| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Original Studies |
Institute of Endocrinology (F.P., E.M., L.A., C.R., A.P.), University of Pisa, Pisa 56124, Italy; Institute of Radiation Medicine (T.V., E.S., E.K.) and Oncology-Pathology Department (E.D., E.C., Y.I.), State Medical University, Minsk 220600, Belarus; Medicina Nucleare (G.R., M.F.), Clinica Medica II, Università La Sapienza, Roma 00140, Italy; and Institute Gustave Roussy (M.S.), Villejuif 94805, France
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Furio Pacini, M.D., Istituto di Endocrinologia, Via Paradisa, 2, 56124 Pisa, Italy.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The epidemiological and clinical features of the disease were studied in 472 patients less than 21 yr old at diagnosis, with differentiated thyroid carcinoma, representing 97.7% of all thyroid carcinomas diagnosed in Belarus between May, 1986, and December, 1995. The results were compared with those of 369 subjects of the same age group, with naturally occurring thyroid carcinoma, observed in Italy and France.
Between 1986 and 1989, the number of thyroid cancer cases per year ranged from 38 and increased to 31 in 1990, to 66 in 1991, to 72 in 1992, to 93 in 1993, to 96 in 1994, and to 90 in 1995. The age at diagnosis was 14 yr or less in 78.8% (children group) and more than 14, but less than 21, yr in the remaining subjects (adolescents group). Mean (±SD) age at the time of the accident was 4.4 ± 3.4 yr (3.2 ± 2.3 in children and 8.9 ± 2.7 in adolescents), the majority of the patients (62.9%) being 5 yr old or less. The time interval between the accident and the diagnosis (latency period) decreased progressively from 7.5 ± 1.6 yr in children 02 yr old at the time of the accident to 6.0 ± 1.6 yr in those 911 yr old. Since 1993, the yearly distribution of new cases showed a decrease in the subjects 9 yr old or more at the time of the accident but not in those 5 yr old or less. This could not be accounted for by a shift of exposed subjects to an age group at diagnosis not included in this study, because only subjects less than 12 yr of age at the time of the accident were considered in this analysis. Mean age at diagnosis in Belarus patients was 11.3 ± 3.1 yr (10.1 ± 2.3 in children and 15.7 ± 1.4 in adolescents), whereas, among patients with naturally-occurring thyroid carcinomas from Italy and France, the majority of cases were diagnosed after 14 yr of age (mean age at diagnosis: 14.6 ± 4.2 yr). The female-to-male ratio was significantly higher in Italy and France (2.5/1), compared with the ratio of patients from Belarus (1.6/1). Most of the tumors were papillary in both series, but a relatively high proportion of follicular carcinomas (P = 0.0001) was found in Italy/France (15.2%), as opposed to 5.3% in Belarus. Extrathyroidal extension and lymph node metastases were more frequent in Belarus (49.1%, P = 0.0001; and 64.6%, P = 0.002, respectively) with respect to Italy/France (24.9% and 53.9%, respectively). Thyroid lymphocytic infiltration and circulating antithyroperoxidase antibody were more frequent in Belarus patients.
Our analysis of Belarus thyroid cancer patients less than 21 yr old showed that the post-Chernobyl increase in thyroid carcinomas involved both children and, to a much lesser extent, adolescents. Subjects 5 yr old or less at the time of the accident accounted for the majority of the patients. No evidence of a decrease in the number of new cases was observed in this age group, as opposed to older subjects. These data support the concept that subjects who were younger at the time of radiation exposure had, and continue to have, a greater risk of developing thyroid carcinoma and strongly suggest that this age group should be carefully monitored in the future. When compared with naturally occurring thyroid carcinoma of the same age group observed in Italy and France, the post-Chernobyl Belarus thyroid carcinomas affected younger subjects, were less influenced by gender, were virtually always papillary, had a greater aggressiveness at presentation, and were more frequently associated with thyroid autoimmunity.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This outbreak of radiation-induced childhood thyroid carcinoma raises the question of whether it differs in its biological and clinical behavior, with respect to childhood thyroid cancer with no previous history of radiation exposure. Moreover, 10 yr after the accident, it remains to ascertain whether the increase in thyroid carcinoma will be limited to children or will extend to adolescents and young adults. To answer these questions, we studied the clinical and epidemiological features of thyroid carcinomas diagnosed in the Republic of Belarus, after the Chernobyl accident, from May, 1986, to December, 1995, both in children (age at diagnosis: <14 yr; n = 372) and in adolescents and young adults (age at diagnosis: >14 to <21 yr; n = 100), here referred to as adolescents. The clinical and epidemiological features of these patients were compared with those of 369 children and adolescents that, in the past 20 yr, received treatment for thyroid carcinoma in 2 centers in Italy (Pisa and Roma; n = 219) and one center in France (Villejuif; n = 150).
| Subjects and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Belarus patients.
The Belarus study group included 472
patients (288 females, 184 males) with thyroid carcinoma diagnosed when
they were less than 21 yr old. According to the official data of the
Belarus medical authorities, these represent 97.7% of all cases of
thyroid carcinoma registered in Belarus in that specific age group,
from May 1986 to December 1995. Patients were classified as children
(age <14 at diagnosis; n = 372) or adolescents (age at diagnosis
>14 and <21 yr; n = 100). With the exception of 2 children born
in 1988, all patients included in this study were already born, or were
in uterus (n = 9), at the time of the Chernobyl accident and were
living in regions of Belarus, to a variable extent, contaminated by
radioactive fallout. As indicated in previous reports (10), the number
of cases of thyroid carcinoma was grossly related to the degree of
radioactive contamination, more than half of the cases (51.9%) being
observed in the most exposed region of Gomel and less than 3% in the
least contaminated region of Vitebsk (Fig. 1
). In particular, 245 (205 children and
40 adolescents) were living in Gomel, 106 (82 children and 24
adolescents) in Brest, 58 (40 children and 18 adolescents) in Minsk, 28
(19 children and 9 adolescents) in Grodno, 24 (14 children and 10
adolescents) in Mogilev, and 11 (5 children and 6 adolescents) in
Vitebsk. Initial treatment of all patients was carried out in the
Thyroid Center of the Belarus Ministry of Health in Minsk and consisted
of total (or near-total) thyroidectomy in 173 patients, subtotal
thyroidectomy in 75, lobectomy in 217, and undetermined in 7.
|
Methods
A centralized data base, including all cases of thyroid cancer registered in Belarus, is located in Minsk. The data included in the present study refer to all registered cases of the concerned age groups, with no selection, except for 13 cases with insufficient information because of initial treatment outside Belarus. Cancer classification used by the Belarus pathologists was that recommended by WHO. Many cases have been revised, on several occasions, by Western European expert pathologists, who have confirmed the diagnosis in almost all cases (11). The clinical records of all patients were examined. The features, the age, and the sex distribution of the thyroid carcinomas observed in Belarus and in the centers of Italy and France were compared.
A moderate increase in thyroid cancer in adults, commonly recognized as the consequence of ascertainment bias, has been reported in Belarus. We have not considered the adults in this study, because of the difficulty in collecting reliable and verifiable data in this age group.
Statistical analysis was performed using the Students t
test,
2 test, and linear regression analysis, as
appropriate. The
2 test was always performed to compare
two qualitative variables in the two populations (Belarus
vs. Italy/France).
Antithyroperoxidase autoantibodies (anti-TPO) were measured by RIA (Sorin Biomedica Diagnostics, Saluggia, Italy; normal range: <10 U/mL); antithyroglobulin autoantibodies (anti-Tg) were measured by immunoradiometric assay (Biocode, Solessin, Belgium; normal range: 550 U/mL).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
As reported in Fig. 2
, the number of
thyroid cancers per year in Belarus ranged from 3 to 8 between 1986 and
1989. Then, a progressive increase was observed, continuing up to 1995:
31 cases in 1990, 66 in 1991, 72 in 1992, 93 in 1993, 96 in 1994, and
90 in 1995. The increase was observed mainly in children but also
occurred in adolescents, with a similar trend.
|
|
|
As shown in Fig. 5
, the age at diagnosis
progressively increased, in relation to the age at the accident. The
correlation coefficient was highly significant, both when all patients
were considered together (r = 0.84; P = 0.0001)
and when the two age groups were considered separately: r = 0.67,
P = 0.0001 in children and r = 0.68,
P = 0.0001 in adolescents. As shown in Fig. 6A
, a weak (but significant) negative
correlation was found between the latency period and the age at the
time of the accident, longer latency periods being observed in younger
subjects. To overcome the bias possibly deriving from the shift of the
subjects who were more than 11 yr old at the time of the accident to an
age group at the time of diagnosis not included in this study
(i.e.
21 yr), the data were further analyzed by excluding
subjects older than 11 yr at the time of the accident. As shown in Fig. 6B
, a weak negative correlation between latency period and age at
accident was found also after exclusion of these subjects. Mean latency
periods were 7.5 ± 1.6 yr, 7.2 ± 1.7 yr, 6.6 ± 1.8
yr, and 6.0 ± 1.6 yr for the age groups 02 yr, 35 yr, 68
yr, and 911 yr at the time of the accident, respectively. The slight
decrease observed was statistically significant (P =
0.0001).
|
|
|
In Belarus, 288 patients were females (227 children, 61 adolescents) and 184 were males (145 children, 39 adolescents), with a female to male (F/M) ratio of 1.6/1, with no difference between children and adolescents. In Italy and France, 266 patients were females (113 children, 153 adolescents) and 103 were males (45 children, 58 adolescents), with an F/M ratio of 2.5/1 (P < 0.0001), significantly higher with respect to Belarus patients; there was no difference in F/M ratio between children and adolescents.
The distribution of the cases in the control group from Italy and
France, according to the age at diagnosis, increased progressively with
the age, the majority (57.4%) of the patients being diagnosed after
the age of 14 yr. The mean age at diagnosis was 14.6 ± 4.2. In
contrast, in Belarus, most of the cases (87.9%) were diagnosed before
the age of 15 yr and the mean age was 11.3 ± 3.1 (Fig. 4
).
As shown in Table 1
, most
Belarus tumors (443 = 93.8%) were papillary (with or without a
follicular component), 25 were pure follicular (5.3%), 2 were
medullary (0.4%), 1 was Hurthle cell carcinoma (0.2%), and 1 was
undifferentiated carcinoma (0.2%).
|
2). Almost half (49.1%)
of the Belarus tumors extended outside the thyroid gland (188 children
and 44 adolescents). Lymph node involvement was present in 64.6% of
the cases (247 children and 58 adolescents), and distant metastases
were found in 7.8%. In the control group, tumors extending outside the
thyroid gland were much less (24.9%), lymph node involvement was
present in a slightly lower percentage (53.9%), both when considering
all cases and when considering only papillary thyroid carcinomas, and
distant metastases were found in 17.3%. It is worth noting that, with
a few exceptions, the Belarus patients were not submitted to 131-I
whole-body scan after thyroidectomy, and only lung metastases visible
by chest x-ray could be detected. In the control group, also distant
metastases (recognized shortly after surgery by 131-I whole-body scan)
were counted. Thus, the incidence of distant metastases was not
comparable in the 2 groups and were not statistically analyzed. When
considering only lung metastases detectable by chest x-ray, their
prevalence was similar in the groups (7.7% in Italy/France; 7.8% in
Belarus).
Autoimmune phenomena (Table 2
)
Lymphocytic infiltration was studied in 52 Belarus tumors and was present in 27 (51.9%) cases. The lymphocytic infiltration was diffuse and typical of chronic autoimmune thyroiditis in 5 cases and focal in the remaining 22 cases. This aspect was analyzed in 96 patients of the Italian series and 22.1% of cases were found to have lymphocytic infiltration (mostly focal).
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the present study, the clinical and epidemiological features of the thyroid carcinoma occurring in Belarus was studied and compared with the naturally occurring thyroid carcinoma observed in Italy and France. Previous reports (1, 2, 3, 4, 9, 10) on post-Chernobyl thyroid carcinoma focused on patients who were children at the time of diagnosis. The present study was extended to the thyroid carcinomas occurring in subjects more than 14, but less than 21, yr old when diagnosed, here referred to as adolescents.
Our data indicate that adolescents showed an increase of thyroid carcinoma similar to, although much less pronounced than, that observed in children. The distribution of the cases according to the year of diagnosis showed that the increase in children reached its peak in 1993, with a trend to a plateau in the following years. The question of whether this finding indicates that the epidemic of radiation-induced thyroid cancer is approaching its peak, rather than resulting from epidemiological bias caused by the shift of exposed subjects from childhood to the adult cohort, may be raised. As indicated above, we addressed this issue by including in our analysis subjects more than 14, but less than 21 yr old at the time of diagnosis, 618 yr old at the time of the accident. If the lack of a further increase of the number of thyroid carcinomas in children observed in the most recent years was caused by a shift of the exposed subjects from childhood to adolescence, one would expect a compensatory increase in the adolescents. This was not observed, supporting the concept that the epidemic might be in the process of approaching its peak.
It is worth noting that the trend to plateau in the outbreak of post-Chernobyl thyroid carcinoma suggested by the present study does not exclude the possibility of a second peak occurring in the next few decades and having a longer latency period, similar to that observed after external radiation to the head and neck (12, 13, 14, 15).
The distribution of the patients, with regard to the age at the time of the accident showed that the younger subjects (less than 5 yr old) accounted for the majority of the cases: 62.9% of all patients and 79.8% of the children. This is consistent with the notion that the thyroid gland of young children is more sensitive to the carcinogenic effects of radiation (16). However, the possibility that, to some extent, this could be caused by the variable time interval between exposure to radiation and observation among the different age groups should also be taken into account. To overcome this problem, we analyzed the yearly distribution of new cases by considering only subjects with an equal period of follow-up. The relative preponderance of children less than 5 yr old at the time of the accident was confirmed in each year of observation since 1990, further supporting the concept that the younger age groups were at greater risk. Interestingly, a trend to a decrease in the number of thyroid cancer cases was observed in the subjects who were 9 yr old or more at the time of the accident, with no new cases being observed in 1995. These data suggest that the risk of developing thyroid carcinoma in the next few years persists in the subjects exposed to radiation at a very young age, whereas it may decrease in the older age groups.
The most striking difference between the thyroid cancers observed in Belarus children and adolescents after the Chernobyl accident and the naturally-occurring cancers observed in the same age groups in Italy and France, was in the age distribution. The Belarus patients showed a distribution pattern resembling a Gaussian curve, with a peak at 10 yr, the large majority of the patients being diagnosed before or at the age of 14 yr. In contrast, the Western European series showed a progressive increase up to the age of 18 yr, the majority of the cases being diagnosed after the age of 14 yr. The difference is in keeping with the concept that the Belarus thyroid carcinoma outbreak was related to a single event, i.e. exposure to radiation action within a limited and defined period of time and having a greater carcinogenic effect in the younger age group.
In Belarus, as well as in Italy and France, females were more frequently affected than males, but the preponderance of females was much more pronounced in the Western European series. Similar findings have been found in the series from England and Wales (17). This suggests that the role of predisposing factors commonly associated to the female sex is less relevant in cases of radiation-induced thyroid tumors than in cases of naturally occurring thyroid carcinomas.
Papillary carcinomas accounted for most of the thyroid tumors found in both series, but the proportion of this histotype was clearly greater in Belarus than in the Western European centers, whereas the reverse was true for follicular carcinomas. The high prevalence of papillary carcinomas in the Belarus patients should not be regarded as surprising, because this histotype is found in virtually all patients developing thyroid carcinoma after external radiation to the head and neck regions (12, 13, 14, 15).
When compared with the Western European series, at histology the Belarus patients showed more frequent extrathyroidal extension of the tumor to the surrounding tissues. This and other histological evidence of a relatively greater aggressiveness of post-Chernobyl thyroid tumors, with regard to the naturally occurring papillary carcinomas, has been reported previously in other studies (18, 19). In both series, cervical lymph node metastases were documented at surgery in many cases, in keeping with the notion that these metastases are frequently present at the time of diagnosis in children and adolescents with thyroid cancer, and not infrequently are the clue leading to the recognition of the primary tumor. Admittedly, although significant, the difference in the prevalence of lymph node metastases in the Belarus and the Western European series was small and its significance, with regard to biological behavior of the tumor, remains to be established. The relatively higher prevalence of lymph node metastases found in the Belarus series is not caused by the lower frequency of follicular carcinomas, because it was still present when the comparison was limited to patients with papillary thyroid cancer. It is worth noting that the finding of lymph node metastases and of extrathyroidal extension of the tumor in a high proportion of cases provides strong support to the view that increased awareness did not play a major role in the detection of the post-Chernobyl thyroid cancer in Belarus.
Lymphocytic infiltration of the thyroid with the pattern of focal thyroiditis (in most cases) and of diffuse chronic thyroiditis (in some) was found in about half of the 52 Belarus patients in whom these changes could specifically be assessed. In a similar percentage of larger numbers of patients (n = 171), serum antibodies to thyroid peroxidase and (less frequently) to thyroglobulin were detected. These figures should be compared with the nearly 20% frequency of lymphocytic infiltration and humoral thyroid autoimmunity found in this and other Italian series (20). Unfortunately, it is impossible to have, as control, an unexposed group of Belarus thyroid cancer patients with measured antibodies. We have studied a population of children from an unexposed Belarus village (Braslav), apparently with no thyroid disease, in which the prevalence of serum antithyroid antibodies was 3% (unpublished observations), not different from that found in normal children of Italy (21). All together, these data suggest that thyroid autoimmune reactions may be related to radiation exposure. This interpretation is in keeping with the observation of thyroid autoimmune phenomena in several survivors of the atomic bomb explosions, as well as in subjects exposed to radiation fallout in the Marshall Islands (22, 23). Although preliminary (requiring confirmation in a larger population, including controls not affected by thyroid cancer), these data suggest that thyroid autoimmunity may be an additional and important consequence of the Chernobyl accident.
In conclusion, our analysis of Belarus thyroid cancer patients less than 21 yr old showed that the post-Chernobyl increase in thyroid carcinomas involved both children and, to a much lesser extent, adolescents. Subjects 5 yr old or less at the time of the accident accounted for the majority of the patients. Ten years after the accident, no evidence of a decrease in the number of new cases is observed in this age group, as opposed to older subjects. These data support the concept that subjects of younger age at radiation exposure had, and continues to have, a greater risk of developing thyroid carcinoma (24) and strongly suggest that this age group should be carefully monitored in the future. When compared with naturally occurring thyroid carcinoma of the same age group observed in Italy and France, the post-Chernobyl Belarus thyroid carcinomas affected younger subjects, were less influenced by gender, were virtually always papillary, had a greater aggressiveness at presentation, and were more frequently associated with thyroid autoimmunity.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received January 27, 1997.
Revised June 24, 1997.
Accepted July 18, 1997.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
H. Acun, G. Kemikler, and A. Karadeniz Dosimetric analysis of thyroid doses from total cranial irradiation Radiat Prot Dosimetry, March 1, 2007; 123(4): 498 - 504. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. C. Travis and M. G. Stabin 131I Ablation Treatment in Young Females After the Chernobyl Accident J. Nucl. Med., October 1, 2006; 47(10): 1723 - 1727. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. G. Saad, S. Kumar, E. Ron, J. H. Lubin, J. Stanek, K. E. Bove, and Y. E. Nikiforov Proliferative Activity of Human Thyroid Cells in Various Age Groups and Its Correlation with the Risk of Thyroid Cancer after Radiation Exposure J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., July 1, 2006; 91(7): 2672 - 2677. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M Niedziela Pathogenesis, diagnosis and management of thyroid nodules in children. Endocr. Relat. Cancer, June 1, 2006; 13(2): 427 - 453. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Hatch, E. Ron, A. Bouville, L. Zablotska, and G. Howe The Chernobyl Disaster: Cancer following the Accident at the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant Epidemiol. Rev., July 1, 2005; 27(1): 56 - 66. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Lyshchik, V. Drozd, Y. Demidchik, and C. Reiners Diagnosis of Thyroid Cancer in Children: Value of Gray-Scale and Power Doppler US Radiology, May 1, 2005; 235(2): 604 - 613. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Faggiano, J. Coulot, N. Bellon, M. Talbot, B. Caillou, M. Ricard, J.-M. Bidart, and M. Schlumberger Age-Dependent Variation of Follicular Size and Expression of Iodine Transporters in Human Thyroid Tissue J. Nucl. Med., February 1, 2004; 45(2): 232 - 237. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Elisei, C. Romei, T. Vorontsova, B. Cosci, V. Veremeychik, E. Kuchinskaya, F. Basolo, E. P. Demidchik, P. Miccoli, A. Pinchera, et al. RET/PTC Rearrangements in Thyroid Nodules: Studies in Irradiated and Not Irradiated, Malignant and Benign Thyroid Lesions in Children and Adults J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., July 1, 2001; 86(7): 3211 - 3216. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. M. Rabes, E. P. Demidchik, J. D. Sidorow, E. Lengfelder, C. Beimfohr, D. Hoelzel, and S. Klugbauer Pattern of Radiation-induced RET and NTRK1 Rearrangements in 191 Post-Chernobyl Papillary Thyroid Carcinomas: Biological, Phenotypic, and Clinical Implications Clin. Cancer Res., March 1, 2000; 6(3): 1093 - 1103. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
G. A. Thomas, H. Bunnell, H. A. Cook, E. D. Williams, A. Nerovnya, E. D. Cherstvoy, N. D. Tronko, T. I. Bogdanova, G. Chiappetta, G. Viglietto, et al. High Prevalence of RET/PTC Rearrangements in Ukrainian and Belarussian Post-Chernobyl Thyroid Papillary Carcinomas: A Strong Correlation between RET/PTC3 and the Solid-Follicular Variant J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., November 1, 1999; 84(11): 4232 - 4238. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| Endocrinology | Endocrine Reviews | J. Clin. End. & Metab. |
| Molecular Endocrinology | Recent Prog. Horm. Res. | All Endocrine Journals |