Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism, Vol 62, 117-121, Copyright © 1986 by Endocrine Society

ARTICLES

T lymphocyte subsets at various stages of hyperthyroid Graves' disease: effect of carbimazole treatment and relationship with thyroid- stimulating antibody levels or HLA status

AM Madec, H Allannic, N Genetet, M Gueguen, G Genetet, R Fauchet, A Stefanutti and J Orgiazzi

Markers of autoimmunity in hyperthyroid Graves' disease were studied at various stages of the disease in connection with HLA status. The 148 patients studied were included in a long term prospective evaluation of antithyroid drug treatment. The proportions of total T lymphocytes and OKT4 and OKT8 positive cells in peripheral blood and circulating thyroid-stimulating antibodies were determined before treatment (M0; 46 patients), after 6 (M6; 50 patients), and 18 months (M18; 22 patients) of carbimazole treatment, at relapse (15 patients) and after 2 yr of euthyroidism after drug withdrawal (remission; 23 patients). Twenty- seven patients were sequentially studied between M0 and M6, and M6 and M18. As compared to matched normal subjects, the mean proportion of OKT8 positive cells was significantly decreased in every group of patients, even in those in remission, and the mean OKT4/OKT8 cell ratios were increased in all groups except the patients in remission. However, OKT4/OKT8 cell ratios in individual M0 patients were widely distributed, being normal in 50%. No correlation was found between the proportions of T cell subsets and thyroid-stimulating antibody values, and the two measures varied independently in patients studied sequentially. OKT8 lymphocyte subset was dependent on HLA status. In DR3-positive patients, the mean OKT4/OKT8 cell ratio was high at all stages of the study; in DR3-negative patients it decreased significantly at M18 and was normal in those patients who had a remission. However, in the DR3-positive and -negative groups of patients, the mean OKT4/OKT8 ratios at M0 and at relapse were similar. In conclusion, the proportions of circulating OKT8 positive lymphocytes reflect only poorly the activity of the immune abnormalities in Graves' disease, but do correlate with HLA-DR3 status.