests in children with pituitary and nonpituitary tumors. Linear regression analyses and ANOVA were used to correlate the results of the tests studied with the dose of radiation, the use of chemotherapeutic agents, and the individual diagnoses.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The peak cortisol response to the low dose ACTH test was not different from that to the standard ACTH test. In fact, the cortisol responses to the two ACTH tests were nearly identical in most patients. Linear regression analysis correlating the results of the two tests indicated an r2 of 0.92 (P < 0.0001).
Of the eight children with low basal serum cortisol levels, five failed the metyrapone test, and one had symptoms compatible with adrenal insufficiency. The mean basal serum cortisol levels of these five children was 78 ± 16.5 nmol/L (2.8 ± 0.6 µg/dL). Two of these subjects failed all of the other tests. Two of them failed the ITT [cortisol, 268 and 287 nmol/L (9.7 and 10.4 µg/dL), respectively], but had normal responses to both the low dose [cortisol, 557 and 723 nmol/L (20.2 and 26.2 µg/dL)] and standard [cortisol, 618 and 759 nmol/L (22.4 and 27.5 µg/dL)] ACTH tests. One child passed the ITT and low dose ACTH test, but failed the standard ACTH test. There was one child who failed the ITT and had a low basal cortisol level (138 nmol/L; 5.0 µg/dL), who unequivocally passed the metyrapone test [compound S, 232 nmol/L (8.0 µg/dL)], the low dose ACTH test [cortisol, 990 nmol/L (35.9 µg/dL)], and the standard ACTH test [cortisol, 943.5 nmol/L (34.2 µg/dL)]. These five children were all treated with glucocorticoid replacement therapy.
One child, who had initially passed the metyrapone test [compound S, 129 nmol/L (4.9 µg/dL)] as well as the other tests developed symptoms compatible with acute glucocorticoid insufficiency 19 months after the initial evaluation. A repeat single dose metyrapone test was indicative of HPA axis abnormality [cortisol, <27.6 nmol/L (1 mg/dL); compound S, 103 nmol/L (3.6 µg/dL)]. She was started on glucocorticoid replacement therapy and achieved prompt resolution of her symptoms.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The ACTH stimulation test is a very simple procedure, but its usefulness in assessing the HPA axis has not been definitively established (26, 27, 28). We hypothesized that the standard dose of ACTH might be excessive in most children and, therefore, would translate into a test with low sensitivity. We postulated that using a lower, more physiological dose of ACTH would improve the tests predictive value. The data generated in this study do not support this hypothesis because the cortisol responses to both ACTH doses were nearly identical.
Graybeal and Fang demonstrated that an ACTH dose of 0.2 µg/kg resulted in peak ACTH levels that were much higher than those seen during the ITT, even if the ACTH dynamics and area under the curve were close to those achieved after insulin-induced hypoglycemia (19). Thus, it is possible that the low dose ACTH test may still not be low enough. Recent observations confirm this. Broide et al. found that 16 of 46 patients treated with chronic inhaled corticosteroids had peak serum cortisol levels less than 18.1 µg/dL when stimulated with 0.5 µg/1.73 m2 ACTH, whereas all but one of these subjects were able to achieve peak serum cortisol levels of 18.1 µg/dL or more when a standard dose of ACTH (250 µg/1.73 m2) was used (29). Tordjman et al. compared the peak serum cortisol levels achieved after a challenge with 1 µg ACTH with those achieved after 250- and 5-µg boluses of ACTH (30). They found 100% sensitivity with the 1-µg test in identifying subjects with HPA axis dysfunction, but only 10% sensitivity with the 250-µg test.
The standard metyrapone test is a rather cumbersome test, in which the patient is required to ingest a dose of meytrapone every 4 h for 24 h before measuring compound S and cortisol levels. However, in a modification of this test, metyrapone is given once (between 2300 h and midnight), followed by the measurement of serum cortisol 8 h later (21). As this method appears to be as effective as the longer metyrapone test (31, 32, 33), we chose to use the simpler, single dose metyrapone test. It has been suggested that metyrapone testing identifies more children with secondary or tertiary adrenal insufficiency than the ITT (34, 35, 36) and may be particularly useful in detecting minor degrees of pituitary suppression that would be unrecognized by insulin-induced hypoglycemia (31, 32). Unlike the ITT, the single dose test is relatively easy to perform and carries little risk. The single most important drawback of the metyrapone test in our study was that a significant number of children (35%) experienced nausea and/or vomiting. This resulted in inadequate dosage delivery and, consequently, an invalid test in 18% of our subjects.
Despite this, the number of children with HPA axis abnormalities identified by the metyrapone test in our study is high and is similar to that reported by Constine et al. (10). Four of the five children who failed the metyrapone test had tumors of the pituitary gland, and the fifth had a visual pathway glioma treated with 6000 centigray units of radiation. In addition, these children had evidence of other hypothalamic-pituitary hormone dysfunction (hypothyroidism, n = 5; GH deficiency, n = 4; hypogonadotropic hypogonadism, n = 2; precocious puberty and diabetes insipidus, n = one each).
Some investigators have considered a normal response to ACTH to be a peak cortisol level of more than 552 nmol/L (20 µg/dL) rather than 496 nmol/L (18 µg/dL). Using these criteria, two children who passed the low dose ACTH test and one child who passed the standard ACTH test would be recategorized as failures. Even so, both ACTH tests would only allow identification of three of the five children who failed the metyrapone test. However, if the lower limits of normal cortisol response were increased to 688 nmol/L (25 µg/dL), the ACTH test would have identified four of the five who failed the metyrapone test. All of the children who passed the metyrapone test had peak cortisol levels of more than 688 nmol/L (25 µg/dL) in response to both ACTH tests.
Our study is not without flaws. Ideally, the five tests of the HPA axis should have been administered in random order. However, we chose to perform the high dose ACTH test in the morning and the low dose ACTH test in the afternoon because we reasoned that the higher dose of ACTH might deplete pituitary ACTH stores, thereby increasing the likelihood of failure to respond to the low dose test. The fact that there was nearly perfect correlation between the responses to the two tests supports the validity of the study design.
In summary, in this study, neither the low dose nor the standard
ACTH test was a useful diagnostic study because patients with evidence
of ACTH deficiency passed these tests. A recent publication in this
journal highlights the potential for serious consequences from
misinterpreting normal responses to ACTH testing, thus supporting this
position (37). Despite yielding a high number of invalid test results,
a single dose metyrapone challenge seems to be a very good test for
evaluating ACTH and CRH reserve. Until better diagnostic methods can be
designed, we suggest measuring basal serum cortisol as a screening test
for HPA axis dysfunction. For subjects with basal serum cortisol levels
below 248 nmol/L (9 µg/dL), a metyrapone test should be performed to
confirm HPA axis dysfunction. If the compound S level is 115 nmol/L (4
µg/dL) or more, the child can be classified as having a normal HPA
axis at the time of testing (Fig. 1
).
|
| Note Added in Proof |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received December 12, 1996.
Revised February 27, 1997.
Accepted March 6, 1997.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
K. H. Darzy and S. M. Shalet Absence of Adrenocorticotropin (ACTH) Neurosecretory Dysfunction but Increased Cortisol Concentrations and Production Rates in ACTH-Replete Adult Cancer Survivors after Cranial Irradiation for Nonpituitary Brain Tumors J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., September 1, 2005; 90(9): 5217 - 5225. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Schmiegelow, U. Feldt-Rasmussen, A. K. Rasmussen, M. Lange, H. S. Poulsen, and J. Muller Assessment of the Hypothalamo-Pituitary-Adrenal Axis in Patients Treated with Radiotherapy and Chemotherapy for Childhood Brain Tumor J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., July 1, 2003; 88(7): 3149 - 3154. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. W. Finkelstein, D. E. Rusovici, E. Green, S. Foreman, H. E. Kulin, M. R. D'Arcangelo, and R. Kemezys Children with Organic Growth Hormone Deficiency Have Elevated Cortisol Responses to Stimuli J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., June 1, 2001; 86(6): 2854 - 2856. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. Dickstein What Should Be Considered A Low Dose in the ACTH Stimulation Test? J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., October 1, 1997; 82(10): 3520 - 3520. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |